A Theory of Nathan and 5 Years Gone.

[RonStoppablefan]

I have a theory that Nathan will get his head sliced opean at the end of the Volume. I think it will be right as soon as Nathan is saying sorry to every one about what he's done. Think about it, would cause suspense, make every one hate Syler agian. Maybe would cause more tension between Peter and Syler adding up to a big battle between them in Volume 5 possibly. Would get Present Peter to turn into Future Peter slowly, maybe Peters storyline in Volume 5 could be trying to hunt down Syler and try to kill him. It would give them both intresting storylines for Volume 5. What do you think of my theory? They did say

Spoiler

Two people are going to die at the end of the Volume.

Nathan was killed in 5 Years Gone by Syler, since that story has been coming true I just though it'd be intresting if this happened.

 

[chaseter]

I want Nathan to die so yes. I also think that a Peter vs Sylar finale battle would be good as well because one of those two needs to die as much as Nathan does. I would say kill Peter because the writers are butchering both but Peter is much weaker and the Petrelli family story has been told.

 

[Frank]

I have a theory that Nathan will get his head sliced opean at the end of the Volume. I think it will be right as soon as Nathan is saying sorry to every one about what he's done. Think about it, would cause suspense, make every one hate Syler agian. Maybe would cause more tension between Peter and Syler adding up to a big battle between them in Volume 5 possibly. Would get Present Peter to turn into Future Peter slowly, maybe Peters storyline in Volume 5 could be trying to hunt down Syler and try to kill him. It would give them both intresting storylines for Volume 5. What do you think of my theory? They did say

Spoiler

Two people are going to die at the end of the Volume.

Nathan was killed in 5 Years Gone by Syler, since that story has been coming true I just though it'd be intresting if this happened.

I doubt 5 Years Gone will come true. Nikki is dead and she was there. DL is dead so Sylar can't get his powers.. stuff like that.

 

[RonStoppablefan]

Wo, wo, wo Nicki was dead? Wasn't it Jessica was dead? And I don't recall Syler even having DL's powers in that future, Peter did but I don't think he used it in that time line. Maybe Claudes powers but you can change powers in futures.

 

[Lando7763]

In "Five Years Gone," Jessica was dead, and Nikki took on her name as her stage name. Sylar, as Nathan, did use DL's power; right before the Sylar/Peter hallway fight tease. He grabs someone through the same door that Mohinder barricaded, to buy Hiro enough time escape to the present.

 

[bullets]

I doubt it will turn otu anything like we expect. It would be full circle but I don't see it happening. I also don't think they would ever kill Peter or Sylar ( at least not for good)

 

[RonStoppablefan]

In "Five Years Gone," Jessica was dead, and Nikki took on her name as her stage name. Sylar, as Nathan, did use DL's power; right before the Sylar/Peter hallway fight tease. He grabs someone through the same door that Mohinder barricaded, to buy Hiro enough time escape to the present.

Wo I forgot about the grabbing Peter threw the door scene, well like I said before some things can change in the future. Powers can change and even a few of the storylines can change. But I do think some how Nathan will get his head sliced opean by Syler and end in a Peter V.S Syler fight. Maybe Nathans hunter will kill Luke, making Syler revengful, slicing opean Nathans head which would make Peter angry. Anrgy/Vengeful Peter=Future Peter and boom you have nearly 5 Years Gone only without the bomb explosion a few changes.

 

[StrainedEyes]

Peter needs to get his scar eventually.

 

[Matt]

Even if it does come true, its not really five years gone. Too much has changed. What will be the similarities? Sylar (disguised as Nathan) is president? That's just about where it would end unless the writers work over time to put everything in place and at this point it would just feel forced because we've gotten to know the characters better (Can anyone really see Parkman as an evil agent of Sylar? Or Claire actually obeying HRG and being a small town hick waitress?)