The ‘Batman’ Casting Thread

[IamtheBatman]

Anybody catch tonight's Grimm there was a guy who looked like Bruce Wayne and it wasn't David Giuntoli either.

 

[BatmanGoesToRio]

i feel like everyone's mainly suggesting christoph waltz as strange because of the beard. not that he'd be a bad choice, he'd be fantastic , but am i the only one who could see him as other villains as well ? joker , perhaps ?

As a German I loved Waltz a long time before he became famous in Hollywood. He could pull off nearly any villain IMHO but he's way too old for playing Joker.
Plus: His Austrian accent would fit that mad psychiatrist scheme of Hugo Strange perfectly. Siegmund Freud was an Austrian also, for example.

In the new movie(s) they could give Hugo Strange an Austrian / German background (with his real name would be Hugo "What-ever-German-name-they-think-of") who is calling himself Hugo Strange after he began working in Gotham.

 

[flickchick85]

In regards to Scott, I do agree when it comes to his scenes in Season 1, Episode 3. However, I think his acting in Season 2, Episode 3 was fantastic.

Agreed. I hated his portrayal when he was first introduced in those few minutes he had in S1, but in S2, I thought he got a better handle on what he was going for and really knocked it outta the park.

 

[BestGirl]

In regards to Scott, I do agree when it comes to his scenes in Season 1, Episode 3. However, I think his acting in Season 2, Episode 3 was fantastic.

That was definitely his best performance. I was in agony leading up to that episode because I wasn't sure I could handle Scott's Moriarty being on my screen for that long. Surprisingly, I found him quite tolerable. Still don't want him near the Riddler or any other Batman character, though.

 

[Superherofan123]

I would really like to see Jon Hamm in the role. I just think he would own! After seeing Dredd I think Karl Urban could do the role justice as well.

 

[Viciousjay]

Bruce/Batman - Ryan Goshling, John Hamm, Jake Gyllenhaal
Alfred - Alan Rickman
Jim Gordon - Bryan Cranston
Joker - DeCaprio
Harley - Kristen Bell
Catwomen - Mila Kunis
Sal Moroni - Travolta (with the right hair piece )
Hugo Strange - Chris Waltz



just a start

 

[SlamAdams]

Batman - Enver Gjokaj
Alfred - Terrance Stamp
Commisioner Gordon - Bryan Cranston (I know he did the animated voice but still)
Harvey Bullock - Michael Madsen
Joker - Sam Rockwell
Two Face - Alexis Denisof
Catwoman - Michelle Monaghan
Penguin - David Suchet
Deadshot - Garret Dillahunt
Mr. Freeze - Christopher Eccleston
Riddler - Jason Flemyng
Lucius Fox - Clarke Peters
Vicki Vale - Jessica Chastain
Dr. Leslie Thompkins - Glenn Close
Jack Ryder - Joel McHale

 

[Bman32x]

Batman reboot

In my series boot, my cast would be reoccurring over several movies. No order relevance just as I thought of it.
Thomas Wayne/Simon Hurt- Christian Bale
Martha Wayne- Marion Cotilliard
**note: yes I purposely picked these two for the reboot symbolism of "killing off" Christopher Nolan's series, plus give diehard fans a chuckle or two**
Dr Leslie Thompkins- Diane Lane
Lucius Fox- Idris Elba
Bruce Wayne/Batman- Taylor Kitsch
Alfred Pennyworth- Ralph Fiennes
Dick Grayson/Nightwing- Alex Pettyfer
Tim Drake/Red Robin- Colton Haynes
Jason Todd/Red Hood- Lee Thompson Young or Brandon T. Jackson
Damien Wayne/Robin- Zach Gordon
Barbara Gordon/Oracle- Amanda Seyfried
Jim Gordon- Brian Cransten
Harvey Bullock- John Goodman
Selina Kyle/Catwoman- Kat Dennings
Andrea Beauxmont/Phantasm- Anna Kendrick
Vicki Vale- Brooklyn Decker
Gotham City Mayor Simon Trent/The Gray Ghost- Adam West
**Movie starThe Gray Ghost- Michael Keaton

Joker- This one was very hard for me. IMO there are only a handful of actors good enough to be Joker, let alone deserve the role. Here's the best I have or would like to see***
1. Johnny Depp
2. Tom Cruise
3. Leonardo DiCaprio
4. James Marsden
5. Jim Carey
Harley Quinn- Helena Bonham Carter
Thomas Elliot/Hush- John Hamm
Mr Freeze- Liev Schriber
Scarecrow- Ben Whishaw
Riddler- Andy Dick
Poison Ivy- Jessica Chastain
Two Face- Harry Lennix
Penguin- Bob Hoskins
Zsaz- Javier Bardem
Dead shot- Timothy Odmundson
Ra's Al Ghul- Alexander Skarsgård
Thalia Al Ghul- Olivia Wilde
Killer Croc- Dave Bautista
Bane- Alberto "Del Rio" Rodriguez
Hugo Strange- Robin Williams
Carmine Falcone- Jack Nicholson
Death stroke- Joe Manganiello
James Gordon Jr- Christopher Mintz-Plasse
Cameos indicate DCU crossover potential:
Lex Luthor- Michael C. Hall
Mercy- Gina Corano
Amanda Waller- Viola Davis
Oliver Queen- Justin Timberlake
Officer Barry Allen/Flash- Shawn Ashmore
Victor Stone/Cyborg- Derek Luke

