The Official Recommendations Thread

I've recently gotten back into comics and after such a long hiatus I am delighted in how many quality indy titles there are these days. Robert Kirkman is a modern-day Stan Lee. I have enjoyed many of his titles such as Invincible and The Walking Dead.

Based on his own creations, yes... Kirkman knows how to create and make a Universe work. Anybody who reads Invivncible can see that.

But when he touches other characters that aren't his own, his writing suffers just a tad.

:yay:
 
I think I actually like Mr. Punch more than Sandman. It's really dense, at the surface it's just about a rather mundane memory, but by trying to understand the narrator as he is in the present makes the narrative very complex and much more ambiguous. The real question is not about his memory, it's about why this one has stuck with him for so long, and how it connects to the Punch and Judy shows which have now gone out of vogue. Dave McKean's art is at its best in the book. His use of photography means he can play with focus, and by mixing media, this creates some really symbol heavy images. It is work to decode, and will take multiple readings (I'm going in on my third now and I still feel like I'm just scratching the surface) but it is really rewarding. It's the first and only thing I've read by Gaiman that didn't have any fantasy or mythological elements. No gods, or sphinxes, or magic (though the Punch and Judy shows and their history kinda take their place from a structural standpoint I guess). I wish he would write more stories like this, because as much as I love his fantasy work, he is really good at the grounded stuff as well, and I find this to be more poignant than the grander abstracts he deals with in Sandman (which is plenty poignant already). Basically, if you haven't read Mr. Punch, you really owe it to yourself to go out and read it.

Mr.Punch was an awesome read back in 1994 as well... :word: :word: :word:

:yay:
 
It was a retro quip.




You're just a Kirkman apologist. Go roll around in your Ultimate X-Men.:woot:


Pfft, I dropped that s**t months ago. I get by just fine with Walking Dead issues to pass the time. :o :p
 
Mr.Punch was an awesome read back in 1994 as well... :word: :word: :word:

:yay:

orly_cthulu.jpg


:cmad::cmad:
 
I can't recpect a man that thinks Rob lefield is stan lee. :(

But I can't stop reading his comics either. :(
 
Based on his own creations, yes... Kirkman knows how to create and make a Universe work. Anybody who reads Invivncible can see that.

But when he touches other characters that aren't his own, his writing suffers just a tad.

:yay:

I dunno, I loved his Marvel Team Up. And Eric O'Grady was his own creation, and, while I still enjoyed Irredeemable Ant-Man, it's probably been my least favorite thing by him.
 
I dunno, I loved his Marvel Team Up. And Eric O'Grady was his own creation, and, while I still enjoyed Irredeemable Ant-Man, it's probably been my least favorite thing by him.


MTU was one of my favorites. Not just of Kirkman's, but it was at the top of my list overall when it was coming out.

Ant-Man was great if fir no other reason than adding another great character to Marvel's stable. I can't wait to see what they do with him in the future.

I would say U X-Men has been my least favorite Kirkman work.
 
Did anyone here read Umbrella Academy? Were you as blown away as I was? I loved it. It was quirky and a good read.
 
Hey gang,looking to abuse my wallet with some new trades.

I'm thinking:

Inhumans by Jenkins/Lee
Nick Fury Agent of SHIELD by Steranko/Kirby

I was also thinking about the rest of Grant's JLA run.I wasn't pleased with NWO and AD for the sole fact that the stories were pretty generic and standard.I understand that this comic brought the JLA brand back to the forefront and all,but how is the rest of the series?

thoughts?
 
Haven't read them so I wouldn't know. But what older TPB do you have?
 
43081_20060528224633_large.jpg


Hawkman by Geoff Johns,James Robinson,Justin Gray,Jimmy Palmiotti,Rags Morales,Ryan Sook, and Joe Bennett

Vol.1 Endless Flight
Vol.2 Allies and Enemies
Vol.3 Wings of Fury
#28-36(uncollected - Fate's Warning 4 parter,done in ones featuring Atom,Monolith,Deadman)
Vol.4 Rise of the Golden Eagle

For anybody wanting to get into the character,this 45 issue run is essential and probably definitive in terms of Hawkman.Out of all the big guns of the DCU,this run is highly underrated and probably the best ongoing run.The main thing to love about this run,is the perfect combination of superhero action,character study,deconstruction,heavy use of recurring themes,classic adventure and emotional investment.In everything Johns has written,this is probably his most fantasy/adventure filled approach to writing,much different than his writing on books like Green Lanten,Titans or JSA.

