• The upgrade to XenForo 2.3.7 has now been completed. Please report any issues to our administrators.

Bought/Thought for August 13, 2008; SPOILERS INSIDE!

If there was internal conflict over Don delivering the baby rather than Thor staying in Asgard, we probably should have seen it, don't you think? Fraction glossed over it if he intended there to be any conflict in the first place. I can come up with reasons why Don delivering the baby would be a better use of their time, at least to Don and Thor, but that doesn't stop it from coming off kind of pat and lame in the issue itself. It was clearly a way to excuse Thor from the action, since he's at such a power level now that he, along with all of the Asgardians, would make short work of any Skrull attack on Asgard, and it read as such. I like Fraction's work, don't get me wrong; I just think this particular issue has a lot of flaws.

As for SI, really, we've waited a pretty long time for the reunion between Thor, Iron Man, and Cap already. Bendis set it up at the end of the last issue, so logically we would expect to read the actual event itself in this issue, right? This issue reads as some weird diversion. I'm not arguing that Reed's return wasn't necessary--there's just a place and time for it. This was the place and time for Thor and Bucky to join the fray, but Bendis didn't make it happen. I guess it may have been meant to build suspense, but the suspense was already there; this is just obnoxious.

I'm just happy that we got a Thor: SI tie-in to explain where he's been this whole time. I really think the whole reason Thor isn't going to be with Asgard is because he planned to appear in NY to help the other heroes. Thus the purpose of the tie-in and the things that happened in it.

And honestly? I don't want to see Thor, Iron Man and Cap show up with 3 issues still left in the mini-series. You know they'd frickin' make short work of these Skrulls PLUS they'll have Nick Fury, who (now that I think about it) I'm really interested in seeing interact with Buck-Cap.

Now that Reed has that De-Skrullifier, we finally get to see all of the heroes fighting together against a common enemy, which really is the climax.
 
I think all of SI: Thor is the reason why he decides to go to New York and help the other heroes. He was trying to stay out of the affairs of petty superheroes and watch over his own people and Earth as a whole, but it becomes clear when the Skrulls attack Asgard that the other heroes' affairs directly affect him and his people.
 
You're right, but you and I both know that Thor would have been there from the start back in the old days or older days rather. He, Cap and Iron Man would all be in New York right now, as Avengers fighting this thing.
 
I wouldn't mind Meggan coming back.

Pete Wisdom's been working for government agencies for, like, his entire existence. He's been attached to the current MI agency since New Excalibur, at least. I think he was New Excalibur's liaison or something.

When he joined old excalibur he defected from Black Air to them and when he was with X Factor he turned them into a Black Ops unit to stop the type of people goverments wouldn't go after. I don't mind his working for queen and country now.

I wouldn't mind meggan back as a supportin character but not on the team. Whats Betsy up to these days?

I don't think every hero should be the punisher or something but some heros should kill not because they want to or go out of their way to kill villains but as a final option.

Most of the heros have been killing skrulls like its going out of fashion lately. Apperantly killing aliens fine, killing humans bad
 
Noone has read SI: Inhumans yet? :(

I won't get mine until tomorrow, and I'll try to give you a review of it. The Inhumans mini is supposed to lead into the next cosmic event, so it should be a must read for us Annihilation fans. :cmad:

Inhumans SI was pretty good. Par for the course Skrull wise.

I'll keep picking it up b/c:

Black Bolt is alive and is being held by the Skrulls. They want to use him as a weapon. What doesn't make sense is why he just doesn't speak, rip apart the ship that's holding him, and get out of there. The Skrulls claim to be close to finding a way to use his power. So that would mean they haven't yet so Bolt should speak up and tear the place up.
But I too am looking fwd to Black Bolt vs Vulcan.
 
Noone has read SI: Inhumans yet? :(

I won't get mine until tomorrow, and I'll try to give you a review of it. The Inhumans mini is supposed to lead into the next cosmic event, so it should be a must read for us Annihilation fans. :cmad:
I've read it, I just haven't done my review yet.
 
