How exactly did Phoenix leave the X-Mansion?

[Pauluz]

How the hell did she get out of there with a school filled with little runts and the rest of the X-Men? Didn't Xavier sense something? Plot hole anyone?

 

[TrailerCues]

Xavier & Storm arrived in the room Jean broke out of after she left to see whats up. You need to pay attention to the Movie a bit more

 

[Pauluz]

Xavier & Storm arrived in the room Jean broke out of after she left to see whats up. You need to pay attention to the Movie a bit more

I saw that and that's why I asked the 2nd question. You need to pay more attention. Still, how did Jean get out of the X-Mansion, she was in the underground level.

 

[tonytr1687]

I saw that and that's why I asked the 2nd question. You need to pay more attention. Still, how did Jean get out of the X-Mansion, she was in the underground level.

Yeah it was another plot hole. They didnt bother to show it, or even the X-men's attempt to go after her while she was even in the mansion...if they even did go after her while she was still in there.

 

[War Lord]

SHe put her right foot in.
She took her right foot out.
She put her right foot in
and she shook it all about.

she did the hokey pokey
She opened a time-warp portal
and that what's it all about.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

She stole Scott's car. ... Really she did. The Phoenix made her do it.

 

[ntcrawler]

There could be some missing scenes put in showing the students reactions when the teacher they thought was dead suddenly appears in the main floor hallway with a pissed off look on her face. No doubt would be interesting to see the shock on their faces when they realize it's not the Jean they know.

 

[tonytr1687]

Right now I'm writing my own version of X3 and thats one scene I added in. Its not really my own version as its basically the same plot and same characters, just with some scenes changed around and a bunch more added in.

 

[ntcrawler]

Same here, though I'm still debating who she should run into. I'm leaning towards Marie. What about you?

 

[War Lord]

Right now I'm writing my own version of X3 and thats one scene I added in. Its not really my own version as its basically the same plot and same characters, just with some scenes changed around and a bunch more added in.

Will you be spending 200 million dollars to produce the film as well?

 

[ntcrawler]

Will you be spending 200 million dollars to produce the film as well?

You're not thinking big enough. It's supposed to be a blockbuster. Comedies these days can cost upwards of $100 million and they don't have any special defects.

 

[TrailerCues]

She put her right foot in.
She took her right foot out.
She put her right foot in
and she shook it all about.

she did the hokey pokey
She opened a time-warp portal
and that what's it all about.

 

[AznBABYBANDIT]

She put her right foot in.
She took her right foot out.
She put her right foot in
and she shook it all about.

she did the hokey pokey
And She opened a time-Por'al
and that what's it all about.

Lol nice song...

 

[chaseter]

How the hell did she get out of there with a school filled with little runts and the rest of the X-Men? Didn't Xavier sense something? Plot hole anyone?

She is Phoenix...she can get out however the hell she wants to. How do you not know that class was in session and all the little "runts" where in their classrooms when she broke out. She knows the layout of the X Mansion...she use to live their afterall. This is another stupid nitpick at someone trying to faulter the film by claiming "PLOT HOLE!" I will say this again...this is like showing Jack Bauer in 24 taking a s*** or sitting down to eat dinner or even take a leak. How can that man hold his urine and bowel movements or not get hungry during 24 whole hours??? Point is...it doesn't serve the plot and is a menial fact to the overall show.

 

[danoyse]

This is another stupid nitpick at someone trying to faulter the film by claiming "PLOT HOLE!"

Hey listen, the movie would have been much better if they'd all stopped to show Jean heading up to her room to get dressed, then hail a cab back to her parents' house.

I agree. She left. Clearly she has the ability to do that, and I took their word for it that she did. Didn't need to see it.

This is like the Angel argument. Did everyone need to see that he got on the plane to know he stowed away???? I just assumed he did.

 

[chaseter]

This is like the Angel argument. Did everyone need to see that he got on the plane to know he stowed away???? I just assumed he did.

