If you could write a What If? comic yourself

[Lobo]

What if the Silver Surfer let Galactus eat Earth

What if Captain America was never found

these might've been done already, I'm not sure, but i'd like to do my version of them

 

[Victor Creed]

Better yet.........What if Galactus ate himself?

 

[Shadowknight]

What if Jessica Jones never retired as a superhero?

What if Sue Storm has received Ben Grimm's mutation?

1. They did that last year. Bendis wrote it. Of course, nothing happened in 75% of the comic. Oh, and she noticed Wanda was going crazy and prevented Disassembled from ever happening
2. There was an issue with "What if the FF got the same powers?" One where they all had Reeds powers, one where they all had Johnny's powers, etc. One story had her turn into a Man-Thing creature, completely mindless. Reed turned into The Brute (like his counter-Earth analog).

What if Peter Parker had been the clone?

What if Spidey never split from Black Cat?

What if Daredevil appeared in costume in his own comic??

1. Not exactly, but there was a What If? where there was an explosion where one survived, minus his memory, and they THOUGHT it was Peter. After a few months he got his memory back that he was the clone, and had been shacking up with MJ and baby May.
2. Happened. Two part story.

Spoiler

BC wound up killed and Peter went on to romance Silver Sable.

I would have liked: What If Kraven the Hunter had never gone insane, and Kraven's Last Hunt didn't happen?

 

[ookami]

What if Jean would actually ****ing die and stay there?

Then I'd worship the writer who would do it.

 

[The Question]

Anyone like my idea?

 

[Wolvenom2099]

Anyone like my idea?

I think it is deffinitely original & would be a good read. Would you be able to fit all of that into a 32 page or 48 page what if special or would you turn it into a series?

 

[Anubis]

What If Iron Lad had stayed in the Past?

 

[Anubis]

Anyone like my idea?

Kinda been done before. You ever read Cap Lives?

 

[The Question]

I think it is deffinitely original & would be a good read. Would you be able to fit all of that into a 32 page or 48 page what if special or would you turn it into a series?

Well, I don't think I'd be able to break it up into a mini series, but I don't think a single issue would suffice either. So, maybe a giant sized special.

 

[The Question]

Kinda been done before. You ever read Cap Lives?

That the one where Cap leads a team of Avengers consisting of The Punisher in Iron Man armor, Namor, Wolverine with Wendigo powers, and The Falcon with Giant Man powers?

 

[Anubis]

No, its the one where he leads powerless versions of Ben Grimm, Johnny Storm, Tony Stark, Reed Richards, and Sargent Nick Fury agianst the Red Skull who controls New York in the 1960's for the Third Reich.

 

[Darthphere]

What if Jubille was Wolverine's daughter?

 

[The Question]

No, its the one where he leads powerless versions of Ben Grimm, Johnny Storm, Tony Stark, Reed Richards, and Sargent Nick Fury agianst the Red Skull who controls New York in the 1960's for the Third Reich.

Oh.



No I haven't.



Dammit.


And I had some sweet ideas for this.



Was Cap lives any good?

 

[VICTORVONDOOMX]

Better yet.........What if Galactus ate himself?

Then he'd be really limber.

How about "What If the last 5 years of Mainstream Marvel made sense?"

 

[Darthphere]

What if the Green Goblin was Peter Parker's father?

 

[Anubis]

Oh.



No I haven't.



Dammit.


And I had some sweet ideas for this.



Was Cap lives any good?

Oh yeah, it was good. But that shouldn't stop you from exspressing yourself artisticly. Besides, I bet Cap Lives wasn't even the frist time they did a story like that either.

 

[The Question]

Oh yeah, it was good. But that shouldn't stop you from exspressing yourself artisticly. Besides, I bet Cap Lives wasn't even the frist time they did a story like that either.

Cool. My idea was to have basically most of the core Avengers be nazi super soldiers. And actually, now that I think of it, I'd have most of the major heroes either be nazi super soldiers, imprisoned, or dead (so I'd take Spidey out of the resistance). What's left with the resistance are villains and not as popular heroes. Plus, I've got great ideas for what evil versions of the various heroes would look like. Wolverine would be very pale and completely hairless, with all sorts of metal bits sticking out of his skin where they implanted mind control devices that they used the brain wash him.

 

[Anubis]

Heh, Sweet

 

[The Question]

Heh, Sweet

Thanks. I'd also have Reed and Sue Richards be scientists working under Dr. Zola. The Hulk would be locked up in a maximum security prison with adimantium walls. And, I'd have it revealed at the end that The Red Skull killed Hitler and took his place years ago, and in turn, The Red Skull's aprentice killed him and took his place years later. And, The Red Skull's aprentice would have been Rick Jones, who is now the leader of the third reich.

 

[Logan Howlett]

What if Wolverine had sex with X-23? Wouldnt that technicaly be considered *********ion?

 

[The Question]

No. More like incest.

 

[ookami]

What if Mystique got the Phoenix's powers?
What if Hawkeye was blind?
What if Gwen Stacey came back with Carnage's symbiote and killed Spidey?

What if Carnage ripped off Sentry's head?
What if Norman Osborne was bitten by the spider or MJ?
What if Doom was a woman?
What if there was no such thing as preptime?
What if Batman's fans knew physics?
What if all the Green Lanterns were afraid of green?
What if Flash had A.D.D?
What if Captain America, Thor, Superman, Doomsday, Deadpool, Punisher, Wolverine, Psylocke, Mystique, Xavier had Tourett's Syndrome?
What if Cannonball had explosive flatulence or explosive diarriah?
What if Homer Simpson led the Avengers?
What if Tony Stark had claustrophobia?
What if Doom had an itch?
What if Gomer Pyle was Captain Marvel?
What if Johnny Storm was a pyro-maniac?
What if Doom was Stephen Hawkins?
What if the new FF was Homer Simpson, Peter Griffin, Fred Flintstone and George Jetson?
What if G.I. Joe and Cobra were trained marksman?

 

[Anubis]

Thanks. I'd also have Reed and Sue Richards be scientists working under Dr. Zola. The Hulk would be locked up in a maximum security prison with adimantium walls. And, I'd have it revealed at the end that The Red Skull killed Hitler and took his place years ago, and in turn, The Red Skull's aprentice killed him and took his place years later. And, The Red Skull's aprentice would have been Rick Jones, who is now the leader of the third reich.

You ever read Warren Ellis' Planetary? Looking at the Wildstorm equivilent of Dr. Richards (Dr. Randle Dowling) he could be quite a scary amoral scientist type.

And LoL Rick Jones, nazi. Does he have the Quantum Bands too?

 

[Logan Howlett]

No. More like incest.

But shes not a relative shes a clone, so technicaly its just him doin it to himself.

 

[Wolvenom2099]

What If? #1 The Lethal Venom (Eddie Brock/Venom takes the place of Peter Parker/Spider-Man) "The Amazing Spider-Man"

What If? #2 Doomed Tales: Doctor Doom (Doctor Doom takes the place of Dr Strange) "Strange Tales: Dr Strange"

What If #3 What if the Trion has possessed the Hulk instead of the Juggernaut?

What If #4 What if Captain America became the Punisher?

What If #5 What if Wolverine was Iron Man?