Article Naming "Smallville" As Best Incarnation Of Superman Since 1978

BareKnucklez

Civilian
Joined
Nov 30, 2005
Messages
958
Reaction score
0
Points
11
Superman has always been a hero of television



This weekend, millions of Americans rushed to theaters to see Superman in his so-called return. Critics and audiences welcomed him with open arms, going on and on about how much he was missed and asking why it took so long for him to get back.

Get back? When did he leave?

Sure, Superman IV: The Quest for Peace hurtled the big-screen franchise into the sun in 1987, thanks to a cheesy plot and ho-hum script. But, on the small screen, the Man of Steel has been fighting for truth and justice ever since.

And, in most cases, he's been doing it better than some his big-screen counterparts.

Just a year after the Superman IV fiasco, Ilya Salkind, who had produced each of the Christopher Reeve films, tried to both profit from and distance himself from the series by launching Superboy, a syndicated, hour-long drama about a young, fully powered Clark Kent.

Actor John Haymes Newton played Clark in the show's first season, which was pretty terrible. But after Gerard Christopher replaced Newton for the final three seasons, the show improved slightly. In fact, the low-budget, mediocre Superboy, with its late-'80s-adventure-show charms, served as a fine stopgap for the fans still smarting from Superman IV who wanted to keep getting their hero fix until the really good TV shows began.

Starting in 1993.

Looking back, I guess I was predisposed to liking Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman, which debuted that year on ABC. It co-starred Teri Hatcher, after all, whom I'd first crushed on during her frequent guest spots on MacGyver. Still, I was charmed - like most of the country - by Hatcher's immediate chemistry with co-star Dean Cain as the two morphed the Superman mythos into a fiery romantic comedy.

Since the show concentrated on Clark more than his alter ego, Cain eschewed much of the clumsy and shy stereotype Reeve had perfected in his movies. Instead, Cain made Clark a smirky Boy Scout who grounded Hatcher's professionally confident but emotionally insecure Lois.

Yes, the show famously dove-tailed once the two got hitched in the fourth and final season (another classic case of fans not knowing what they really want), but by then, I had moved on to yet another Superman adventure.

In 1996, four years after his Batman: The Animated Series revolutionized the way superhero cartoons were perceived, animator Bruce Timm worked his magic on the Man of Steel. Airing on Saturday mornings, Superman: The Animated Series suffered early from comparisons to Batman's more noirish show. (Unfortunately, when the two get compared, dark and broody Batman almost always earns more cool points than high-and-mighty Supes.) But Timm's devotion to strong storytelling and interesting characters (Wings star Tim Daly voiced Superman, by the way) allowed the show to establish its own identity.

More importantly, though, a string of guest appearances by other heroes in the show's final season paved the way for Superman's greatest animated show to date - Justice League. Launched in 2001, the show featured the Man of Steel teamed up with Batman, The Flash, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern and a slew of other DC comics heroes. Way more than a revamp of the campy Superfriends show from the late '70s, the new series (which added characters and the word Unlimited to its title in later seasons) also offered Superman his best stories.

It's easy to give Superman giant baddies to smash, but Justice League, which aired on Cartoon Network, also gave him personal demons to battle, especially when he bickered with the morally nebulous Batman. Clearly aimed at grown-up fanboys like myself, the show aired as late as 10:30 p.m. before finally signing off earlier this year.

Younger fans, though, still had other options. Cartoon Network launched Krypto the Superdog, a spunky animated series about a human boy who adopts Superman's Kryptonian mutt, in 2005. Aimed at grade-schoolers, the vibrant show featured such characters as Streaky the Supercat.

It was teenagers, though, who should be credited with keeping Superman relevant these past few years. Without them, the young-adult skewing WB network would never have found success with Smallville.

Launching in the fall of 2001, almost a month before Justice League premiered, the show quickly established a formula that would woo die-hard fans and Superman newcomers for five seasons (and counting). In the world of Smallville, which has Clark Kent growing up in modern times, there are superpowers, yes, but no tights. And while superhuman leaps aren't out of the question, flying certainly is. And just when the show seems to get too caught up in alien plans for world domination that can only be stopped by some superhuman feats, it cuts to the tragic, star-crossed love story of young Clark (Tom Welling) and Lana Lang (Kristin Kreuk).

In the pilot episode, after noticing Clark is reading a book by Nietzsche, Lana asks him, "So, what are you, Clark? Man or Superman?" Thankfully, Smallville, which moves to the new CWnetwork this fall, doesn't make him choose.

The show's ability to explore both sides of our hero's character is what gives Smallville its power - and what makes it the best Superman saga since 1978. On any sized screen.

Contact Jeff at 343-2371 or [email protected].
 
