• The upgrade to XenForo 2.3.7 has now been completed. Please report any issues to our administrators.

At the Mountains of Madness - Guillermo Del Toro's Next Project!

Status
Not open for further replies.
yeah shoot a movie as R and then editing it is not the way to go

He could easily shoot the scenes that might have a bit of gore then shoot it a bit differently for the theatrical version.
 
He could easily shoot the scenes that might have a bit of gore then shoot it a bit differently for the theatrical version.
Thanks for increasing the budget a few million. :up:
 
I wish there was a way to release both a PG and Rated R version of the same movie if the ratings was such a big deal. I think a director said something about that being a good idea.
 
Yup, I'll be crapping my pants. By the way, did you read the script Piper? Because the ending of the script is I believe different from the original story ;)
 
So wait, the creature designs from ILM are so terrifying that the movie automatically gets an R-rating? I don't know if I buy that...
 
I don't see why any of the concepts needed to make this work couldn't be accomplished with a PG-13 rating.Lovecraft didn't need gore and cursing and sex to make his concepts work, why would Del Toro. The fact that this is moving again is excellent news.
 
I don't see why any of the concepts needed to make this work couldn't be accomplished with a PG-13 rating.Lovecraft didn't need gore and cursing and sex to make his concepts work, why would Del Toro. The fact that this is moving again is excellent news.

I agree. I don't think ANYTHING Lovecraft ever wrote was R-rated. There's a difference between what is implied and imagined by your own mind as opposed to what's actually on the page or screen. I'll argue that if you removed the F-word and the nudity from The Shining, I'm not sure why it would need to be R-rated on content alone. And if you argued that tone/theme/suggestion warrants an R, The Ring would be a hard, hard R. Poltergeist was PG, for christ's sake. The Walking Dead is on basic cable and goes lightyears beyond what is acceptable in a PG-13 film. My point is, the inconsistencies in American content ratings are painfully noticeable and largely a joke. Del Toro could EASILY make the film PG-13.
 
The Shoggoths would probably be too creepy & extreme for PG 13, depends on how they do it though, but the way they're described in the script is something else. It's The Thing like but more f*** up in my opinion.
 
R-rated adaptions would probably fit the stories from his early period, the "macabre era". The "Cthulhu cycle" stories are not so much R-rated but I cannot see them adapted as big movies. I think it would be possible with AtMoM, but I think it has also the danger of becoming a very generic monster movie.
 
Yeah, I don't think adapting Lovecraft or Shakespeare or Poe is really going to get you big box office numbers anymore. That ship has sailed. As a result, you won't get a huge budget because the studio assumes it'll bomb, and they won't let it be rated beyond PG-13 because they want as many people in the theater as possible. Welcome to the age of the Teenage Sci-Fi Franchise (almost every movie that exists now, minus the Oscar bait in the Fourth Quarter).
 
Yup, I'll be crapping my pants. By the way, did you read the script Piper? Because the ending of the script is I believe different from the original story ;)

Oh yeah, I've read the script and I absolutely loved it. It still gives me goosebumps whenever I read it. And the ending with the hooded figure gives you the impression of impending doom.
 
Last edited:
The big issue with adapting this story is it's influence on other films like Prometheus and The Thing. The GA probably think "Mountains" ripped off those films.
 
Most of the horror in Lovecraft's works come from the buildup of tension and the overbearing sense of dread. Really, save for a couple of moments in the novella, Mountains is easily doable in a PG-13 film. And those couple of moments can be filmed in such a way that the gore isn't so explicit or graphic.

We've got horror movies out nowadays sneaking away with a PG-13 rating. Can't see why this one couldn't as well.

At this point, I just want this movie made damnit. Anything to wash the taste of Pacific Rim out of my mouth.

Haha, I'm with you there.

But just watch. Del Toro will cast Charlie Hunnam and Ron Perlman in this thing. :cmad:
 
Hey man Hunnam can act his ass off. I wouldnt be opposed to him in this.
 
Are you just judging that off PAcific Rim. Because he's great on Sons of Anarchy and I liked him in Green Street Hooligans
 
I hope we see imagery like this in the film;
tumblr_mrophw9sc51sp5rz9o2_1280_zps63a6d1c7.jpg


Mountains_of_madness__Attack_by_MarcSimonetti_zps673683e6.jpg
 
Having just read the script, There is an exponential amount of gore added to the story. Things are gonna have to be rewritten. And believe it or not, the descriptions of the Shoggoths alone, would land this thing an R rating.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"