You're right, but you and I both know that Thor would have been there from the start back in the old days or older days rather. He, Cap and Iron Man would all be in New York right now, as Avengers fighting this thing.
Well, yeah, but we're so far removed from the old days that they're irrelevant at this point, unfortunately.
When he joined old excalibur he defected from Black Air to them and when he was with X Factor he turned them into a Black Ops unit to stop the type of people goverments wouldn't go after. I don't mind his working for queen and country now.

I wouldn't mind meggan back as a supportin character but not on the team. Whats Betsy up to these days?
She's in New Exiles because Claremont is apparently in love with her and takes her from comic to comic as he goes.

I know about Pete's history with government agencies. I just meant that he's been back with the government for so long now that making a big deal of it would seem pretty out of place.
 
When he joined old excalibur he defected from Black Air to them and when he was with X Factor he turned them into a Black Ops unit to stop the type of people goverments wouldn't go after. I don't mind his working for queen and country now.

I wouldn't mind meggan back as a supportin character but not on the team. Whats Betsy up to these days?

I don't think every hero should be the punisher or something but some heros should kill not because they want to or go out of their way to kill villains but as a final option.

Most of the heros have been killing skrulls like its going out of fashion lately. Apperantly killing aliens fine, killing humans bad


Betsy is stuck in Exile with Claremont holding her hostage. :o
 
Daredevil Saga: This freebie gives a history of what's been happening since Brubaker took over the writing on Daredevil, leading up to his next storyarc, with the introduction of Lady Bullseye. Hey, it's free...what can you say? No rating is appropriate for something that is just an extended recap page.

Secret Invasion #5: There is some real heart and soul missing from this series. It all comes across very bland, and while we see the heroes starting to fight back in this issue, it has made the entire Skrull Invasion seem not as dire; for, not much time has really gone by since the invasion began. (After all, the Avengers are STILL in the damn Savage Land....it seems as if the Invasion began about 3 hours ago.) I really feel as if many people on The Hype could have come across with a better script for this idea, and it's just another Marvel Event disappointment. It's not that it's bad...it's that it's very mediocre. 6/10

Secret Invasion-Thor #1: Thankfully, like with DC's Final Crisis, the tie-ins have been redeeming this story. The first of three issue, Secret Invasion-Thor is going to give us more action than we've seen in the first 10 issues of Thor's current series. The return of Beta Ray Bill had me cheering. Plus, it was great to see Don Blake doing his job for once. This set-up issue was great, and I cannot wait for issue #2. It's what I want in a Thor comic. 9/10

Secret Invasion-Runaways/Young Avengers #2: This team-up is a lot of old fashion fun. There is a lot going on in this 3-issue tie-in, as the various members of the Young Avengers and Runaways are all split up, with the goal of keeping Hulkling safe from the invading Skrull army. This issue is filled with action, and it's great to see these two groups again. Each used to have one of the best comics Marvel was putting out, and I miss reading their adventures. And, adding in Miyazawa's art is perfect. (I can see how some might not be a fan, but I really am, especially when he used to draw for Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane.) 8/10

Secret Invasion-X-Men #1: Now, the art for this comic is just awful. Cary Nord's use of background colors always makes his comics almost nauseating to read, and it tends to blend with the characters in the worst way. There is more green in this book than I've ever seen in a comic. The story, thankfully, helps to redeem the book a bit. Unlike with Bendis' invasion of New York, other titles, like Black Panther and this one, show the Skrulls as being very strategic in their battles. Of course, as the X-Men only very recently moved to San Franscisco, the Skrulls had not planned for them to be around for what was considered to be an easy attack. (There is also a subplot of Nightcrawler being transfixed on a mystical blue orb, which reminded me so much of Stephen King's Dark Tower series.) 7/10

Secret Invasion-Inhumans #1: Events from the Inhumans last mini-series finally get addressed and combined with the Secret Invasion. The Inhumans learn of the Skrulls invasion when the body of Blackbolt is shown to be a Skrull, and from there stems the mistrust of everyone they come in contact with. By the end, the invasion is full-on, and we learn of what the Skrulls have planned with the real Blackbolt. It's a real good first issue, as each tie-in has proven to be better than the main series. 8/10