Let me know what you guys think! Annotate any edits

 

[IamtheBatman]

Spencer Conway for Bruce Wayne/Batman

 

[Rodrigo90]

A rebooted franchise, with Bale playing a different character.

Christian Bale - Bruce Wayne/Batman
Pierce Brosnan - Alfred Pennyworth
Bryan Cranston - Commisioner James Gordon
Richard Madden - Dick Grayson/Nightwing
Sigourney Weaver - Leslie Thompkins
David Harewood - Lucius Fox
Vincent D'Onofrio - Harvey Bullock
Charlize Theron - Selina Kyle/Catwoman
Kaya Scodelario - Barbara Gordon/Batgirl

Matt Smith - The Joker
Jane Levy - Harley Quinn
Viggo Mortensen - Ra's Al Ghul
Gemma Arterton - Talia Al Ghul
Ralph Fiennes - Mr. Freeze
Michael Sheen - The Riddler
Stephen Graham - The Penguin
Joaquin Phoenix - Two-Face

 

[BatmanGoesToRio]

I am just starting my reboot casting list and I'm very unsure about most of the characters. But I'd definitely like to see:

John Cleese as Alfred Pennyworth
Benedict Cumbarbatch as Edward Nygma / The Riddler
Christoph Waltz as Hugo Strange
Viggo Mortensen as Roman Sionis / Black Mask
David Bowie as Jonathan Crane / The Scarecrow
Robert DeNiro as Carmine Falcone
Al Pacino as Salvatore Maroni

And after watching the Kick Ass 2 trailer I'd love to see Jim Carrey as a batman villain again. Not in over-the-top-mode as in BF, though.

 

[BestGirl]

You know, whenever I see Cumberbatch mentioned on casting threads it's always for a villain, but what if he were to play the hero? Could he be Bruce, or would he look strange in the cowl?

 

[Rodrigo90]

He looks strange without a cowl lol

 

[shauner111]

He's one weird looking mother****er regardless.

 

[The Vafrous]

What about Dustin Clare (Gannicus from Spartacus) as Bruce Wayne/Batman?

 

[IamtheBatman]

Tom Selleck for Commissioner Gordon

 

[Ash Talon]

Karl Urban for Batman would be great. Or Manu Bennett. Manu has certainly got the physique to pull off quite the intimidating Batman; something we haven't really seen yet on film. He's not a bad actor either, based on his role in Spartacus. He can certainly do grim and intense.

 

[Just_Human]

If Anne didnt get the Selina Kyle part in TDKR, I would have been prefectly fine with .....

 

[Rorschach2012]

You know, whenever I see Cumberbatch mentioned on casting threads it's always for a villain, but what if he were to play the hero? Could he be Bruce, or would he look strange in the cowl?

Cumberbatch is too ugly for sure. Disgusting looking man, but perfect for villain roles

 

[Eddie Dean]

Let's not get carried away here.

 

[Rorschach2012]

edit

 

[The Techno Bat]

Batman/Bruce Wayne - Matt Bomer (White Collar)

Robin/Damian Wayne - Jared Gilmore or Preston Bailey

Nightwing/Dick Grayson - Zac Efron

Red Robin/Tim Drake - Logan Lerman (Percy Jackson & The Olympians)

Red Hood/Jason Todd - Christian Antidormi

Batgirl/Barbara Gordon - Victoria Hester

Alfred - Jerome Flynn (Ripper Street) I want an Alfred that can actually kick a little butt, and doesn't seem frail and really old.

Commisioner Gordon - Bryan Cranston

 

[TX85]

Batman Beyond

Bruce Wayne:

Jon Voight

Or

Clint Eastwood

Terrance McGinnis(I wouldn't make him a high school teenager):

Jesse Metcalfe

Commissioner Barbara Gordon:

Angela Lansbury

Dana Tan:

Shay Mitchell

Derek Powers/Blight:
Ted Danson

 

[OutRiddled]

I don't really care who they cast as Batman, because the Justice League movie is going to suck balls.

If they do make any future Batman movies though, I hope they don't cast it based on looks. Michael Keaton is about as un-Batman looking as you can get, yet he gave arguably the best performance.

Ah **** it, just get the dude from Twilight. t:

 

[TX85]

I agree about Keaton,He has been my favorite Batman on film..Although I think Val Kilmer is underrated as Brice Wayne AND Batman