Which is The BEST X-Men movie ?

[spideydave]

X2 GREAT ACTION GREAT STORY

X1 Great story lack of action maybe it kinda dull


X3 LACK OF STORY, ACTION LOOKED SO FRIGGIN CHEAP!

 

[spideydave]

Ok my fellow X-fans, The time has come to choose Which was either your Favorite or BEST X-Men flim.

X-MEN {2000}

-----------------------

X2 / X-MEN : United {2003}

-------------------------------

X3 / X-MEN : The Last Stand {2006}[/QUOUgh the poster for the third one pisses me off.Makes me wanna throw up

 

[High Voltage]

1. X-Men 3
2. X-Men
3. X2

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

I'd say... X2/X3 and X1 by itself...

 

[phoenix_force]

story wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
application of story
1-x2
2-x1
3-x3
critic wise
1-x2
2-x3
3-x1
action wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
effects wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
acting wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
my favourite
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1

 

[LongDong]

In regards to Eric's "plastic prison", I got the impression that they were using some sort of neural inhibitor to weaken Magneto when he was in the plastic room, and this reduced his power and range.

In other words, use your damn imagination.

You got the impression? Sorry I just cannot make up things about movie sin my mind in an effort to making said movie better. I don't work that way. Very cool for you though, that you do! YAY

 

[LongDong]

Hmmm. Ok Long Dong I find it odd that one of the big complaints is the logistics of how Magneto could pull a jet out of the sky but not escape from his plastic cell. Well I ask you then in The Last Stand how can he move the entire golden gate bridge to alcatraz and then march his expendeble "pawns" across it but he cannot just land the bridge on top of the building itself crushing and killing everyone inside, including leach and complete the objective without so much sacrifice of his beloved mutant "brothers". Or just use the large ammount of metal in and around the building to take out all of his opponents. I only bring this up because you seem to like The Last Stand more and sited among other things logistical problems involving magneto. I believe these also exist quite prominatly in the climax of the last stand.

Good point, but I personally find fewer flaws with X3 than I did with X2. I was pleased they finally nailed wolverine and Storm right. Beast was awesome, Iceman was better, Juggernaut ruled and Pheonix was smokin hot

 

[Level7]

story wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
application of story
1-x2
2-x1
3-x3
critic wise
1-x2
2-x3
3-x1
action wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
effects wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
acting wise
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1
my favourite
1-x3
2-x2
3-x1

Nothing personal but the critics enjoy X1 more than they have X3
And How can you think X3 had the best acting? Halle Berry is a terrible actress and did her worst performance in this film.

 

[Obsidian]

Good point, but I personally find fewer flaws with X3 than I did with X2. I was pleased they finally nailed wolverine and Storm right. Beast was awesome, Iceman was better, Juggernaut ruled and Pheonix was smokin hot

They didn't really nail Wolverine or Storm. Wolverine was turned to a generic action hero who happens to be practically God with his unlimited rapid healing factor. Storm was just given more lines and shown with more of her powers.

 

[Nathan]

Oh no, he didn't... Please tell me he didn't just say they nailed Wolverine and Storm right... Someone tell me he didn't!

 

[Angry Sentinel]

Oh no, he didn't... Please tell me he didn't just say they nailed Wolverine and Storm right... Someone tell me he didn't!

Hold on, I got it

Good point, but I personally find a slew of flaws with X3 than I did with X2. I was pleased they finally derailed wolverine and Storm right? Beast was awesome, Iceman was better, Juggernaut fooled and Pheonix was smokin hot... without phoenix flames

Fixed.

 

[LongDong]

Oh no, he didn't... Please tell me he didn't just say they nailed Wolverine and Storm right... Someone tell me he didn't!

Oh yes I did, X2 had him SO wrong that any improvement made can be construed as nailing it. Singer butchered the franchise and it is on the way to being repaired.

 

[LongDong]

Hold on, I got it


Fixed.

How creative of you

 

[HighVoltage]

1. X-Men 3
2. X-Men
3. X2

My same thought, High Voltage.

 

[Obsidian]

Oh yes I did, X2 had him SO wrong that any improvement made can be construed as nailing it. Singer butchered the franchise and it is on the way to being repaired.

There was no improvement in the character of Wolverine in X-Men 3. He was just turned into a two dimensional demigod.

 

[Sl2005]

1. X-Men: United
2. X-Men: The Last Stand
3. X-Men

 

[grey_jeanie]

1. X-Men: United
2. X-Men: The Last Stand
3. X-Men

same

 

[Decay]

1. X-Men: United
2. X-Men: The Last Stand
3. X-Men

same...