Question about the new Nancy story.

Roarks? There aren't any more Roarks, Marv kill Cardinal, whi only leaves the Senator, she can take him. I don't think Frank would want Marv to help, then he'd be in two stories, A Dame To Kill For which is going to be in Sin City 2, and the new Nancy Story.

 

That would be a really great idea. And technically, Marv was in 2 stories in Sin City, Hard Goodbye and TYB.

 

Agreed.

 

No I think Frank Miller should take advantage and make a new stellar charecter..

 

NO WAY. I just don't think that'd work...

 

Well he's writing a new book so we should have new charecters.

 

Depends. If they're bad guys, I don't mind, they'll die a bloody death, but if they're good guys...I'm gonna have to warm-up to them

 

Yea,But Frank is a genius! The new characters should be cool.

 

There's still doubt in my gut, but Frank's a God, so I can trust him

 

You think maybe The Man could appear in the new Nancy story?

 

As long as he didn't kill her

 

Possible, depending on when the story takes place, since "The Hard Goodbye" is, I believe, only a few months after "That Yellow Bastard".

 

Not too happy about the Nancy story. Sounds too "Kill Bill" for me. I don't have a doubt in my mind that Quenton is going to direct that segment. -_-; Another reason why Frank is doing the story is because of the popularity of Jessica Alba being Nancy.

Just my opinion is all.

 

I think your right, But personlly I think the story could rock, Plus Quentin Tarinto is a great director.

 

Ooh, I like the idea of Nancy hiring the Salesman to help her go after the Roarks.

 

That would be cool.

 

That would be awesome.

 

Ideally, I'd have it be that she originally hired him to kill HER. Maybe she would hire him under the name Cordelia. Then, when he sees that it's really Nancy, who he watched in the bar before and has a deep sort of admiration for, he refuses to kill her and they join together. Ideally, I'd have it all from the Salesman's point of view. But oh well.

 

oooh, 2007 seems so far away.

 

That idea rocks!

 

Actually, The Hard Goodbye takes place about 4 years after That Yellow Bastard. Check the story and you'll see Dwight moaning about how Ava left him, which In A Dame To Kill For, took place four years before the events of that story. Since A Dame To Kill For takes places slightly before and during The Hard Goodbye, the time span is four years before. Therefore, the Senator is still alive at this time because Marv mentions him still being alive. Also, there is a third Roark brother, the Attorney General. He isn't mentioned in the movie, but he is mentioned, but never shown, in The Hard Goodbye. What I would like to see if Nancy run into a Roark that is actually a good person and she has to struggle with the fact that she might have to kill a good person in the name of vengeance. I think that would really bring some fresh drama into the story instead of it just being a straight revenge piece.

 

This would be good.

 

I don't think that makes sense--where is it shown that The Salesman has even been in the same room as Nancy, let alone have a deep admiration for?

 

Actually, Miller has said that the crime textbooks in Nancy's room in TYB is supposed to be a hint to what's to come for her--suggesting that Nancy might very well become a gumshoe.

Maybe still a little Kill Bill-like, but that should be enough to make it fresh.