Official 300 Critics Reviews Thread

[Cinemaman]

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/300/?show=all

100%

1. Variety.com - http://www.variety.com/index.asp?la...ept=berlin&nav=Rberlin&articleid=VE1117932810
2. Emanuel Levy - http://emanuellevy.com/article.php?articleID=4724
3. The Hollywood Reporter - http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/film/reviews/article_display.jsp?&rid=8813
4. Groucho Reviews - http://grouchoreviews.com/index.php?module=subjects&func=viewpage&pageid=203
5. IGN.com - http://movies.ign.com/articles/763/763580p1.html

More reviews to come

 

[Erundur]

hell to the ****ing yeah

 

[Shifty]

Good to see.

 

[Nebins]

yeah but keep in mind its only out of 5 reviews. No doubt this will keep a high score but I don't think it'll stay with a 100%

 

[chesslover]

The only review that matters is your own.

 

[Shifty]

http://www.comingsoon.net/index.php

300 is on the CS! poll, go vote!

 

[buddha182]

I have yet to write my review, but it'll still keep it at 100% once I do. It'll be up on RT too once I publish.

 

[Mr. Socko]

Usually I don't like critics, but it's cool seeing what the majority and minority think on RT. But this is just of those few reviews. Should still stay high though.

 

[dawhistleblower]

http://www.comingsoon.net/news/reviewsnews.php?id=19031


i had very high hopes for this movie... but then SHH gave it a review... and with the track record here... if they say see it, i have learned to stay away!

to bad i wont cause this is 300!!

 

[Nivek]

http://www.comingsoon.net/news/reviewsnews.php?id=19031


i had very high hopes for this movie... but then SHH gave it a review... and with the track record here... if they say see it, i have learned to stay away!

to bad i wont cause this is 300!!

I gotta agree, the Ghost Rider review seemed unconvincingly positive, and after seeing the film and REALLY detesting it, I'm not sure I would buy into another SHH sponcered review. But critic opinions never are really that important to me. Even if it's from here. It's reassuring, but I made my decision to see it outside of reviews.

 

[War Party]

http://www.comingsoon.net/news/reviewsnews.php?id=19031


i had very high hopes for this movie... but then SHH gave it a review... and with the track record here... if they say see it, i have learned to stay away!

to bad i wont cause this is 300!!

But the difference with SHH review of Ghost Rider is that many other critics didn't like it very much. They were the minority for Ghost Rider. But 300 sounds like it will be received better by critics. So if that's the case, you should be good. But I don't let critics make up my mind, I prefer to see it for myself.

 

[Isildur´s Heir]

It´nice to see that people are enjoying 300, it looked great by the trailers, it was one of those movies that i couldn´t imagine failing...guess i still got it, the all "i know how a comic book movie will turn out".
I never read the book, never got my hands on the TPB.

But, to be honest, i´m not a big defender on the all comic book translation to screen, like Sin City and 300.
Don´t get me wrong, i love Sin City, just like i know Sin City II will rule also, but i prefer a more realistic approach....
All in all, can´t wait to see 300

 

[slipknotrocks]

Glad to hear everyone is enjoying the movie!

 

[Caliber]

Glad to hear everyone is enjoying the movie!

Its reassuring to hear good reviews.

 

[Shifty]

I gotta agree, the Ghost Rider review seemed unconvincingly positive, and after seeing the film and REALLY detesting it, I'm not sure I would buy into another SHH sponcered review. But critic opinions never are really that important to me. Even if it's from here. It's reassuring, but I made my decision to see it outside of reviews.

There was two SHH! reviews for Ghost Rider.
Edward Douglas gave GR a 6/10 and 300 a 8/10.
I believe Mirko gave GR a 8/10. Yeah I saw it and couldn't wait until it was over.

 

[dawhistleblower]

I gotta agree, the Ghost Rider review seemed unconvincingly positive, and after seeing the film and REALLY detesting it, I'm not sure I would buy into another SHH sponcered review. But critic opinions never are really that important to me. Even if it's from here. It's reassuring, but I made my decision to see it outside of reviews.

I was absolutely against X3 at first then the review SHH gave it convinced me... then they did it again with GR! I even said "There is NO way we are getting "REAL" reviews when SHH is in bed with Hollywood and "BIG STUDIOS" right now as they help "censor" what we post on here like YOUTUBE links!"

and BAM! Fell for it again!

but you are right... 300 will be great cause it is great... not because some ass kissers agree to tell us it is great. We are one of the biggest target audiences for this studios and companies and SHH gets all kinds of exclusive interviews and screenings! Of course the reviews that come from here are going to be as biased!

 

[blind_fury]

Zach Snyder is the antithesis of MSJ. Snyder actually brings credibiltiy and respect to the comic book movie genre.

Godspeed Zach. Godspeed.

 

[Arkady Rossovich]

I think 300 will be a success,because i dont think anyone else thinks this is a superhero movie.Just a fantasy movie.t:

 

[_BB_]

Zach Snyder is the antithesis of MSJ. Snyder actually brings credibiltiy and respect to the comic book movie genre.

Godspeed Zach. Godspeed.

Completely agree. He was approached to do X3 and just by looking at the trailers and come of the scenes from 300 I couldnt imagine what he would have done with X3, all I know is it would have been at least 10 times better.

No way are critic reviews going to influence what I think about this movie and they hardly ever do for any other movie for that matter. I just know that im going to love every minute of 300.

 

[Cinemaman]

100%

 

[Secret_Riddle]

Completely agree. He was approached to do X3 and just by looking at the trailers and come of the scenes from 300 I couldnt imagine what he would have done with X3, all I know is it would have been at least 10 times better.

No way are critic reviews going to influence what I think about this movie and they hardly ever do for any other movie for that matter. I just know that im going to love every minute of 300.

No doubt he would have made an amazing x3

 

[matrix_ghost]

This is a quote that one should always remember.
Even though it was meant for Watchmen, it also applied for X3 It's definately ONE of the main reasons why there would never be a Zach Snyder X3 :

I don’t know how to make it PG-13, you know, I really don’t

 

[ultimatefan]

Dammit, every day it gets harder to wait...

 

[zanos]

Is blood and gore really something you absolutely need in a comic book film like X3? Strange.

 

[chesslover]

Magneto: "MUTANTS!!!!!!!!!!! TONIGHT WE DINE IN HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!