MaskedManJRK said:
The only problem with that is no Qui Gon Jin, who was, undoubtedly, the best part of the prequal trilogy.
It's not a problem in this alternate reality.
In the first one Obi Wan did nothing. It was a whole wasted movie where the great, tragic friendship between Obi Wan and Anakin was reduced to him being introduced to a little boy and that's it.
Then, we just skip to way older Anakin in AOTC so we just have to take everyone's word for it that they have affection for eachother, however, since it's already the second movie, Anakin has to start being a b****, so really all we see is them bickering, mocking eachother, fighting and Anakin resenting him. What many fans really wanted to see was exactly what George didn't show us, what happened be
tween the movies he made...Anakin as the young student of Obi Wan and them being like "brothers" and sort of "Father and Son"...and then them fighting side by side in the (supposedly) epic "Clone Wars", and then Darth Vader (not VINO) in his prime as a bad-ass destroying the Jedi.
It would've been a much smoother and natural fall to the Darkside if they had followed one of the HUGE rules of story-telling...."Show don't Tell".
If it had started with Anakin already being Obi Wan's student, then they would've had a whole movie of good-times together with a hint of the bad that's to come...then, a whole movie where Anakin's older and they've grown apart which would then come to the point of no return by the end, and then, a whole movie where the fanboy dream of millions of kids from the 70's and 80's would've come true...seeing a black, armored, bad-ass Darth Vader hunting down and killing the Jedi.
It would also leave it less vague as to how Obi Wan knew Darth Vader was Anakin.
I say that "the Darkside clouds everything". The freaking Sith Lord Darth Sidious was hanging out with the Jedi for years and they couldn't ever tell that he was a Sith until the end.
I say it would be the same with Darth Vader. But in my movie, much like the shocking revelation that DV was Luke's father...Obi Wan would actually find out that DV was Anakin by his own mouth and get all shocked and dismayed.
It would also make it more believable that Obi Wan and Yoda were never found for 20 years if the Emperor and Darth Vader felt that they had watched them die themselves.
In closing,
1. Qui Gon was one of the coolest characters in the prequels, but that's not saying much.
2. If he had to exist, it should've just been in EU stuff, or he could've easily been another soldier in the Clone Wars, fighting alongside Obi Wan and Anakin, because by completely ignoring the base of the story, Anakin and his Darkside-fueled betrayal of Obi Wan and the Jedi...for an entire movie, they had to cram it all into only TWO movies which was ridiculous.
There was no reason to have Qui Gon or Anakin as a little boy pod-racing or Gungan politics when Anakin deserved a THREE movie arc, such as the one Luke Skywalker had...1)Promising but naive force-sensitive older teen. 2) older guy struggling to learn more and find his place, feeling torn between what he knows he
should do and what he
wants to do. 3) A mature, wiser man who has made his choice and acts on it.
p.s. I also believe Qui Gon's presence in the movies makes it stupid that he didn't appear with Anakin, Obi Wan and Yoda at the end of Jedi since supposedly he was the one that led them to the ability to retain their consciousness after death.
It just makes more sense that it's the story of the master Yoda(the best guy), Anakin(the worst guy) and Obi Wan(the guy inbetween), and that's who we see for the happy ending.