Pff. Smallville is argueably the best live adaptation on the small screen, but when it comes to Supes adaptations in every form of the medium, nothing can touch Superman: The Animated Series. And that includes Donner's original film.
 
Good article.:up:

I agree with it, my wife read that article and she was like "well, duh."
It made me laugh.:)

Only thing is, Lois and Clark so does not get the respect it deserves, the show was so charming.:O
 
Brainiac 8 said:
Good article.:up:

I agree with it, my wife read that article and she was like "well, duh."
It made me laugh.:)

Only thing is, Lois and Clark so does not get the respect it deserves, the show was so charming.:O

True about L & C. I doubt there will ever be a Perry White as great as Lane Smith. Best Perry ever.
 
i agree B8 (as if i wouldnt) but did you notice the shows demise began when teri cut her hair? same thing with Felicity. maybe the american viewing public isnt ready for short haired series female stars.
 
ppffftttt, that sissy clark in smallville will never grow up to be a legendary superhero unless chloe joins the justice league with him....

:o:o
 
Hmmm. you may be onto something there Kaboom...it was quite a change when she made her hair so short. I think the frog eating clone arc is what turned off alot of viewers though. It's not so bad to watch back to back on DVD, but it was much more frustrating to watch on a weekly basis.:O

and Yes, Lane Smith was the best Perry White ever.:up:

I would have loved to have seen Hugh Laurie play Perry like he was supposed to. I'm ok with him not doing it though, because now we have one of the best shows on tv with "House".:up: :)
 
November Rain said:
ppffftttt, that sissy clark in smallville will never grow up to be a legendary superhero unless chloe joins the justice league with him....

:o:o



:rolleyes: Alrighty then.


ventura.large.jpg
 
I think Smallville kinda wins by default cause yeah there have been tons of Superman projects on TV whereas any chance for another Superman movie (even the current one) is always overshadowed by Christopher Reeve because it's the movies and movies tend to have more prestige and icongraphy for a character compared to TV. But Smallville while having flaws makes a bold and more creative approach to the mythology.




























































With that said Christian Bale as Batman would still **** him up....
 
November Rain said:
ppffftttt, that sissy clark in smallville will never grow up to be a legendary superhero unless chloe joins the justice league with him....

:o:o

AlbSnorkel.jpg
 
Milk that for all it's worth Kaboom. Odin just sounds bitter.
 
Just an aside: You guys(and girls) do get the "Alburqurque. Snorkel." reference right?
 
Alright. Imagine if you were youre name was Justin Bartha, and you were standing across from Nic Cage who wsa saying something like:

"...by iron pen. Mr. Matlack can't offend..........it's iron....its strong..."

and someone else chimes in."Prison. Iron Pen means prison."

and You (as Justin Bartha) says. "Albuquerque. Snorkel. See i can do it too."

if i've still lost you , its from National treasure. the point is, and the reason i make the reference on these boards is often times as we're discussing a topic, somebody will pop in with some variation of "smallville stinks" and usually keeps it a short remark like that without any supporting reason. so i like to say "Albuquerque. Snorkel." just as a demonstration that just because something is said so matter of ffactly, doesnt make it true or relevant.

if you still dont get it, go watch the scene its in the first 10 minutes of the movie or so, hopefully, you'll get it then.
 
Kaboom said:
Alright. Imagine if you were youre name was Justin Bartha, and you were standing across from Nic Cage who wsa saying something like:

"...by iron pen. Mr. Matlack can't offend..........it's iron....its strong..."

and someone else chimes in."Prison. Iron Pen means prison."

and You (as Justin Bartha) says. "Albuquerque. Snorkel. See i can do it too."

if i've still lost you , its from National treasure. the point is, and the reason i make the reference on these boards is often times as we're discussing a topic, somebody will pop in with some variation of "smallville stinks" and usually keeps it a short remark like that without any supporting reason. so i like to say "Albuquerque. Snorkel." just as a demonstration that just because something is said so matter of ffactly, doesnt make it true or relevant.

if you still dont get it, go watch the scene its in the first 10 minutes of the movie or so, hopefully, you'll get it then.

I didn't remember that it was from National Treasure, but I figured that was the context you were going for - in response to people just blurting out random "Smallville SUX" comments.

I think I'm going to start shouting back, "FREEBIRD! WHOO!"

heh.
 
What's scary Kaboom, is I did get it.:confused: :O

I love that movie though, by far one of Cage's best.:up:
 
Brainiac 8 said:
What's scary Kaboom, is I did get it.:confused: :O

I love that movie though, by far one of Cage's best.:up:

That's another one that I always fall asleep during while I'm watching. :O

And I didnt get your joke either Kaboom, but that often happens with me. :o
 
well know everybody knows, so when i say it again, we all know what im talking about. and knowing is half the battle!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"