The Amazing Spider-Man Official Black Cat Casting & DIscussion Thread

Which Actress For Black Cat?

  • Elisha Cuthbert

  • Anne Hathaway

  • Rachel Mcadams

  • Eliza Dushku

  • Diora Baird


Results are only viewable after voting.
Remember when Bradley Cooper doing A-Team got leaked? What happened with someone put a camera in his face and asked him about it? He lied his ass off.

Again, McAdams could certainly be telling the truth and I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt. But...actors do lie, folks.
true.

for all the Mcadams fans. be happy that she didnt say that she was testing. because then it would be over for her.
 

How can that be. We had an insider giving us info. From this very thread:

on november 3, i made a post that official news will be coming and before that alot of gossip, news and rumors about the fourth spider-man and I even gave a HUGE hint a few days before the news of racheal mcadams ( well known actress auditioning for a role as felicia ) on the drag me to hell effects thread. I am sorry that I couldnt openly blab it out so that I can prove anything but, it was STILL THERE DAYS BEFORE the news broke out. Thats as far as I was going to go and even making reference to a cat coming out of the bag. within the past 6 days and even other websites are starting to mention that there has been ALOT of commotion going on about the fourth film LATELY, not before. ohh and as far as pissing people off, I really dont care because I will stand up for the people that I work with and it's pissing people off that I wasnt full of it so they closed the thread once my point was proven. I dont care what anyone says, you wanted news you got it in SIX DAYS and I left a hint about it. Steve from countingdown was also right and some mod on here said that listening to him was a mistake when he was right on the money about hearing news. Face it pal, the black cat is all over the web now and remember that I stated WELL KNOWN ACTRESS and racheal my friend is a very well known actress. You wanted proof and answers now your getting them, ENJOY IT. You still think im full of it then fine whatever I did the best I can to post every time things were getting hectic with news gossip and rumors until finally the cat came out of the bag and its only time for the official word. I always tell people to wait for the offical word because you never know with hollywood nowadays and thier fabrications to hide the truth.

Also whats this stuff about spider-man 3 having 3 villains when there was actually 4. Black suited spider, Venom, sandman, and new goblin. So technically if there could be three for part 4. Also, when was james franco announced as a villain during the time that we all were focusing on black suited spidey, venom, and sandman ? Point being, there was no point for an annoucement because he was already part of the cast. keep that one in mind and dont count the lizard out. It all depends on the studio because they call the shots. Just like the majority blamed sam for the green goblin power ranger suit, when it was in fact willem dafoe who rejected the other designs. Then again everyone will blame sam if things dont work out your way.


well since the official news thread got closed I was going to say, read between the lines and notice the date was a few days before the cat came out of the bag. Today is the 9th where the news came out and I posted this on the 7th. I couldnt admit to it cause I would have gotten in trouble but, I was hoping that someone would have figured it out. Also I did twist a little lie there cause you cant find the well known actress audioning for the role of feclicia anywhere, I just couldnt admit it was from me :) So how does everyone feel about racheal mcadams ? ohh and rocco you had me there with alison lohman and the whole well known aspect of it, I had to improvise there lol


because they finally realized that I wasnt full of it and decided to smack themselves silly instead of an apology for putting me down when I WAS RIGHT ON TARGET!

Its funny on how they are posting news about it now... ohh wait a minute was that official im sorry at this point actually news that just came out on the hype or did I use up my nine lives lol

Feels like old times on when people doubted me for that pic of eddie brock and that i photoshopped it but, that was much worse than what I had to put up with on here at least some people believed me.

geez I guess the websites above and many others out there are not legit...


Sorry but, I tried to give out a hint days before the black cat news was out on the drag me to hell thread. If you know of any rumors about a well known actress trying to audition for the role of felicia out there on the web then please let me know. I also tried telling everyone to keep thier eyes peeled on the news, gossip, and rumors and it's been occuring ALOT lately. I am very sorry that I cannot go any further than that and im also sorry if I ticked anyone off but, you have no idea on how difficult this has been for me when I come on here and people are bashing the people that I have worked with and looked up to when they dont know the full story to it on how things really work out there even when I tried to explain things. I already learned my lesson that no matter how hard I try to convince some people, they are just too damn stubborn and for those of you who trusted me, thanks. I dont understand why every one on here get so touchy when it comes to things like this because I always encourage those to wait for the official word but being on this forum has been the worst experience. I used to be a whiny fan boy that just complained on how they ruined my childhood heroes but, after understanding how things really work I grew nothing but respect for those people in the industry that I would at least be thankful to be able to see the characters come to life on the big screen and that things can always be worse. I trust in sam raimi for spider-man 4 and I hope that many of you decide to give him a chance and just do your research before assuming and putting the blame on the wrong people when it's indeed the studios that have the FINAL say with every thing and not the director.


