Which is The BEST X-Men movie ?

[The Caped Knight]

Ok my fellow X-fans, The time has come to choose Which was either your Favorite or BEST X-Men flim.

X-MEN {2000}

-----------------------

X2 / X-MEN : United {2003}

-------------------------------

X3 / X-MEN : The Last Stand {2006}

 

[Buddha]

I would rank them like this....

1. X-2
2. X-3
3. X-1

 

[The Caped Knight]

Actionwise

1. X3

2. X2

3. X1
-----------

Storywise

(1) X2

(2) X3

(3) X1

 

[borinquenknight]

1. X2
2. X1
3. X3

 

[Supreme Power]

After watching X3 twice today:

X2 (but not by much)
X3 (Length and lack of development hurt it for me.)
X1

 

[DACrowe]

1. X2
2. X1 (why such disrespect for what is by all intensive purposes a good movie if little on action, it was high on character and suspense for the climax)
















3. X3

 

[CapBeerCino]

There is already a poll about that.

 

[Supreme Power]

I absolutely still love X1, but X3 was better IMO.

 

[The Riddler]

i actually like x-men 1 a lot.
x-2 was really good.
x-3 was darker and funnier, with more action but it seemed rushed.

to me, i like them all the same.

 

[Cyclops]

X2, followed closely by X-Men, which did a good job of introducing the characters, and then every other Marvel film, and then X-Men: The Last Stand.

Yes, every other Marvel film is a batter X-Men movie than X-Men 3.

 

[cardslinger]

Actionwise

1. X3

2. X2

3. X1
-----------

Storywise

(1) X2

(2) X3

(3) X1

I agree with this. I liked X2 and X3 about the same, but for different reasons.

 

[StorminNorman]

1 X3 - Most Action, Good Story, Worked with a base of fairly deep characters from past movies
2 X1 - Good story, great character building, little action
3 X2 - Decent story, decent actionbuilding

 

[LEX]

Action-wise:
1) XMTLS
2) X2
3) X-Men

Story-wise:
1) X2
2) XMTLS
3) X-Men

Pace-wise:
1) X-Men
2) X2
3) XMTLS

 

[pyromaniac]

Action-wise:
1) XMTLS
2) X2
3) X-Men

Story-wise:
1) X2
2) XMTLS
3) X-Men

Pace-wise:
1) X-Men
2) X2
3) XMTLS

Isn't it funny how all those films have flaws and avantages of their own?

 

[twix]

probobly because i am completely stoned off of just seeing the movie i am going to say x-men 3.. i thought it like.. totaly rocked my socks you know.. =P

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

My ranking:

01: X2: X-Men United
02: X-Men: The Last Stand
03: X-Men

Overall, a great ****ing trilogy.

I wish that some things had played out a bit differently throughout the course of the trilogy, but overall, it's an amazing trilogy, 3 amazing chapters. Great all the way through, no real weak link.

 

[The Kid]

X1: Good start for the franchise, not the best, but good nonetheless. Logan's intro and the struggle of rogue are handled very well. Magneto and the dynamic between him and charles, two sides of the same coin, is made perfectly clear. Best of all, is this prooved that x-men could be done well with intelligence and seriousness and still make money. No need to camp it up since it's a comic. Fantastic four prooved to fox that they didn't have to make x-men actually good to make money. So then we got x3.

X2: Out of this bloody world. Nightcrawler's entrance is brilliant beyond anything I've seen yet in a comicbook movie. The whole show is told naturally and paced well. Characters show dynamic changes. The action is intense. Stakes higher, everything is beautifully done from logan's inner conflict, to pyro's. **** this movie's the best of the bunch. The drama at the end is heartbreaking.

X3: Emo cyclops dies. nuff said. I haven't seen it but from what I've read, it's a fantastic four meets power rangers. full of silly nonsense on the level of batman and robin. Beast being good doesn't save it, no.

 

[CGHulk]

X3
X1
X2

 

[WorthyStevens]

What was the best
1. X2
2. X3
3. X1

What I enjoyed the most
1. X3
2. X2
3. X1​

 

[The Caped Knight]

X1: Good start for the franchise, not the best, but good nonetheless. Logan's intro and the struggle of rogue are handled very well. Magneto and the dynamic between him and charles, two sides of the same coin, is made perfectly clear. Best of all, is this prooved that x-men could be done well with intelligence and seriousness and still make money. No need to camp it up since it's a comic. Fantastic four prooved to fox that they didn't have to make x-men actually good to make money. So then we got x3.

X2: Out of this bloody world. Nightcrawler's entrance is brilliant beyond anything I've seen yet in a comicbook movie. The whole show is told naturally and paced well. Characters show dynamic changes. The action is intense. Stakes higher, everything is beautifully done from logan's inner conflict, to pyro's. **** this movie's the best of the bunch. The drama at the end tugs at your heart.

X3: Emo cyclops dies. nuff said. I haven't seen it but from what I've read, it's a fantastic four meets power rangers. full of silly nonsense on the level of batman and robin. Beast being good doesn't save it, no.

Now that's bull**** X3 was 10 x10 better than, FF, PR & B&R . X3 was pretty good. I think you should see the movie for yourself . You may find that you may have overjudged it bassed on someone else opinion .

 

[War Party]

I enjoyed the hell out of X3, but I enjoyed X2 a little more. But X3 was still great in my opinion.

 

[WorthyStevens]

news flash! whatever you enjoy IS "the best".

You don't say "I enjoy Pepsi the most but Coke is the best."

What I meant was, X2 is in fact a better movie than X3, but I enjoyed X3 better.

 

[LEX]

news flash! whatever you enjoy IS "the best".

You don't say "I enjoy Pepsi the most but Coke is the best."

Good point. (Pepsi > Coke)

By the way, I voted for all of the X-movies.

 

[Supreme Power]

I Agree, Every Horrible Review & Thing I Heard Wuz Put To Rest When I Seen X3. Brilliant Movie. F Brian Singer & Superfag. He Can Have That Franchise. Imma X-Fan For Life.
X3=All This Talk About It Wuz Too Much Action & Rushed I Thought It Wuz Paced That Way Cuz The Others Were Slow. This Movie Wuz Near Perfect. I Absolutley Loved It.

X2=Also Near Perfect. No Good Villian & Confusing Storyline Hurt It. Deathstrike Could've Been Saved For A Wolverine Movie. But I Still Love It. Nightcrawler's Performance Wuz The Highlight. And You Could Feel Cyclops Emotion At The End. Very Moving.

X1=Even Though Last, I Can Watch This Movie Almost Once A Month Still. Maybe More. Although I Have Favorites, I Love The Whole X-Men Films Franchise. I Watch This For The Introduction To Wolverine, Toad, & Sabertooth. Might Sound Corny, But I Love The Brotherhood. "Scream For Me." & "You Owe Me A Scream."-Sabertooth. "Quit Playing Around."-Toad
-$!X

X1 was the first time ever, ever, that I followed a movies production from start to finish. I could not believe they were making it and could not wait to see it. I loved it then and still do.

But the one negative about it that resurfaced somewhat with X3 was that it was too short for me. I guess with X3 I just wanted more of everything. But I love it better than X1 now.

 

[Cyclops]

haha! This dude thinks X1 is better than X3! Hilarious!

Haha! This dude thinks X3 isn't a piece of garbage! Hilarious!

Welcome to the world of opinion, moron.