Crooklyn said:
Yeah, I think WETA set the bar mighty high for cgi characters there. The use of mo-cap really did help bring out the character. Of course, it doesn't hurt to have Serkis doing the acting either.
Amen. I loved that guy just on the basis of LOTR, but then his work in Kong was incredible, as well. He obviously studied gorillas a lot in preparation for that. His performance as the big guy was flawless.
Always did wonder why Davey was in the sunlight most of the time. Hrm. Probably has to do with how they were confident in their cgi that he'd work in a well-lit environment.
That's probably true. And ILM never turns down a chance to show off. Perhaps they felt that if they kept Davy in darkness all the time, it would make it seem as if they weren't happy with their work. But hell... in the original "A Nightmare of Elm Street" you barely saw Freddy clearly... he was perpetually in shadows, and that worked to his advantage as a monster. It made him scarier, even though the makeup was quite distrubing in its own right, and Robert Englund would be scary as hell on a sunny beach wearing flower-print trunks and his actual face.
As far as Gollum goes, he's supposed to be an object of pity that reminds us of our own frailties as much as anything else. He's evil sometimes and seemingly harmless other times, so the connection with his eyes and his face was necessary, I thought.
Still, I thought with Davy, that showing his face - particularly his eyes - in full light made him less frightening a lot of the time, because it humanized him. The eyes are the most important part of the face. "The gateway to the soul," as they say - and as a former art student I've always appreciated that the eyes were the most crucial aspect of a portrait. The eyes make or break a likeness.
Well, they also make or break a character. It was Cillian Murphy's eyes that made him just as scary without his mask as with it, in "Batman Begins," and it was Michael Keaton's eyes that made him somewhat unnerving to look upon as Batman in Burton's movies. Similarly it was never seeing Darth Vader's eyes (or indeed any of his face) that made him so creepy when I was a kid. Freddy's yellow eyes in "New Nightmare" made him seem somehow even more evil than he ever had before.
A design is EVERYTHING.
Davy Jones' eyes and facial movements reminded me of somebody else, and I couldn't think of who it was. But I just wracked my brain and I realized who it was he reminded me of. He reminded me of Odo from Deep Space Nine. THAT'S why he didn't scare me. Because subconsciously I was thinking of grumpy old Odo retiring to his bucket for the night.
The best way to hide flaws within a cgi work is to surround them in shadows. Human skin, I think, is at least 7-10 years from being perfected on the computer. Which is why I still consider Gollum to be a great achievement, but hasn't quite reached greatness yet.
I'm not sure how much better Gollum could be done, though... I mean he was exactly the way I always pictured him, or at least unnervingly close. I did a sketch of Gollum in 1998, and when I saw him in the movie I went "HOLY SH1T!" because it was almost exactly my sketch.
LOL!!!