Justice League The Justice League Casting Thread

[Superman Lives]

I don't see Jon Hamm as Batman, he has already declined playing Superman and other comic book Heroes.



http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1656054/jon-hamm-calls-playing-superman-young-mans-game.jhtml

What other comicbook heroes?

Casting Superman is completely different from casting Batman. There's a huge physical component with Superman, always.

Yes, the JL:M was a failed attempt but when they did the casting it was a project that had been in the pre production stage, there was a producer, a director a Script and WETA had even designed and created costumes and the casting was completed.

By 'failure,' I'm referring to the casting for JL:M as a whole. None of the casting calls they made for JL:M were received well. It was a different time.

That shows what type of candidate they were looking for WW, same for the TV pilot show, the fact that it was not picked up for season on does not mean that casting was wrong.

The show had nothing to do with the Warners Features Division.

Secondly, the pilot demonstrated a complete lack of understanding about how to handle Wonder Woman. That is why it's a failure. The casting for that project is in alignment with that lack of understanding.

The studio wanted Biel (badly) for Wonder Woman before. She turned them down because the script showed a misunderstanding of the character.

http://splashpage.mtv.com/2012/08/02/jessica-biel-total-recall-wonder-woman/

 

[Micromind]

I just don't see the love and support Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel get among the fans, If they get cast, I guess some will be happy but I won't be seeing any movie with them, It would be the first time I did not go to a movie featuring Batman.

Edit: If Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel are soo good, then why they are not in any DC or Marvel movies ? yeah..

 

[Rowsdower!]

Her look is workable with the right hair and makeup. There are other actresses that look the part more, but she is passable. She has the star power and recognition going for her.

Her name on a poster would be recognized by the general public, and easy to market.

I remember a rumor a while back that Biel tested for a role in Man of Steel. Everyone assumed at the time that it was Lois Lane (and it probably was) but... with the rumors of a Wonder Woman cameo in MOS cropping up and the hints that the film will provide a lead-in to a JL movie... perhaps Biel was secretly cast as WW.

I know it's a long shot, but it is possible.

 

[Majik1387]

I just don't see the love and support Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel get among the fans, If they get cast, I guess some will be happy but I won't be seeing any movie with them, It would be the first time I did not do to a movie featuring Batman.

Edit: If Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel are soo good, then why they are not in any DC or Marvel movies ? yeah..

Biel almost was, she dropped out on her end, she wasn't dropped by WB.
Hamm apparently doesn't want to be a superhero, that's why he isn't in DC or Marvel movies.

Now come on, think of a better mindframe than that. Going by that I can say right back to you why Gosling or Jolie or any other of the numerous fancasted actors aren't in DC or Marvel movies.

I remember a rumor a while back that Biel tested for a role in Man of Steel. Everyone assumed at the time that it was Lois Lane (and it probably was) but... with the rumors of a Wonder Woman cameo in MOS cropping up and the hints that the film will provide a lead-in to a JL movie... perhaps Biel was secretly cast as WW.

I know it's a long shot, but it is possible.

I'm confident she's on the backburner in preparation for a WW movie, unless they find another actress they feel is better for the part.

 

[Superman Lives]

I just don't see the love and support Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel get among the fans, If they get cast, I guess some will be happy but I won't be seeing any movie with them, It would be the first time I did not do to a movie featuring Batman.

Edit: If Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel are soo good, then why they are not in any DC or Marvel movies ? yeah..

Hamm and Biel will get general audience support, that's the biggest factor. They are popular.

It's a tough sell to introduce a new Batman in 2015's JL to audiences so soon after Bale. The film's best bet is to get someone like Hamm who would be well accepted by the GA, and play it safe. He could be the 'RDJ' of this film.

Biel was actually just cast in The Wolverine as the main villain, but she recently turned it down due to scheduling.

I remember a rumor a while back that Biel tested for a role in Man of Steel. Everyone assumed at the time that it was Lois Lane (and it probably was) but... with the rumors of a Wonder Woman cameo in MOS cropping up and the hints that the film will provide a lead-in to a JL movie... perhaps Biel was secretly cast as WW.

I know it's a long shot, but it is possible.

