Gotham City Concept Thread

Batman

Dramatic Example
Joined
Oct 1, 2003
Messages
19,335
Reaction score
7
Points
58
Yes, yes, I know what's coming. And I'm fully prepared to be turned down on such an idea... but honestly, with all of the comments made over the last few months, it seems like this is the one idea I've ever had that people would be even slightly interested in giving another chance.

What I want to discuss is how we can improve Why So Serious?'s concept. The obvious thing we need to keep is some sort of basic ties to the movie, to keep it from being another comic game... however, I wouldn't be opposed to making said ties more obscure. For instance, Batman could have taken down Carmine Falcone before the game began, but Scarecrow's still active, and Ra's Al Ghul could have never re-appeared. Simple stuff like that that leaves character choices and story options more open to the players.

Another thing we could work to establish is that this is by no means a linear continuity. Elements of Batman Begins and the comics like Year One could have been used as the basis starting point, but from there on, this is our own story. I felt like one of the biggest problems of the last game was that it followed too closely to what could've led into TDK's continuity... let's avoid that from happening again. One way to do this is by allowing characters who would normally be excluded because of the mythology (IE: Nightwing, Bane, Red Hood, ect.) to actually be allowed, so as to not just say 'well, the comics are our bible, so we have to follow them to a tee'. No. No, we don't. And we have to make that clear.

Another thing. Guest stars are allowed from the getgo, but they're never to bring the story out of Gotham City. The same limitations would be needed for superpowers aswell. One rule to prevent multiple guest stars being taken up instead of Gothamites is that guest stars can only be picked up as second characters. The first character one plays has to be a Gothamite, and they have to play them for a specific period of time before they're allowed a guest star.

I'd really love to hear your ideas, because I think there's still a demand for this game. And since The Dark Knight already hit, I think the potential for it to be a less limiting, more fluid game could be quite vast.
 
I read the first few lines. That's all I needed. Yes. :up:
 
Compete for Batman, you say? :o
 
Cool. That's two vouches, at least.

Any thoughts on my ideas for changes, though? Or anything to add? I don't want to just post the same concept, given that it failed. Something has to change.
 
Cool. That's two vouches, at least.

Any thoughts on my ideas for changes, though? Or anything to add? I don't want to just post the same concept, given that it failed. Something has to change.
Uh...this time we make it more clear the cops can take down crooks too? :huh:
 
Gotham Central taking a more active role could be a nice change of pace.

We had a few, but in the overall sense, Batman was still the only one going out and taking down the major criminals.
 
Gotham Central taking a more active role could be a nice change of pace.

We had a few, but in the overall sense, Batman was still the only one going out and taking down the major criminals.
I guess cause people think if a normal cop can take you out, you weren't very dangerous.
 
There's only a few characters I could see myself playing for a Gotham RPG, and I'm already playing one in the OU.
But, I'd be up for a second stab at a Gotham-based game if it got off the ground.
 
I'm mixed on this.

Moving away from the noir opens up the game to possibilities.

Moving away from the noir kinda takes away my interest.
 
I'm mixed on this.

Moving away from the noir opens up the game to possibilities.

Moving away from the noir kinda takes away my interest.
You know it's calling you.
 
While I agree that the original game focussed too much on The Dark Knight, I honestly don't see a place for Detective Sergeant Vincent Del Arrazio here.
 
I'm mixed on this.

Moving away from the noir opens up the game to possibilities.

Moving away from the noir kinda takes away my interest.

Well, while the overall game wouldn't have a noir aspect, anyone could always play their characters and tell their stories in such a fashion.
 
Like, Harl. I'm mixed. I don't want to start this game again just to see it fail. It broke my heart when the original died. :csad:
 
That's why I'm trying to work to fix the problems. And those problems aren't going to get fixed if no one says what they felt they were.

Unless I touched upon all of them. :confused: Then, well... we're set.
 
I saw no problems. As I said on MSN, laziness.

Speaking of MSN... if you can, get on it for a second. I need to confer with you on a matter involving this, since Syn's not on.
 
Hmmm.......I could possibly be intrigued in a game like this.

I've always wanted to try my hand at playing Batman...
 
That's it. If Soze is Batman, then I'll join this RPG.
 
I have to admit it... I'd love no one more in the role.
 
Hmm...

I don't know. I was apprehensive the last time frankly...
 
I was in this the first time around and I'd love to do it again.
 
I've been thinking about it, and once you really open up the playing field, you're pretty much going for Ult. DC RPG, Part Deux.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"