Revenge of the Fallen Transformers: ROTF User Review Thread

What did you think of TF:ROTF?

  • So so

  • Good

  • Awesome

  • Bad

  • Really bad

  • So so

  • Good

  • Awesome

  • Bad

  • Really bad


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
really? they did? i must have missed that part....anyway OP wasnt missing any limbs...just his mechanical entrales ;)

it may be easier to reattach an arm than rebuild someones insides
 
Optimus got the Matrix shoved into his Spark, just like Megatron got the Allspark fragment shoved into his. They didn't do anything special and repair Optimus first. That Matrix revived him even with his chest blown wide open. I'm sure an Allspark fragment would've done the trick as well. Especially since the Allspark is also shown to repair Transformers, as seen with Frenzy.
 
not for a robot....to reattach an arm you need to sacrifice another robot. to rebuild a robots insides all you need is some magic robot pixie dust :)
 
Megatron was. But he got revived with a Spark fragment.

but megs was, and they used a spark fragment to bring him back..

But Megatron was and it worked on him just fine!

EDIT: You guys got me!

Don't yell at me! :p

Speaking of bringing Megs back, it looked like a smaller Decepticon was sacrificed in order to get parts. Is that what happened? And if so, who was the unlucky donor?
 
Don't yell at me! :p

Speaking of bringing Megs back, it looked like a smaller Decepticon was sacrificed in order to get parts. Is that what happened? And if so, who was the unlucky donor?
Scrapper - A yellow Caterpillar 992G scoop loader who forms the right arm. Confusingly in the movie, their appeared to be three Scrappers, One of the Scrapper was killed by his fellow constructicons brutally cannibalising his parts when Scalpel demanded more parts for rebuilding Megatron in the bottom of the Laurentian Abyss. In the film's climax, another Scrapper in vehicle mode is seen merging with the other six Constructicons to form Devastator; this one is killed when Devastator is destroyed by an experimental rail gun. The individual Scrapper is seen pursing Sam and Mikaela in Egypt during the final battle, he is killed with Long Haul after some fighter jets drop bombs on them.

:huh:
 
I thought it was Scrapper. The multiple constructicons were confusing. Hell, there were 2 Rampages and they weren't even the same color haha.
 
Also, how come when Bumblebee transformed into a robot he still looks like the old Camaro? :huh:
 
really? i didnt even noticed this. when was this?
Pretty much throughout the entire movie. I distinctly remember it in the garage scene and when he's trying to console Sam after Optimus died.
 
Maybe it was cause he looked dirty? But I have to rewatch the movie again to be sure but I could have sworn he looked like the old one when he was a robot. :huh:
 
I think it's just that he looks dirty as hell. He's definitely got the new Camaro's side mirrors in robot mode.
 
Last edited:
Also, how come when Bumblebee transformed into a robot he still looks like the old Camaro? :huh:

All the robots were scraped up and dirty in humanoid form, but were clean and showroom quality. Bumblebee never had the old Camero style chest in TF2.

Of course, another continuity error in the films. Same was true in the first film as well.
 
its an artistic choice. when they are in robot mode it looks more interesting if they have dirt and scratches. and it looks mroe cool and ''pretty'' if they are clean in car mode.

like how supermans cape never has any cloth wrinkles inside. like how supermans suit is under hes normal clothes. the same for spiderman. like how batman's cape gets bigger when he is standing on a statue or when he is gliding.

artistic choices to make the movie look as best as it can be. i respect that some people have problems because its unrealistic and its actually fantasy. its magic. but its movie magic.
 
i am very happy that they gave Sideswipe such a badass scene in the beginning. i dont have a problem that they didnt show more action from him because they had a lot of robots inside the movie.
but i only see here what a great designe he had. he really looks like a superhero from a comic.
 
"Stupid" is the only way to describe it. The plot is laughably incomplete

What's incomplete about it? The lack of resolution? What kind of story would you liked to have seen?

The soldiers drop Optimus off. That is all they do in this movie.
There's a subplot about the government having second thoughts about the autobots, but if you think about it, it's irrelevant. Nothing in the movie is affected by this subplot.

It gives them something to do in the plot, and raises the stakes of that element a bit, making it more than just another NEST outing. It shows the broader bond between the NEST team and their robot overlords. :). And it's conflict. It's one of the few conflicts found in the film, one of the few elements of Transformer/human interaction that is explored.

A fellow robot died in order to give Optimus his upgrade. Upon beating the Fallen, what does he do? Chucks it aside like so much waste. A fellow robot died to give Optimus his strength back.

1. Jetfire was more or less already dying. He seemed to know this.

2. As someone said, what's Prime going to do, transform into a semi with jet wings?

What i didnt like was the Starscream/Megatron dynamic, as i said in my review as well. Megatron was abusing SS all the time for no reason. In G1 Starscream often contradicts Megatron but Megatron is barely abset.

4) Starscream was a wuss. In G1 he had some guts and he often spoke his mind even though he contradicted Megs and without the latter beating him all the time. Megatron lived with Starscream's treachery. Here SS was constantly bowing and hoping that Megatron would spare him, while Megatron was overly abusive towards him.

It's from the comics. Megatron's constantly shooting Starscream, beating on him when he talks back, etc. Starscream spoke his mind a bit in the movie, didn't he?

22) Didnt like how Megatron was like Vader. Galvatron was Unicron's servant as well, but we saw him hate Unicron and bow with difficulty. Here Megatron is honestly loyal to the Fallen. It never crossed his mind to use him and then betray him and use his device.

I thought the film made it pretty clear that Megatron was loyal to the Fallen's ideas, because he wanted the machine to be used for Energon purposes. When Prime took The Fallen on, Megatron wasn't exactly helping. He fled with Starscream, and left his mentor/master to die.

Re: The Allspark and the Matrix reviving and killing...both in the comics have multiple uses and meanings. It's something of a MacGuffin. Always has been.
 
Last edited:
I loved the movie. I have issues with story and bots but hey...it's Bay. I see you guys talking about healing and such and I thought of this: Starscream got beat with his own severed arm by Megatron but in the same scene, you can see Starscream re-attaching his arm on top of the building. Why could this not be done by Megatron or other bots?
 
Is there anything funnier than Starscream getting hit with his own arm?

I'm pretty sure it can be done by other robots. Bumblee was badly damaged in the first movie, and managed to be repaired. They can take a decent amount of damage, but if their spark cores are destroyed or the damage is really extensive, they're done. Hence Jazz not returning, Megatron overloading in TRANSFORMERS, and Prime and The Fallen dying in ROTF.
 
Last edited:
Awesome movie.

I just wish they didn't have Jolt in it(stupid GM) and had more scenes with Sideswipe.
 
Stupid Jolt? He didn't even do anything to give you a chance to dislike him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,436
Messages
22,106,842
Members
45,898
Latest member
NeonWaves64
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"