What's the Best game of this Generation (So far)?)

[Terror Inc.]

Man this is really a tough one, there's been a LOT of good games for this Gen. Most of the lists I can agree with, loved the Arkham games, GTA 4 of course rocks. Bioshock is a great new series, and I'm a huge Elder Scrolls fan. However if I had to pick one, MGS 4 would have to take it for me, that game was sad, exhilarating, engrossing, and epic all rolled into one. Not to mention returning to Shadow Moses was one of the coolest Experiences of my gaming career. Now if I had to make a list, I'll just throw out my top three:

1. MGS 4 (for reasons stated above.)
2. Limbo (a tiny and often overlooked little game, but it is really a work of art, and I recommend it to anyone I know that plays games.)
3. Skyrim (although there are things I like better about Oblivion, never before have been so engrossed and spent so, so many hours playing a game.)

and just for an honorable mention : GTA 4 (first title I saw for 360 and was blown away.)

 

[Spuzz]

MGS4 is still pretty amazing/hard to top given how early in its system's life it came out.

 

[Spider-Vader]

1.) Halo 3
2.) Call of Duty 4
3.) Mass Effect 2
4.) Red Dead Redemption
5.) Marvel Ultimate Alliance
6.) Mass Effect 3
7.) Skyrim
8.) Assassin's Creed II
9.) Left 4 Dead
10.) Minecraft
11.) Call of Duty: Black Ops
12.) Batman: Arkham City
13.) The Walking Dead
14.) Ultimate Marvel vs Capcom 3
15.) Half-Life 2: Episode Two

 

[James]

So far my vote would probably go to Fallout 3. When all's said and done, I believe it'll be GTA V.

 

[james-in-cali]

I agree with the arkham city and uncharted 2 love but no mention of new super Mario wii yet? If that game does not leave you grinning ear to ear your are dead.

 

[Mrs. Sawyer]

I wouldn't call that the best of the generation. I think the Mario Galaxy games are both superior too.

 

[DarkMelody]

It's hard for me to come up with a ranked list really, Skyrim, Mass Effect, Bioshock, Fallout 3, and Arkham Asylum are probably my unsorted five but I also probably forgot or left out a ton of masterpiece games I enjoyed.