JLA vs. The X-men

[MagicPrime]

The problem when trying to use scans to prove a point becomes sort of moot because I as well as others can go and find scans that counter the ones that were just posted. The Xmen as well as the JLA has been written by different writers at different times. In some issues Jean, Magneto or Superman could be shown as being powerful and gaining the uperhand and overcoming their opponent and then you can go back and find a scan where the same chracters are engaged in battle and the foe taking them on gets the uperhand. Also other heroes or villians that are powerful may best Phoenix or Magneto or Superman as example. It's just like Phoenix is fighting magneto and she loses, but Doom has beaten magneto, but she fights Doom at some point and she wins. I'm not saying that has actually happened but I'm just making a point.

Exactly! Which is why I didn't say I didn't believe the scans. I just said they had really crappy dialog - which was very very true.

 

[Whirlysplat]

Indeed, and don't take The Phenomenol too serious he was just banned from killermovies and his last thread he made was Imperiex vs. Onslaught. Ho hum.

Everyone who matters has been banned from KMC that forum is only fit for trolling.

 

[BAH HUMBBUG!]

So since the team rosters can include so many characters.

If all characters were included, that were inside cannon. What would the rosters look like?

 

[Phenomenal]

I'm not saying that has actually happened but I'm just making a point.

And believe me, I understand your point, it happens all the time in comics...

At the rest of you ( especially The Leaguer) you're acting ridiculous. I'm not gonna waste my time because you ignore facts and scans, If you wanna cry and moan and try and downplay that then go ahead.

Polaris stating what he could do to Superman. And making him Blind.
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/Dr.jpg

Draining Superman!!!
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/fe57fe85.jpg
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/c4d0ec35.jpg

Can't wait to see you twist, cry and moan about these.

 

[Flash Facts]

How can Superman be blinded like that when he has flown into suns out being blinded? Also if he drained the energy out of Superman where did it go? That much energy would surely have some sort of effect on the surrounding area.

 

[Phenomenal]

It's a comic book, things like that happen! Also, Superman going near the Sun is nothing for him because he get's more power the closer he gets.

 

[CaptainClown]

well technically he could use his super hearing then pummel polaris.

 

[Flash Facts]

Well if light is a power source for Superman then shouldn't the beam have just given him a power boost? Also what happened to the energy that was drained from him?

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

You guys are going about your counter-arguments all wrong. He did provide scans to support a valid argument. lets not go into how physics should work etc.....

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

And believe me, I understand your point, it happens all the time in comics...

At the rest of you ( especially The Leaguer) you're acting ridiculous. I'm not gonna waste my time because you ignore facts and scans, If you wanna cry and moan and try and downplay that then go ahead.

Polaris stating what he could do to Superman. And making him Blind.
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/Dr.jpg

Draining Superman!!!
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/fe57fe85.jpg
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f106/vancegathing/c4d0ec35.jpg

Can't wait to see you twist, cry and moan about these.

Yes. You bring up a point that pretty uch everyone already knew. Supes can be drained but not mearly because he is weak! Superman holds back, often times to much. If he wanted he could have had those to dead in nanoseconds. I read the trade of that a short time ago.

 

[CaptainClown]

But Polaris still has a weakness and that is his fragile mindstate, well I would assume I had to wiki it) His claim is magneto is all powerful so how does he lose?

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

And thats the whole argument here. Magneto may be able to drain Superman but Superman and Flash can take him out within some immeasurable fraction of a second. Magneto SOMEHOW manages to put his shield up? Lantern just drains the crap out of it and then Flash knocks him out in a femto second. Or Martian Manhunter could just Psi the crap outta him. Martian Manhunter is AT LEAST Charles Xavier level.

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

But Polaris still has a weakness and that is his fragile mindstate, well I would assume I had to wiki it) His claim is magneto is all powerful so how does he lose?

He has lost before. Pretty bad too if I recall. I just gotta remember.....

 

[Nokio]

And its "moot" not "mute" - just a heads up. If you edit it - i'll edit mine and no one will be the wiser -_^

OH DAMN!

 

[MagicPrime]

OH DAMN!