yeah and stan lee is getting two liners for the next one... give me a break we all knew dylan could return and the same with bruce thats NOTHING NEW compared to an actual villain... not everyone could have predicted that the black cat ( out of all of the spider-man villains ) was going to be in the fourth film. If I said a hunter or a doctor and the black cat came up then I would have been wrong. I gave you something and its not my fault if you didnt pick up on the hints DAYS before it happened. Also people asked for proof and I gave it to them because I have nothing to hide now its being turned around on me for providing proof. twisting my words around like 3 to 4 years instead of the 3 to 4 months, then saying that I stated 10 days or after thanksgiving when I said it MORE THAN A MILLION TIMES THAT STEVE FROM COUNTINGDOWN SAID THAT ! NOT ME. YOU ALL GOT YOUR PRECIOUS NEWS THAT WAS NOT SOMETHING TO BE EXPECTED WITHIN SIX FRIGGIN DAYS, SMILE AND BE FRIGGIN HAPPY ABOUT IT ALREADY ! GEEZ...

Today from that other site:

Originally Posted by IcEXMaNuSa
im getting some weird news here, it seems that rachel being the top contender for the black cat was false. I dont know if thats accurate yet but, one of my co-workers is hearing that her reps are saying that she never intended to be in the film at all. Anyone here about this as well ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by rocco2216
Who was never intended to be in the film? Rachel McAdams? or Black Cat?

Quote:
Originally Posted by IcEXMaNuSa
I just posted the news, rachel was never intended for spidey 4. The other actress did confirm the strong lead role though and that she might not get it. It's a well know actress though just wasnt rachel.
:dry:

Don't believe everything you read or hear. Mcadams might very well end up being Black Cat, and the character could very well be in the film, but don't be fooled by imitations.
 
Last edited:
You losers need a reality check. He's been right about everything so far! :cmad:

Seriously though, isn't it a weird "coincidence" that his "sources" told him McAdams wasn't the top contender after she publicly denied being involved. Weird, huh?
 
Last edited:
I'm encouraged that this is getting denied, but that doesn't mean it won't happen. It just might mean nothing is official and their trying to wait til it becomes official before confirming.

However, if this BC in SM4 thing turns out to be false...WOOHOO!!! I'm happy :up:
 
Did any of you honestly think Black Cat was going to be in this? And did any of you honestly think McAdams was going to play her?

Honestly?
 
Did any of you honestly think Black Cat was going to be in this? And did any of you honestly think McAdams was going to play her?

Honestly?

Just because McAdams isn't playing Black Cat, doesn't mean she (Black Cat) won't be in it. Wasn't Black Cat going to be in Spider-Man 2 at some point?
 
I'm encouraged that this is getting denied, but that doesn't mean it won't happen. It just might mean nothing is official and their trying to wait til it becomes official before confirming.

However, if this BC in SM4 thing turns out to be false...WOOHOO!!! I'm happy :up:
agreed

Did any of you honestly think Black Cat was going to be in this? And did any of you honestly think McAdams was going to play her?

Honestly?
the British chick confirmed that she auditioned for the role so... but i hope we don't see BC in SM4
 
Just because McAdams isn't playing Black Cat, doesn't mean she (Black Cat) won't be in it. Wasn't Black Cat going to be in Spider-Man 2 at some point?

Yeah, Black Cat was featured in early drafts of Spider-Man 2.

Michael Chabon mentioned that when he was hired, the script that they had at the time had (along with Doc Ock) Black Cat, The Lizard, and Harry as the new Goblin.

[YT]LI_v2Q0-ai8[/YT]
 
EXCLUSIVE: Julia Stiles in Talks for Spider-Man 4
Posted by Matt Patches at 1:57 PM

UGO has learned that Julia Stiles has met with a casting company in New York to discuss the upcoming Spider-Man 4!

