The Last Stand vs Wolverine

[Catman]

Which was, um, better, X-Men: The Last Stand or X-Men Origins: Wolverine?

 

[chaseter]

This is like comparing the bird flu to the swine flu But, I did enjoy TLS more than this movie.

 

[alexlachiusa]

Wolverine was way better.

It made me cringe far less than X3.

X3 was a piece of ****.

 

[Catman]

This is like comparing the bird flu to the swine flu

lol.

Wolverine was way better.

 

[Nirvana]

Wolverine was better. X3 was bull****.

 

[Team Andino]

Id say Wolverine is better because it wasnt as disappointing as X3 but Chaseter is right about the comparison

 

[BMM]

I'll have to think about it, but X-Men Origins: Wolverine doesn't have a scene nearly as well done as the Xavier vs. Phoenix dual, and I don't even like The Last Stand.

 

[K.B.]

I voted Wolverine..it sucked but at least it had some decent scenes and moments where the characters actually acted like they did in previous films (wolvie) and like they should (Sabes)

 

[chaseter]

I thought this Wolverine went right in line with X3's Wolverine; an angry good guy

 

[craigdbfan]

I thought this Wolverine went right in line with X3's Wolverine; an angry good guy

The guy was pretty much a saint in both X3 & Wolverine. We never saw the Wolverine defending the kids over at the X-Mansion.

A darn shame really.

 

[chaseter]

We never saw confused Wolverine go bat**** crazy in the Weapon X facility.

 

[chaseter]

dbl post

 

[K.B.]

Well I doubt Jackman even knows up from down anymore with regards to playing Wolverine.

A recent interview he did this week had him saying he wants to do the classic "beserker rage" we see in comics because they havent done that in any of the films yet.

After I read that I kinda sat there confused,scratching my head saying "Uhh Hugh..don't you remember X2 where you kill like 12 guys in the first 10 minutes?"

 

[gap5ewl]

They both sucked.

 

[Timstuff]

I liked X-Men 3. I thought Wolverine was atrocious though. It's pretty bad when a movie makes you miss Brett Ratner.

 

[Catman]

Wolverine was better. X3 was bull****.

Id say Wolverine is better because it wasnt as disappointing as X3 but Chaseter is right about the comparison

I voted Wolverine..it sucked but at least it had some decent scenes and moments where the characters actually acted like they did in previous films (wolvie) and like they should (Sabes)

Is Wolverine better because it's, well, Wolverine? While X-Men 3 basically dissed a bunch of characters.

 

[BMM]

^ I would say The Last Stand has its highs and its lows, whereas X-Men Origins: Wolverine is more steady in its quality.

 

[sniktsnakt]

This was kinda tough, which made me sad.

I ended up with Wolverine, though, mostly because of Sabretooth. I thought the CGI was actually better in X3, though. Maybe it's just been too long since I've seen it. The fight scenes in Wolverine were painful, but not in the way they should have been.

Despite this being the one that Wolverine got his claws, I felt like he was *declawed* the whole movie.

I love Hugh, but do these people even know what a berserker rage is?

 

[Nathan]

Disliked both, but I'd have to give it to X3.

 

[Team Andino]

Is Wolverine better because it's, well, Wolverine? While X-Men 3 basically dissed a bunch of characters.

With X 3 I truly thought the whole "cure" thing was gonna lead to Apocalypse like in the animated series an instead all it really was a bout so some lame temporary fix of peoples powers. X3 had much more potential for greatness an dropped the ball BIG. Wolverine on the other hand I knew it wasn't gonna be gory and the story already looked meh and I already knew the fate of Striker an Sabretooth doesn't add any suspense. Wolverine was...ok but IMO X3 just had to much on the line

 

[K.B.]

Is Wolverine better because it's, well, Wolverine? While X-Men 3 basically dissed a bunch of characters.

No because X3 dissed Wolvie too. I twas basically Logan crying for 1 hour 30 mins but ends up happy in his garden at the end.

Wolverine wins for me becasue at least there were moments where he had the bad attitude like he did in X1.

 

[Team Andino]

Oh yea an Cyclops was killed for no reason in the first 15 minutes to. What a waste of time

 

[Ipodman]

my rating
X1 > Wolverine > X2 > X3

 

[craigdbfan]

Oh yea an Cyclops was killed for no reason in the first 15 minutes to. What a waste of time

Even though X3 is the weakest of the trilogy, I have to say that Cyclops wasn't used by Singer very well either. He wasn't the Scott I knew from the comics who stood out as the leader, instead he was completely overshadowed by Wolverine. Re watch both X1 and especially X2 and you'll see the limited thought that went into the character. I loved both of those movies but X3 merely put an end to a character that was barley being used but instead playing more of an "obstacle" to allow Wolverine and Jean's odd relationship.

The characters in Wolverine is just straight up cardboard. X3 had way more believable emotion (Even though X1 and X2 still trump Ratners film by a substantial margin) than Wolverine's almost soap opera execution (thanks to the dialogue provided by whatever script they went with).

 

[Gumbo LeBeau]

I voted Wolverine..it sucked but at least it had some decent scenes and moments where the characters actually acted like they did in previous films (wolvie) and like they should (Sabes)

I don't even think i will be considering taking your opinion seriously based solely on the fact that you think Sam Jackson(a black man) should play the second most evil aryan Nazi leader next to Hitler as Red Skull.

I voted Wolverine.