Shhh... we shalt not speak of this again!

 

[BAH HUMBBUG!]

And thats the whole argument here. Magneto may be able to drain Superman but Superman and Flash can take him out within some immeasurable fraction of a second. Magneto SOMEHOW manages to put his shield up? Lantern just drains the crap out of it and then Flash knocks him out in a femto second. Or Martian Manhunter could just Psi the crap outta him. Martian Manhunter is AT LEAST Charles Xavier level.

But doesn't Magneto have his helmet to block out Chuck? Why wouldn't it work against J'onn? Unless I am mistaken?

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

apparently Charles has overpowered the Helmets defenses, at least thats what I heard.

 

[BAH HUMBBUG!]

Ah, well I wouldn't know. But that doesn't mean J'onn could. For one he wouldn't know about it initially, two he doesn't know Magneto like Charles does, so there is a possibility that Charles could figure out how Magneto would have concieved such a thing.

Not saying J'onn couldn't just saying because Chuck did, does not mean J'onn instantly does.

 

[Phenomenal]

Yes. You bring up a point that pretty uch everyone already knew. Supes can be drained but not mearly because he is weak! Superman holds back, often times to much. If he wanted he could have had those to dead in nanoseconds. I read the trade of that a short time ago.

And Superman has killed someone in nanoseconds where?

 

[trustyside-kick]

He is talking about the fact that if Supes went all out, he could.

But that being mentioned...I was surprised with the Superman: Doomsday movie that came out like 2 days ago. They showed Superman fight in a way that made me respect him: as he should. He wasn't just blindly throwing punches.

 

[Phenomenal]

Superman has always fought like a brute. He just throws punches and hit opponents with cars or whatever else he could find.

I am not really into the Doomsday movie.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Have you seen it yet? It is really different from the comic version. I'm not a Superman fan, and I saw Braniac Attacks and couldn't believe it was allowed to see the light of day, but with Doomsday being worked on by Bruce Timm, I had more faith and decided to buy it.

I was not disappointed (say for two small details, but they are small), and the special features are awesome. Also, I wish the DC Animated films could be longer. I mean, Marvel's movies have sometimes been like 90 minutes, yet DC is always at 70-75 minutes.

And as I was saying, they actually wrote Superman fighting-wise in a way I've been hoping to see: intelligently.

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

Superman has always fought like a brute. He just throws punches and hit opponents with cars or whatever else he could find.

I am not really into the Doomsday movie.

You pretty much ADMIT that you don't know anything about Superman in your statement. Let me guess, did you watch some episodes of Justice League and suddenly think you knew about Superman?

 

[Ultra-Herald9]

And Superman has killed someone in nanoseconds where?

Superman doesn't kill. Superman also doesn't blitz people who don't have the durability to withstand it. So I guess Superman flicking Magneto in the back of the head to K.O. him is more accurate.

 

[Phenomenal]

Have you seen it yet? It is really different from the comic version. I'm not a Superman fan, and I saw Braniac Attacks and couldn't believe it was allowed to see the light of day, but with Doomsday being worked on by Bruce Timm, I had more faith and decided to buy it.

I was not disappointed (say for two small details, but they are small), and the special features are awesome. Also, I wish the DC Animated films could be longer. I mean, Marvel's movies have sometimes been like 90 minutes, yet DC is always at 70-75 minutes.

And as I was saying, they actually wrote Superman fighting-wise in a way I've been hoping to see: intelligently.

No I haven't seen the Superman vs Doomsday movie, only commercial clips.

Braniac attacks SUCKED MAJOR RECTUM BTW.

You pretty much ADMIT that you don't know anything about Superman in your statement. Let me guess, did you watch some episodes of Justice League and suddenly think you knew about Superman?

Oh my, please I have read MANY Superman comics and Superman is just a raw slugger. Don't even bring up that bull training from mongul or that so called crap training in v?ahalla for a 1000 days. Despite all of that supes goes to his usal routine and just fights like a madman.

So I guess Superman flicking Magneto in the back of the head to K.O. him is more accurate.

LOL, Did you miss the scans I posted? Did you forget Maggs shileds? I think not.