Captain Britain and MI13 #4: A new superteam is born out of the disaster of the Secret Invasion, and for once I'm a bit excited about Captain Britian, Pete Wisdom, and Black Knight. (Now, if only they'd bring back Megan!!!) This finally makes up for the crap Claremont was giving us...now, if only they can cancel and save Exiles at some future date. 8/10
 
Psylocke was Marvel's human sacrifice to Exile Claremont; he's moving to progressively less relevant books (soon, he'll take over writing duties on Spider-Girl from Tom DeFalco:cwink:).
 
Well, yeah, but we're so far removed from the old days that they're irrelevant at this point, unfortunately.

And that's the appeal of delaying seeing them in action for just one more issue. Now, if they aren't in the next one, I'll be pissed, but all of this really reminds me of those times when I'm watching the news and they have an awesome story, but save it until the end of their broadcast.
Don't pay any attention to me right now though, I think I'm rambling just because I haven't been on here much in a while.
 
BTW, see Tropic Thunder!!! It's refreshing to see an original idea done well...and, if you've stayed away from the spoilers of who makes a surprise appearance in the film, see it fast before someone spoils it for you.
 
Psylocke was Marvel's human sacrifice to Exile Claremont; he's moving to progressively less relevant books (soon, he'll take over writing duties on Spider-Girl from Tom DeFalco:cwink:).


I hope not. :(

Spider-Girl is consistantly one of the most entertaining comic books published by Marvel.
 
Well, yeah, but we're so far removed from the old days that they're irrelevant at this point, unfortunately.

She's in New Exiles because Claremont is apparently in love with her and takes her from comic to comic as he goes.

I know about Pete's history with government agencies. I just meant that he's been back with the government for so long now that making a big deal of it would seem pretty out of place.

Excalibur and MI:13 are more Superheros team than Goverment agents. Especially now anyway.

I haven't read Claremonts Exiles, I heard it sucks as most Claremont things do these days :csad:
 
Well, MI-13 deputized all of Britain's superheroes, but it seems as if Captain Britain will be operating the superhero team while Pete Wisdom acts as a liaison between Brian's team and the government. Technically MI-13 still works for the government, but it appears it'll be very much Brian's team.
Psylocke was Marvel's human sacrifice to Exile Claremont; he's moving to progressively less relevant books (soon, he'll take over writing duties on Spider-Girl from Tom DeFalco:cwink:).
Bite your tongue. I like my Spider-Girl. :cmad:
 
Not like usual, Claremont has outdone himself with suckitude for the comic. He has stripped everything that made the series good and left us with a shell of a book where noone is in character, and everyone is bland.
 
Reviews, Part the Third: Secret Invasion (1 of 2)

Secret Invasion #5

Hallelujah, the Savage Land plot is over! It overstayed its welcome by, oh, let's say four issues, apart from sporadically interesting Black Widow scenes in #4; Bendis is about the only remaining writer who thinks the continual "who do you trust?" scenes are interesting, when really they'd become rote by the time the event started. This is probably the best issue of the series, as, after a rather leisurely pace for the first four, the plot suddenly lurchs forward; Brand frees Reed, who in turn whips up a Skrull detector, and then they go and pick up the Savage Land crew, while Maria Hill finally gets tired of standing on the Helicarrier deck for several issues and blows the place up. The scene with Cassie waking up seems to be intentionally reminiscent of her arrival in the Secret Avengers HQ in Civil War. Bendis takes a lot of abuse from Dread for his heroes being incompetent, but this issue generally has characters acting super-elite. Albeit not the Avengers, for the most part, who are nominally the centerpiece of this; Brand, Hill, and Reed Richards are at the moment most responsible. I did enjoy all the Skrull guises (I hope Stephen Colbert is okay). Yu's art continues to be excellent, surprisingly.

