World Battles: Round 9

[ZombieONE]

Jean Grey vs Magneto

VS

ok, remember this is Jean Grey from X2 not Dark Phoenix from X3.

WINNER: JEAN GREY

 

[Pizzaboy1138]

Magneto can use metal, but Jean could try to change his mind.

 

[WorthyStevens]

Jean. Magneto was in complete fear of her by the end of X3.

 

[PowersOfMind]

Jean definitely. He can only manipulate metal. She can manipulate...anything.

 

[Avalanche]

If we're talking pre-Phoenix Jean, then Magneto gets my vote. I debate her being able to fend of all he has to throw at her.

Phoenix Jean is obviously another matter.

 

[Deep Thinkin'!]

Jean.
Magneto - metal
Jean - everything
You can't compare.
Plus, with Mag's helmet off........ he's a goner

 

[LEX]

Are you kidding me?

Jean

Magneto = metal-manipulator
Jean = everything-manipulator

 

[Avalanche]

I still think Magneto stands a good chance. Before the effects of the Phoenix, we saw Jean do very little with her powers. In X1 Toad took her out with ease. In X2, though her power expanded, she wasn't capable of any spectacular feats of the level Magneto was. Magneto could stop the plane from crashing, where as Jean's powers didn't allow her to do so.

Obviously, without metal, Magneto is ruined.

 

[Farren]

Jean. Magneto was in complete fear of her by the end of X3.

Exactly

 

[LEX]

I still think Magneto stands a good chance. Before the effects of the Phoenix, we saw Jean do very little with her powers. In X1 Toad took her out with ease. In X2, though her power expanded, she wasn't capable of any spectacular feats of the level Magneto was. Magneto could stop the plane from crashing, where as Jean's powers didn't allow her to do so.

Obviously, without metal, Magneto is ruined.

Well, we are talking about X3 Jean, aren't we?

 

[PowersOfMind]

Leaving out the reference to movie Jean. I think that if Jean were fighing for her lfe she would surly whip Mags ass.

 

[JeanGrey12]

Jean easily. He can manipulate metal. She can move anything. I'm talking before the phoenix as well.

I think this is a good idea, but some of the pair ups don't really make sense...oo well. Its fun though.

Jean Grey Rocks

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

For Jean! For Jean! ... She can manipulate anything.

 

[Avalanche]

Well, we are talking about X3 Jean, aren't we?

The main post says we're voting for X2 Jean, and not X3 Phoenix.

 

[LEX]

The main post says we're voting for X2 Jean, and not X3 Phoenix.

My bad. I didn't see that part.

My decision still stands.

 

[Phoenix342]

jean all the way but it wont be her easiest battle to fight

 

[bcd90]

Magneto could stop the plane from crashing, where as Jean's powers didn't allow her to do so.

Not true, in the book it said she could have easily lifted the plain up as well as herself, but she chose not to.

 

[bcd90]

Ok if we are talking movie Jean (before Pheonix) vs movie Magneto then surely Magneto would win. If Jean could whoop him, then why didnt she step out of the car at the train station and destroy him? She just sat in the car doing nothing. I think movie Jean can only move things with her mind that she would be able to move with her hands. Her telekinesis is weak, she couldnt even levitate logan to Magnetos machine. Storm had to fly him over while she steadies him. And in X2 she became a bit more powerful but still not enough to beat Magneto.

 

[Kmack]

Magneto

 

[micky-fox]

If this is pre-Phoenix...

Magneto, definitely. Not only could he lob multiple cars or buildings at her, he could also stop the flow of blood in her body. His power dominates Jean Grey's.

 

[Juggertha]

Jean, if she could be bloody enough.

 

[Iceman]

Jean before the Phoenix influence (which is really only X1) was too timid to use her powers to their full potential. Magneto is the most powerful mutant in these films if you take away Phoenix.

 

[Decay]

If you are talking about the movie characters then Jean would be the winner without a doubt.

 

[Avalanche]

Not true, in the book it said she could have easily lifted the plain up as well as herself, but she chose not to.

The books aren't always reliable for what happened in the movie. See Jean being blind.

Why would Jean choose not to save the plane from crashing? Choose not to save herself and the other X-Men from certain death?

 

[Bastila]

Jean can just read his mind and know what he is planning to do or make him do things by controlling his mind. She can beat him without Phoenix power anyway ....go Jean.