'Hater' chiming in...
I've waited a little bit before posting because I want to word this based on my thoughts rather than based on my reaction.
I'm gonna give credit where credit is due.
There are things that really hit the mark, and deserve acknowledgment.
The look on Denny's face when Sand drops the towel is
spot on Eisner. As a matter of fact, that whole scene plays very well... just so long as the audience doesn't see any more of Mendez's body than they do in the trailer.
In spite of the fact that I would prefer the actual suit and hat color, he does appear to translate well on screen in the brief shots he appears in, and the post team seems to have dropped some minor blue tinting on the suit in shots.
The girls are way overused, but look good in their roles. Denny's main problem
is his feminine woes, and so I'm glad it is a main plot point, and the scenes look good, however, I would like to see a Spirit trailer that focuses on the point that he actually fights crime.
Here's one thing that stood out and it is both a praise and a concern...
I think the shot of Denny being spit out of a woman's mouth is very, very WWII era pulp, and I'm glad they did something so artsy, however...
How in the world does this fit into any 'reality' that this film is aiming to emulate from Eisner's work?
Between this shot and the whole floating around with Lorelei inside of a bong scenario... I really hope Denny's in a coma, dreaming... or he's been drugged and is hallucinating while lamenting his womanizing and having a 'time to get responsible' moment.
Octopus is just ridiculous... and not in a good way. Christopher Lee once said that when he was filming his lighsaber battle with Yoda, he told George Lucas to remove a scene where Yoda had lept onto his back. His reason was "We don't want to risk an
unintentional laugh". I think that fits my concern about how Octopus is handled.
Overall, it's way too avant garde to look like Eisner, but there are things that work, at least for this multi-decade Spirit reader. I'm not completely against this film... just not sold on it at all.