World Hilary Duff as Supergirl

[Superboy]

Actually, Perabo or the other girl in this picture, Mischa Barton, if you want a younger (not by much) Supergirl. I guess the best way to think on that is Perabo for a modern, Earthborn Angel Supergirl and Barton for the Kara Zor-El Supergirl.

 

[Lazarus440]

Originally posted by Superfreak
The Middle One i think

nope.

 

[Gambit_Fan]

she can't act so no

 

[batmanplaysbass]

Wow. its kinda werid to see a old topic thats been dead a year come back to life, lol

 

[The Kryptonian]

No way dude! No way. Hillary Duff? Lizzie McGuire? The teen pop star? Ha!

Naomi Watts baby! Or Elisha Cuthbert.

 

[Strange]

To be honest I do not want to see Supergirl in a Superman movie.

 

[Webley]

I think Hilary Duff would make a kick ass Supergirl.

 

[Oldguy]

Hell no. Especially not after she went tooth-pick waify, that bit of baby fat was the best thing going for her.

 

[Swordmaster]

F**k...no...

 

[Webley]

I say give her the job looks like Supergirl to me.

 

[White_Howling]

I'd say wait at least 3 years for her to become Supergirl (when she turns 18). If she still looks as good then, then OK.

and if she loses all her baby fat.. then she might have a chance

 

[storyteller]

I would shave my eyes and "bass tape" myself if duff ever became associated with superman(unless its smallville since it already went to hell)

 

[White_Howling]

smallville already had a kara.. well kind of

 

[igotatromboner]

a spin-off movie is years away

 

[Webley]

smallville already had a kara

Duff would have made a better kara than the girl on smallville cant wait to see her in the move.

 

[Showtime]

Why in the blue hell did I find this thread in the Superman Returns forum?

 

[Mentok]

Nah, give it to Elisha Cuthbert, I would pay to see her running around in that outfit.

 

[Mentok]

Hell no. Especially not after she went tooth-pick waify, that bit of baby fat was the best thing going for her.

I gotta agree woth you on that

 

[WormyT]

WAHAHHAHAHA
OF COURSE NOT!!
Hillary duff? Supergirl?
A whole thread?!

Whahahahah!

 

[Super Kal]

can we like, put this in the Misc. Superman films forum now?

 

[Showtime]

can we like, put this in the Misc. Superman films forum now?

Please let's.

 

[ROBOCOP CPU001]

WRONG FORUM!!!!!!


sometimes i think some people do it on purpose...Just to get attention to there thread!


please move.

 

[Supergirl]

No, thank you. Give me someone who has more acting talent than say... I don't know... a Paper bag.

 

[AdWolF16]

elisha cuthbert should have been the invisible woman but fox dropped the ball.. wb would have to be braindead not to choose her for supergirl if the need arises

 

[Dr. Fate]

How about 5'9" Estella Warren?

Hilary Duff as Supergirl would be like Lindsay Lohan as Jean Grey or Mera or Mary Jane Watson - it sounds funny but if it were to be attempted, it just wouldn't work.