Best SNL alum

[triplefive]

Um, seriously?

Kattan:
1) Corky Romano
2) Night at the Roxbury

Schneider:
1) Deuce Bigalow
2) The Hot Chick

Has Tracy Morgan even had any starring roles?

And Fallon was bad enough on SNL to begin with.

 

[The Chairman]

And Fallon was bad enough on SNL to begin with.

Fallon has one good role, in my favorite movie, Almost Famous. But it's because the role is similar to himself: obnoxious and unwanted.

 

[jrpstarwars]

Um, seriously?

Kattan:
1) Corky Romano
2) Night at the Roxbury

Schneider:
1) Deuce Bigalow
2) The Hot Chick

Has Tracy Morgan even had any starring roles?

And Fallon was bad enough on SNL to begin with.

Wasn't everyones 'flavor of the month' Will Farrell in Roxbury??? Wasn't he in Bewitched also??? Yeah, he's alot more talented than KAttan

 

[triplefive]

1) yes.

2) we're comparing movie careers here. do you seriously think kattan's career can stand up to ferrell's?

 

[cryptic name]

Um, seriously?

Kattan:
1) Corky Romano
2) Night at the Roxbury

Schneider:
1) Deuce Bigalow
2) The Hot Chick

Has Tracy Morgan even had any starring roles?

And Fallon was bad enough on SNL to begin with.

hey, hey, Schneider was also in Surf Ninjas. and that movie is incredible.

 

[Warhammer]

Bill Murray.
Eddie Murphy.

 

[jrpstarwars]

1) yes.

2) we're comparing movie careers here. do you seriously think kattan's career can stand up to ferrell's?

Ferrell got his because he is a tall, goofy gump who acts like a child. What pisses me off is all these people ripping Sandlers movies and praising Ferrell's. I would almost put money on Sandler's movie career outlasting
Will 'The Dill' Ferrell.

 

[triplefive]

... but you were talking about kattan just a second ago. i'm not arguing with you about sandler.

i gave him a vote, too.

 

[jrpstarwars]

... but you were talking about kattan just a second ago. i'm not arguing with you about sandler.

i gave him a vote, too.

Not you, but there is a lot of Adam Sandler bashing on here.

As for Kattan, if he was Ferrell's size and Ferrell his the roles would be reversed.

 

[co2]

This is a Hella hard one to answer. Though there are those that I like much better, I was forced to give it to Dan Akroyd..only because he wrote and starred in Blues Brothers and Ghost Busters, two of the greatest comedies of all time. He also wrote Gross Point Blank and..er..Coneheads..among many others. So he gets my vote based more on his talents as a creator rather than a comedic performer.
One that I just DO NOT like, that actually had some major success post SNL was Chevy Chase. He made a ton of movies.....two of which were actually funny.
But my favorites would be Chris Farely, Mike Myers, Dana Carvey, Phil Hartman, Will Ferrell, and of course Bill Murray

 

[jrpstarwars]

This is a Hella hard one to answer. Though there are those that I like much better, I was forced to give it to Dan Akroyd..only because he wrote and starred in Blues Brothers and Ghost Busters, two of the greatest comedies of all time. He also wrote Gross Point Blank and..er..Coneheads..among many others. So he gets my vote based more on his talents as a creator rather than a comedic performer.
One that I just DO NOT like, that actually had some major success post SNL was Chevy Chase. He made a ton of movies.....two of which were actually funny.
But my favorites would be Chris Farely, Mike Myers, Dana Carvey, Phil Hartman, Will Ferrell, and of course Bill Murray

Akroyd is a good choice brother,rock on!!!

 

[jrpstarwars]

TOP 5 THUSFAR:
1. Bill Murray 17 (expected it)
2. Will Ferrell 13 (I strongly disagree)
3. Mike Myers 10 (no prob with this choice)
4. Dan Akroyd 7 (like Murray, expected)
5. Chris Farley, Eddie Murphy 6 (this fits)

 

[Speedball]

Farley was never an Alum, since he died a part of the cast.
Ben Stiller was never a part of the SNL cast, So why is he even up there?

I voted for Carvey, Myers, Ackroyd, Chase, Murray, Curtain, Lovitz and Nealon.
I would have voted for Downey as well, but I don't think of him as a really important cast member, since he was only there for one year.

And Where in the hell is Julia Louis-Dreyfus???

 

[The Chairman]

Farley was never an Alum, since he died a part of the cast.
Ben Stiller was never a part of the SNL cast, So why is he even up there?

I voted for Carvey, Myers, Ackroyd, Chase, Murray, Curtain, Lovitz and Nealon.
I would have voted for Downey as well, but I don't think of him as a really important cast member, since he was only there for one year.

And Where in the hell is Julia Louis-Dreyfus???

Farley died AFTER he left the show, not while he was a cast member.

Stiller was on for a very brief period as a supporting player during the 1988-1989 season.

Dreyfuss has had a successful television career, but not in film, which is what the choices of the poll are based on.

 

[Speedball]

Farley died AFTER he left the show, not while he was a cast member.

Stiller was on for a very brief period as a supporting player during the 1988-1989 season.

Dreyfuss has had a successful television career, but not in film, which is what the choices of the poll are based on.

She was in Christmas Vacation and A Bug's Life

 

[The Chairman]

She was in Christmas Vacation and A Bug's Life

She had a relatively minor role in CV (a great one, though). Yeah, she had A Bug's Life, but she's nowhere in the same league with Murray, Myers, Murphy and Aykroyd.

 

[Speedball]

ummm...wow...over-react much?
He wasn't talking to you btw.

 

[triplefive]

ROFL, why are you so ridiculously defensive?

You're not going to make it long here.

 

[Spider-X]

... genius...

for those playing the homegame... it t'was a joke...

 

[jrpstarwars]

ROFL, why are you so ridiculously defensive?

You're not going to make it long here.

I'm not defensive, YOU ARE!!!

 

[Gonking]

Ben Stiller

 

[WorthyStevens]

I'll ride the bandwagon and also say Bill Murray and Will Ferrell. Chris Farley as well.


But no love for Cheri Oteri?

 

[Warhammer]

Somebody's angry....

 

[co2]

I'll ride the bandwagon and also say Bill Murray and Will Ferrell. Chris Farley as well.


But no love for Cheri Oteri?

In my opinion, she is among the best cast the show ever had...but post SNL success?...has she done anything besides the first Scary Movie?

 

[Karea07]

Thank god Jimmy Fallon has no votes. He is by far one of the worst and untalented actors i've ever seen.