Beast should have had some dialogue with Magneto--

javon said:
It's a shame, because since Storm wasn't even in the lab when Xavier mentioned that Jean had a duel personality by the name "Phoenix", then she doesn't know the name at all. Thus, she wouldn't have said "Phoenix" in her sentence. Ain't that amazing?

:huh: All she said was "And Jean".

In the novelization she is with Xavier and Logon in the infirmary when Xavier explains the Phoenix dual personality stuff. So in a earlier version of the script she probably was present in the scene.

and

javon said:
I'm not saying that she didn't care for her, just that she didn't show any affection.

it was wierd, cause when Logan was packing and Storm did her whole "Shes gone Logan and shes not coming back" not caring thing, and then when Logan gets back her tone is suddenly all concerned like she does care now "You found her?"

Thats one thing, Halle Berry's acting from scene to scene is very inconsistant. Her voice tone too,
(horrendless so in X1, the accent was constently shifting and it was like she was alternating between 3 different accents, and not in a realistic way)

does this make Halle a bad actress? I feel bad, cause i like her and she seems nice but...
 
xii22_loop said:
it was wierd cause when Logan was packing and Storm did her whole "Shes gone Logan and shes not coming back" not caring thing, and then when Logan gets back her tone is suddenly all concerned like she does care now "You found her?"

Like javon said, he went to the encampment to find Jean. Of course she would ask him if he found her. And if you actually watched the packing scene, Storm says: "She killed the Professor. She made her choice." To me that clearly is a line from someone who doesn't care for that person.

xii22_loop said:
Thatsone thing, Berry's acting from scene to scene is very inconsistant. Her voice tone too, (horrendless so in X1, the accent was constently shifting and it was like she was alternating between 3 different accents, and not in a realistic way)

Well after filming X1, Singer decided to pull Storm's accent, although it can still be heard on some lines. That's probably why you thought you heard alternate accents.

xii22_loop said:
does this make Halle a bad actress? I feel bad, cause i like her and she seems nice but...

Personally, I thought Halle did her best job of the trilogy in X3. She finally a decent role in the film, her own opinions, and took charge when things were looking down. It was just the lack of character development that let her down. If we had heard about her past in Africa etc, more of her lines eg. "What kind of coward would take this cure just to fit in?" would have made sense.

Again, the writers let her down again. With more opinions, she really needed reasons behind it. But they didn't deliver.
 
Beast and Jean, Beast and Magneto, Beast and Mystique, Beast and anybody talking would have been great.
 
i know they dropped the accent for X1, i'm not confused. It was just an inconsitent accent, whatever its probably hard to do.

from x1, compare the ''logan, you can't do this alone"
to the "i can't control it like that" when shes abotu to blow Logan up to Rogue.

also the deleted scene where Sorm talks to Rogue after a lesson and says "I don't think there are very many places like this"

immm not trying to start a halle bash, but a question: I guess it is normal for somebody who speaks different languages to have a on and off high and low sort of accent to their voice.
But i agree the writers let her down, but i personally like her as Storm.
 
chaseter said:
Beast and Jean, Beast and Magneto, Beast and Mystique, Beast and anybody talking would have been great.

beast to Mystique - "its a shame what they did to you my dear, you looked much better blue" lol
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"