i think from all things, genisys let down because of the obvious casting error, and that there actually want really a story. it was too predictable and a bit of a mess.
there actually was potential for a story, and that was pops, how did he get there,
who sent him, and how were the more advanced terminators sent there in the first place. the john connor transformer edition was interesting, and some scenes were pretty cool, but it was trying to hard. too much showoff, too little content and suspense.
i think on writing and screenplay, there are too many 'nerds' out there that try to create a nerdgasm story. probably the sense of reality from the board is out of touch, too. they probably were able to say, we NOW have the opportunity to do a back to original terminator movie, which will cause loads of interest, and that enough will bring money on the table.
never seems people asked: but, apart from making a buck from it. will we be able to make a buck AFTER it, and do we satisfy from a bunch of millions, or can we make it better and gain a whopload of money from it AND create a renewed 'cult' from it?
anyway, this movie missed suspense a lot. Terminator 1 was thrilling, till the end.
Terminator 2 was too.
thats why those worked. T3 was a bit predictable, i think the ending of the movie was what actually made that movie something 'worthwile'. or just 'satisfied' the feeling (that judgement day was inevitable).
T4 Salvation more or less worked because it delved into a different storyline. more of a 'survivor' story. And Bale was a guaranteed hit. I do wonder how good a terminator bale would have made.
T5 Genisys was like a cover of a legendary movie. Performed like a 'got talent' participant and their 'crew' made a combo-cover of taking not 1 but 2 music hits and combining them together and somehow think the public would love it, instead of it being poorly written, poorly combined, and above all, the people portraying it actually have no talent, and on top of it all, have the original actor/artist sing one line alongside. it only works on these shows because its fake as shiz even the applaud are fake as shiz.
makes me wonder, how on earth has nobody come up with a better movie in all the past years?