As did I...

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

She left the mansion and on her way, she bought some dope and ....yeah pic screams "She's on dope!"

... Not that she is, but she looks calm ...and content but doped up inside

 

[chaseter]

Hey listen, the movie would have been much better if they'd all stopped to show Jean heading up to her room to get dressed, then hail a cab back to her parents' house.

I agree. She left. Clearly she has the ability to do that, and I took their word for it that she did. Didn't need to see it.

This is like the Angel argument. Did everyone need to see that he got on the plane to know he stowed away???? I just assumed he did.

The biggest one that makes me laugh is that some people think it is dumb that Magneto flew on the GGB just because Juggs said he couldn't swim. How awesome would it have been to see Mags and the gang still a small boat or perhaps a yacht and sail their merry way to Alcatraz. Hell...they could have even stolen some jet ski's or a hang glider or a WTF CARES! That GGB sequence was great and showed off Magneto's powers and pomposity.

 

[ntcrawler]

She is Phoenix...she can get out however the hell she wants to. How do you not know that class was in session and all the little "runts" where in their classrooms when she broke out.

Because there was no one left to teach the class. Scott was "dead", Jean was obviously "dead", Charles and Ororo were in the basement. So who's left? NightCrawler? Maybe the Cook?


Besides You're missing the point. This isn't meant to be a nitpick that destroys the integrity of the film, like your Jack Bauer example. We're simply trying to fill in the blanks. It's an interesting scene to contemplate, but much more interesting than this Jack person's bowel movements.

 

[ntcrawler]

This is like the Angel argument. Did everyone need to see that he got on the plane to know he stowed away???? I just assumed he did.

Wolverine can smell stowaways you know

 

[Neto Magnus]

my guess is that there's an exit door in the sublevel. From the trailers I assumed she'd be taking the elavator but who knows.

what really bothers me is where did the x-men go after their Danger Room session. I mean, we see them walking all the way to the end of the hall but we don't hear a door opening. In real life they just walked out of frame where there is no door. But in the movie it just looks like they kept going and going.

 

[chaseter]

Because there was no one left to teach the class. Scott was "dead", Jean was obviously "dead", Charles and Ororo were in the basement. So who's left? NightCrawler? Maybe the Cook?


Besides You're missing the point. This isn't meant to be a nitpick that destroys the integrity of the film, like your Jack Bauer example. We're simply trying to fill in the blanks. It's an interesting scene to contemplate, but much more interesting than this Jack person's bowel movements.

Errrmmmm I don't think Prof. X and Storm where hanging out in the basement the entire time. They came down to the basement where Wolverine was after Jean had left the mansion. If Scott wasn't dead you know that he would be down there along with Jean anways(I guess he is a bad teacher too). It is just a mute point. If the kids where roaming the halls...I would certainly get the hell out of the way from a pissed of woman demoleculerizing doors.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

If the kids where roaming the halls...I would certainly get the hell out of the way from a pissed of woman demoleculerizing doors.

Oooh -laughs with glee- but thats the fun part

 

[danoyse]

The biggest one that makes me laugh is that some people think it is dumb that Magneto flew on the GGB just because Juggs said he couldn't swim. How awesome would it have been to see Mags and the gang still a small boat or perhaps a yacht and sail their merry way to Alcatraz. Hell...they could have even stolen some jet ski's or a hang glider or a WTF CARES! That GGB sequence was great and showed off Magneto's powers and pomposity.

I know! What were they supposed to do...row? How long would it have taken them to grab a boat and not be seen sailing over to Alcatraz???

 

[danoyse]

what really bothers me is where did the x-men go after their Danger Room session. I mean, we see them walking all the way to the end of the hall but we don't hear a door opening. In real life they just walked out of frame where there is no door. But in the movie it just looks like they kept going and going.

They walked off the set. It's just a movie, you know.