I did not catch the first Silent Hill film, but immensely enjoyed the second one. My only complaint was that they could have added a half hour to the film to expand on some of the plots or add the necessary shading to them; the film felt rushed at times.
I'm a HUGE Silent Hill fan. It's what got me into Jacob's Ladder.
But those films, particularly Revelation. ...were just....I can't even describe my disdain for them!
The first one was good.
And if you'd actually seen it, you would understand my complete and utter smack so hard facepalm at the sequel.
Now if the games themselves were movies, we would surely have a dedicated thread for them here. Because nearly all those games contain some of the best horror stories, set pieces,, music scores, symbolic structuring, creature design, and just general mind****s of all time