I loved the original New Mario (DS). But the console New Mario games (Wii and Wii U) are not the same as the (IMO) much better handheld New Marios. I tried New Mario U at that event I went to and it is really more of the same New Mario Wii schtick, which I didn't like.
And even though I do love the portable DS New Mario, after Mario 3D Land, I'd much rather have another one of those over more New Mario, DS, 3DS, Wii or U...the 3DS sequel was again more of the same...and with the number reaching installment 4 there's really nothing "new" about NSMB...