Ali MacGraw was a huge success in the blockbuster tear-jerker, "Love Story" as the tragic, sassy Jenny Cavilleri. As a result, "golden girl" MacGraw was the first choice to play Daisy in Paramount's upcoming "The Great Gatsby" (1974). She turned down the plum role because she was soon to wed Steve McQueen, whom she'd met and fell in love with during filming of "The Getaway" (1972). Macho McQueen made it clear that he expected his young wife-to-be, not yet divorced from Robert Evans, to cut back on her film commitments once they were married. Ultimately, the part went to Mia Farrow. Critics weren't impressed nor kind in their appraisal of Farrow or the film. Time magazine cruelly ripped her performance apart, calling it "...a catastrophe. She works up a mannered creature with bulging eyes and squeaky voice who never suggests Daisy's strength, her greed, or even her gaiety and charm." The film had a mediocre showing at the box office. It's tempting to speculate as to whether MacGraw as Daisy would have saved the film, or if she, too, would have been grilled mercilessly by reviewers because of the bland script.