Secret Invasion: Inhumans #1

As a follow-up to Silent War, this is more then a bit awkward; Maximus is still king, but nobody seems to be mind-controlled anymore; though Pokaski does get in a hilarious explanation for why Maximus' ending declaration of war on Earth hasn't materialized: namely, it's easy to say you'll go to war, harder to actually do it. That, and the idea that Maximus is now thoroughly bored with ruling the city day-to-day, are very perceptive/satirical; of course, Maximus seizes on the Skrull threat to have some fun as dictator. Elsewhere, Pokaski indulges in one of the most tired plot devices at Marvel: [random character] beats up Tony Stark. In this case, random character is Medusa, though Tony at least gets a calm response line. The various members of the Royal Family are handled fairly well, Medusa especially, though she seems a bit passive in the final moments (not that that'll last). Raney's art is excellent; the colouring as well provides a very rich look for the Inhuman court.
 
Secret Invasion: Inhumans #1

As a follow-up to Silent War, this is more then a bit awkward;

Agreed. Wasn't there supposed to be a third mini by Hine continuing his Quicksilver/Inhumans story?
 
FANTASTIC FOUR #559:

I assumed that all of the continuity issues you discussed were not actually issues, because I figured the NEW Defenders were from the future.

And maybe they are here to prevent the imminent destruction of Earth everyone is so worked up about?

Or possibly to prevent the death of the Invisible Woman, which would explain this seemingly very-strange title.

I swear that metal-looking guy is Colossus's son. And this also allows Bruce to be Professor Hulk again, which he obviously is not in present continuity.

ALSO....I seem to remember Millar stating that his current run on Wolverine ties into this story as well, and time-travel feels like an obvious explanation to me.
 
Psylocke was Marvel's human sacrifice to Exile Claremont; he's moving to progressively less relevant books (soon, he'll take over writing duties on Spider-Girl from Tom DeFalco:cwink:).

Boo, spider-girl hate. If that's the case with less important books put him on Spider-Man, it can't get any more screwy at this point.
 
Agreed. Wasn't there supposed to be a third mini by Hine continuing his Quicksilver/Inhumans story?
They changed course on that in favour of the whole SI/War of Kings setup. Hence, this series shifting gears from 'Maximus has mind-controlled the city and is about to attack Earth' to 'Maximus is in charge, but otherwise situation normal'.
Boo, spider-girl hate. If that's the case with less important books put him on Spider-Man, it can't get any more screwy at this point.
I don't hate Spider-Girl (I don't really think much of it either way, which I imagine is the common view).
 
I assumed that all of the continuity issues you discussed were not actually issues, because I figured the NEW Defenders were from the future.

And maybe they are here to prevent the imminent destruction of Earth everyone is so worked up about?

Or possibly to prevent the death of the Invisible Woman, which would explain this seemingly very-strange title.

I swear that metal-looking guy is Colossus's son. And this also allows Bruce to be Professor Hulk again, which he obviously is not in present continuity.

ALSO....I seem to remember Millar stating that his current run on Wolverine ties into this story as well, and time-travel feels like an obvious explanation to me.

I flipped through this, very meh, IMO:

While I agree that's probably where this is going, I'm not a giant fan of two of the most formidable beings in the MU getting used and abuse like nothing. Kinda lessens so many previous stories when you see major villians or cosmic beings get steamrolled with seeming ease.

Also for the invisible woman's part of this story, where was she?

And the final issue being that millar has apparently decided the craptastacly obvious geoenvirnmentpolitical device of new earth is sticking around, yeah preachy crap about the dangers of capitalism, its good he's not being redundant.

While I know this will tie into 1984 and Old Man Logan, both of those stories are vastly superior (especially Logan) to this.
 
Not like usual, Claremont has outdone himself with suckitude for the comic. He has stripped everything that made the series good and left us with a shell of a book where noone is in character, and everyone is bland.

So, exactly like usual.
 
I don't hate Spider-Girl (I don't really think much of it either way, which I imagine is the common view).

That's a shame, one of the better comics out there. People who like reading about actual superheroes being superheroes read spider-girl.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"