The history of Hawkman may seem confusing,but Johns explains it all with much ease and makes the whole reincarnation idea one of the main themes of this run.He uses it with alot of tragedy and sadness,Hawkman has had to deal with losing his loved ones over and over again,this is why he fights so hard to save lives.It's also why he questions the need to love people,when he knows he will just pass them by.

43082_20060528225051_large.jpg


Johns explores many of these past lives to really build the character and it's just beautiful to read.It really puts the whole interest in archaeology into perspective,Carter is simply interested in gathering all the things he left behind in his past lives.From visiting different countries to see his gravestones to keeping a box of pictures of all the loved ones he has lost in these past lives,Johns really brings out Carter's character from under the stereotyped winged brute.

There are many supporting roles and cameos here.Hawkgirl,Green Arrow,Ray Palmer,Dr.Fate,and many more.His history with many of these characters is explained as well as his stints in the JLA and JSA.It will not take a hardcore DC fan to realize that Green Arrow and Hawkman dislike each other or that Hawk and Atom are the best of friends.These rel'ps are all made clear and do not confuse new readers.

43084_20060528225459_large.jpg


85453_20070414235453_large.jpg


In terms of action,it comes in boatloads.This is one of the defining aspects of Hawkman that really separates his from the other big guns of the DCU.The idea of when he puts the helmet on,he becomes this brutal merciless warrior who uses nothing but deathblows.Carter is constantly struggling with his savage nature and does not always keep it in check.Seeing Hawkman go ape**** on anyone from street thugs,supervillains or monsters with a mace is always brutal but fun to watch.There's bloody mutilations,head smashing,limb breaking and beheading for all to enjoy.

Rags Morales has to be commended for his new yet classic take on Hawkman.The menacing look of the hawk helmet,the addition of a variety of deadly weapons and the barbaric movements when in action,this isn't your grandaddy's Hawkman,all due respect of course.

If you ever were curious about Hawkman's character,looking for a truly solid read unlike any typical cape book or looking to see what makes Hawkman one of a kind in the DCU,look no further than this run.

Highly recommended.

28815_20060316045703_large.jpg


28821_20070320163038_large.jpg
 
Has anyone read B. Clay Moore's Hawaiian Dick series? It sounds cool and with the ongoing starting up next week, I was thinking of jumping in.
 
I was wondering if the Heroes trade is worth a look?
 
I've got a couple of questions:

How many Y: The Last Man trades are there so far?
What are some good Thor trades to get?
 
I've got a couple of questions:

How many Y: The Last Man trades are there so far?
What are some good Thor trades to get?

Thor stuff....

Avengers Disassembled Thor
Thor Blood Oath
Thor Visionaries:Walter Simonson
Thor Eternals Saga
 
I've got a couple of questions:

How many Y: The Last Man trades are there so far?
What are some good Thor trades to get?

There are nine volumes of Y-TLM, with a final tenth volume on the way. I'll second GNR's Thor recommendations
 
the current JMS ongoing is great too

I haven't read the Simonson run for the sole fact that I tend to shy away from runs that include buying like 5 to 10 tpbs
 
Ok

The Walking Dead &
Invincible

are my two favorite comics at the moment. I've heard Dynamo 5 is pretty good.

What other titles would you guys recommend? From Marvel, DC, Image, Dark Horse or any other comics out there. Either series, mini series, graphic novels or just one shotters or anything.
 
Ok

The Walking Dead &
Invincible

are my two favorite comics at the moment. I've heard Dynamo 5 is pretty good.

What other titles would you guys recommend? From Marvel, DC, Image, Dark Horse or any other comics out there. Either series, mini series, graphic novels or just one shotters or anything.

if you like Zombie stories, Black Gas by Warren Ellis is a fun read. it's released by Avatar.

it also seems you're a Kirkman fan, I'd recommend Battle Pope. it's NOTHING like Walking Dead, but it's awesome in it's own way.
 
if you like Zombie stories, Black Gas by Warren Ellis is a fun read. it's released by Avatar.

it also seems you're a Kirkman fan, I'd recommend Battle Pope. it's NOTHING like Walking Dead, but it's awesome in it's own way.


Eh, not really a Kirkman fan, ever since he made those comments about people needing to respect Rob Lefield and compared him to Jack Kirby he lost major points with me. But he is a pretty damn good writer, at least so far.

I like Warren Ellis, Dark Blue was awesome I've also heard transmetropolitan rocks hard.

I like the new Thor run but it's not very far along so we'll see. I loved Civil War, thought it was really well done, I liked Planet Hulk, didn't care for World War Hulk at all.

I just like good stories period. Doesn't need to be a Zombie story, but I also did like....Marvel Zombies, but just for ****s and giggles.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"