Top 3 suspects after episode 11:
1.[BLACKOUT]Kieran. It has to be him, right? He could easily set everything up, arrived around the time the season 1 killings started, never had a face to face with the killer and conveniently shows up AFTER the killer disappears. Also, the killer looking at the picture of him and Emma was very weird. Everything is pointing to him. It's just... he's so obvious right now, isn't he? I could see the writers give us the ultimate "f- you" and kill him off at the beginning of the finale.[/BLACKOUT]
2. [BLACKOUT]The sheriff. I gotta list him. At the start of the season, he was my prime suspect, but the show did a good job making me doubt it by following him so much. He's involved with the original killings, he's got to be. But if it's him, then there's definitely an accomplice, since he was on his way to the farm when the mayor got killed there.[/BLACKOUT]
3. [BLACKOUT]Eli's mom. We don't know much about her. Well, nothing actually. She didn't have any real interaction with Emma or Audrey, but it would be surprising if it was her.[/BLACKOUT]
My god, can't wait to find out who it is!
If there's an accomplice [BLACKOUT]Stavo is my number 1 pick. His drawings are way to specific. He's had contact with the killer. Probably helped him/her out. If the killer turns out to be a woman, then it was him who killed Haley.[/BLACKOUT]
Oh and [BLACKOUT]Brooke[/BLACKOUT] is definitely my dark horse. What a shocker that would be.