I don't think there's any validity to those 'rumors.' Didn't they come from CBN or one of those shady sites that makes everything up?

 

[Micromind]

Question: Would you ever consider playing a female super hero?
Jessica Biel: That would be great, where are they, where is that one, they’re really hard to find.

Question:What about Wonder Woman?
Jessica Biel: I think Wonder Woman is a tough one, I think people have had a really hard time adapting it.

Question: Is there a character in the back of your head you wouldn’t mind playing?
Jessica Biel: No because I really don’t know much about comic books. I know the classic characters but I think the female characters you are talking about are probably a little bit more obscure.

comic book movie.com/fansites/GraphicCity/news/?a=64981

Doesn't look like WB want her in consideration for WW.

 

[Majik1387]

Doesn't look like WB want her in consideration for WW.

Their actions speak differently.

And the article you quoted adds nothing to current conversation.

 

[Micromind]

Their actions speak differently.

And the article you quoted adds nothing to current conversation.

OK, Can you provide any proof that WB are thinking about Biel for WW as you speak about their "actions" ?

 

[Superman Lives]

WB wanted Biel. Biel was the one who turned down WB on her end. She wasn't pleased with how halfassed WB were handling the character.

But she said this in a recent interview:

"If Wonder Woman had the right script and it was really powerful and emotional and interesting, I would be into that kind of thing," she said. "I feel that sometimes the character development gets thrown to the wayside in those movies, and I’m really interested in that kind of thing … So if both the elements could be there — the physicality and a real developed character, whether it’s a Wonder Woman thing or a Justice League thing — I’m open to it."

http://splashpage.mtv.com/2012/08/02/jessica-biel-total-recall-wonder-woman/

 

[Lily Adler]

If Biel becomes WW, I pray her acting skills improve.

 

[Micromind]

WB wanted Biel. Biel was the one who turned down WB on her end. She wasn't pleased with how halfassed WB were handling the character.

But she said this in a recent interview:

"If Wonder Woman had the right script and it was really powerful and emotional and interesting, I would be into that kind of thing," she said. "I feel that sometimes the character development gets thrown to the wayside in those movies, and I’m really interested in that kind of thing … So if both the elements could be there — the physicality and a real developed character, whether it’s a Wonder Woman thing or a Justice League thing — I’m open to it."

http://splashpage.mtv.com/2012/08/02/jessica-biel-total-recall-wonder-woman/

That part of quote is from a 2009 interview, I quoted her latest remarks (see my post #956 above.)

Anyway Biel as Wonder Woman is just a bad idea.

 

[Superman Lives]

That part of quote is from a 2009 interview, I quoted her latest remarks (see my post #956 above.)

All her remarks are in alignment. She wasn't happy with how they handled the character, that's why she turned it down.

Anyway Biel as Wonder Woman is just a bad idea.

WB likely thinks otherwise. There aren't many other recognizable names that would fit this role.

If Biel becomes WW, I pray her acting skills improve.

She would basically be the 'Scarlett Johansson' of this movie. She's sufficient, and really in the same talent bracket as ScarJo.

 

[Micromind]

She would basically be the 'Scarlett Johansson' of this movie. She's sufficient, and really in the same talent bracket as ScarJo.

Maybe you are correct in compararing her with Scarlett Johansson, there is even some resemblance in the facial features.

But Wonder Woman is much more iconic character than Black Widow, nobody will be angry if Marvel fail to portray Black Widow accurately not so with Wonder Woman, all critics, fans and general audience will start giving angry reactions if something is not done correctly, that includes casting.

 

[Micromind]

As my final comments on this particular subject matter, I say -

Hell No to Jon Hamm as batman and Hell No toJessica Biel as Wonder Woman.

I just cannot accept either of them, no matter what arguments you make, if they do cast either I will just avoid that movie.

 

[Project862006]

i still like gemma artreton she is still very young at 26 is 5'8 and a solid actress

 

[Llama_Shepherd]

I would get behind Arterton, she is one of my favourite choices .