This makes sense based on the recently debunked rumor that Rachel McAdams was set to star. Could this mean we'll be seeing the Black Cat saving Spidey's last dance? We haven't heard specifics about which role she was eyeing and assume it's all early talks, but why not?

More after the jump!

Personally, she'd be a great fit. Stiles is an underrated actress and unlike McAdams (who's about to star in the upcoming Sherlock Holmes), hasn't had a leading lady role in a franchise film. Yeah, we saw her in Bourne, but playing Black Cat would get her out from behind a computer screen and bouncing across building tops!

http://movieblog.ugo.com/movies/exclusive-julia-stiles-in-talks-for-spider-man-4

I'm sure our psycho ex-poster will claim "he knew this the whole time" :whatever:
 
I like Julia, I don't see her as Black Cat though.
 
No chance Julia Stilles is the up for the black cat, she is not the 'bouncing across rooftops' type. My guess is she'll be up for some boring official type that is linked to the Bugle, and it's takeover if that rumour is true. Whatever, she will be shuffling papers in an office not her ass in a cat-suit.

edit: Liz Banks said earlier in the year that she would not be returning as Betty Brant if she did not get a bigger role. Perhaps Julia Stilles will be playing JJJ's new secretary.
I would prefer Liz Banks back, but she has not been announced yet as coming back, and i just saw her in a hairdo advert, she has moved onto a bigger role in hair products, she don't do wigs anymore.
 
Last edited:
I like Julia, I don't see her as Black Cat though.

Rachel McAdams...Julia Stiles...Ok, all beautiful chicks. But Black Cat has big boobs. Really. Boys, i'm not perverted. But MJ has big boobs in comics and Kirsten Dunst no, and ok...We pass. Now Black Cat has really big boobs and the only two names who comes out are McAdams and Julia Stiles, two beautiful chicks with no-boobs?

:doh:

Sorry, dudes. I'm not perverted, i'm only think that Raimi hate boobs instead Venom and Carnage.
 
Rachel McAdams...Julia Stiles...Ok, all beautiful chicks. But Black Cat has big boobs. Really. Boys, i'm not perverted. But MJ has big boobs in comics and Kirsten Dunst no, and ok...We pass. Now Black Cat has really big boobs and the only two names who comes out are McAdams and Julia Stiles, two beautiful chicks with no-boobs?

:doh:

Sorry, dudes. I'm not perverted, i'm only think that Raimi hate boobs instead Venom and Carnage.

Sam Raimi loves boobs, going by some of the extras he has cast in the movies.
It's just that he favours acting over boob size.
The extras spent all their money on boob jobs while the others spent their hard earned money on acting lessons.

I am perverted, i have thought long and hard about this.

anyway, who cares, the acting is what is important, but BC has to be very good looking, big boobs are a bonus.
 
Sam Raimi loves boobs, going by some of the extras he has cast in the movies
Oh yes.. the stupid cleavage shots I hate so much. The only moment in the Spider-Man movies I go :facepalm:
 
Seriously if they will go with Black Cat...They must cast the real Black Cat:

diorabaird.jpg
 
So much speculation, these lovely interwebs...

Romola Garai said she had done an audition but was among hundreds of actors and actresses who put themselves on tape, and she said the role was never specified.

At this point, all that's known is that there have been what sounds like open auditions for people to put themselves forward for consideration.

As for McAdam, it has a suspicious smell about it and sounds more like fanboy wish-casting.

Rather like that 'Brian Blessed is Odin' nonsense that at least one major site reported as gospel truth (and even put it on wikipedia) when it turned out to be poop.
 
I really like Julia Stiles. Great actress who takes her work seriously. I wish she would've been cast as Mary Jane from the beginning. I'm not incredibly high on Black Cat and the character. I do think she's different than catwoman in terms of motivation and intentions.For these movies though, I'd rather see Spidey go up against a guy. Spidey can't punch a woman! (Although MJ felt the wrath of symbiote peter) Vulture or Lizard! Come on! I'll even go for Peter-MJ romance if done well. Come on...Spidey 2 was loved by all and had romance.
But IF BC HAS to be in the film, Stiles or Mcadams...excellent choices.
 
I agree with the previous poster that she is probably replacing Betty Brant. Wouldn't be suprised if it's a recast all together. BC doesn't fit the bill for her.
 
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"