 

[Superman Lives]

But Wonder Woman is much more iconic character than Black Widow, nobody will be angry if Marvel fail to portray Black Widow accurately not so with Wonder Woman, all critics, fans and general audience will start giving angry reactions if something is not done correctly, that includes casting.

You're exaggerating big time. Biel is actually a popular choice for Wonder Woman on the web with general audiences.

If anything will fail to portray the character 'correctly,' it would be the script. According to Jaimie Alexander when she turned down WW and joined Marvel, WB/DC basically portrayed WW as the T+A of the film. WW is a character the studio doesn't know how to handle yet.


Honestly, if they are able to portray WW as respectable as ScarJo's Black Widow, I'd be fine with that.

As my final comments on this particular subject matter, I say -

Hell No to Jon Hamm as batman and Hell No toJessica Biel as Wonder Woman.

I just cannot accept either of them, no matter what arguments you make, if they do cast either I will just avoid that movie.

This movie isn't being made for you. Both of them are popular with general audiences.

I would get behind Arterton, she is one of my favourite choices .

I'd be okay with Arterton as well. My only drawback with her is she's kind of bland and forgettable in the work I've seen her in. She's good as love interests, but could she handle this?

 

[HighFivingMF]

If anything will fail to portray the character 'correctly,' it would be the script. According to Jaimie Alexander when she turned down WW and joined Marvel, WB/DC basically portrayed WW as the T+A of the film. WW is a character the studio doesn't know how to handle yet.

Where did you see that?

 

[Superman Lives]

Where did you see that?

Link

 

[HighFivingMF]

It'd be nice to know which version she was up for.

 

[Lily Adler]

Count me in for Arterton. She's a good solid choice for WW.

 

[Derrick9592]

Count me in for Arterton. She's a good solid choice for WW.

Ditto

 

[BestGirl]

I just don't see the love and support Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel get among the fans, If they get cast, I guess some will be happy but I won't be seeing any movie with them, It would be the first time I did not go to a movie featuring Batman.

Edit: If Jon Hamm and Jessica Biel are soo good, then why they are not in any DC or Marvel movies ? yeah..

I agree, especially in regard to Hamm. He's old and looks even older, and has already said that superheroes should be played by younger men than himself. I wouldn't boycott any Batman movie he was the star of, but I'm also tired of seeing his name brought up here all the time.

 

[DE LA LUNA]

As my final comments on this particular subject matter, I say -

Hell No to Jon Hamm as batman and Hell No toJessica Biel as Wonder Woman.

I just cannot accept either of them, no matter what arguments you make, if they do cast either I will just avoid that movie.

You should at least be humble enough to give it a chance. Don't be so closed minded, because they could surprise you. Remember, this is just a movie and you should enjoy it - don't take any personal grudges against actors/actresses.

i still like gemma artreton she is still very young at 26 is 5'8 and a solid actress

Spoiler

I never thought about her. I think she has the right face for Wonder Woman, and she could get into shape if she wanted to for the part. However, she was kind of whiny in Prince of Persia. I'd give her a chance however.

 

[Superman Lives]

I agree, especially in regard to Hamm. He's old and looks even older, and has already said that superheroes should be played by younger men than himself. I wouldn't boycott any Batman movie he was the star of, but I'm also tired of seeing his name brought up here all the time.

Again, he said that with regards to a Superman question specifically.

There are actors older than him playing superheroes. Not to mention Batman wears a mask.

I think the reason his name is brought up so often here is that he's the safest choice to replace Bale so soon after TDKR.


Justice League (2015) will have no rebooted Batman solo films leading into it, and will introduce this new Batman within JL instead. It needs to be someone audiences can immediately connect with, otherwise it would be a very jarring transition.

He can do it. Jeremy Renner is the same age as John Hamm and is kicking ass as Hawkeye, and will be for several more years.

I never thought about her. I think she has the right face for Wonder Woman, and she could get into shape if she wanted to for the part. However, she was kind of whiny in Prince of Persia. I'd give her a chance however.

I've seen her in Clash of the Titans also and she came off as very 'sweet' and girly. She's almost like Mary Elizabeth Winstead in that regard.

She doesn't strike me as Wonder Woman material, but she's well cast for the love interest roles she usually plays.