Sequels Should Black Cat be the love interest in SM 4 and 5?

[I Am The Knight]

Well, I think it's almost obvious. I mean, I don't see why we wouldn't see her again.

Maybe because the writers would want to steer away from the love triangle dynamics, which most likely would be the case if both MJ and Gwen are in the movie. I'd have Gwen in a cameo role capacity at most, unless they want Peter to be with her now.

I know Bryce has said she is willing to come back but I dont know if she is in the script. If she can be fleshed out more I dont have a problem with her being there, but I dont want Spidey 4 to be over crowded like part 3. It runs that risk if the villains are Kraven and Lizard, plus whatever drama is goin on in Peter's life.

Yup.

 

[King of Kings]

If Gwen isn't in 4 then maybe they could split up Peter and MJ and introduce Felicia then maybe set up Blackcat for Spidey 5.

 

[mantheycallTHOR]

i think she could be something that could really add something intense to the series, it could have a early smallville type love triangle type vibe but hyped way up...

and it could be something that last into the 5th film before its done

 

[Chris Wallace]

Absolutely not.

 

[Cagefighterkip]

considering the rumor that there's another gal in S4 i'd bet its felicia...
http://www.deadlinehollywooddaily.c...-raimi-studio-may-shoot-4-and-5-at-same-time/

 

[Chris Wallace]

I still think because of the similarities to Catwoman, they should steer clear of Black Cat altogether.

Uninitiated viewers will see her as nothing but a knockoff.

 

[Jick]

i think she could be something that could really add something intense to the series, it could have a early smallville type love triangle type vibe but hyped way up...

and it could be something that last into the 5th film before its done

no love triangles. seen that already.
if she's there, I hope she is just a teaser. the Black Cat from SM2 The Game was the best. if they really do her, what is likely, then I hope she is a lot like that.

 

[Cagefighterkip]

I still think because of the similarities to Catwoman, they should steer clear of Black Cat altogether.

Uninitiated viewers will see her as nothing but a knockoff.

i dunno --
i feel if they set up the character right and make an interesting character, people wont care save for the people who dont like this character from the comics or trolls.

 

[Chris Wallace]

I doubt the comparison can be overcome, but I would love to be proven wrong. Sometimes when I'm skeptical about something, being wrong can be fun. Like when I relentlessly bashed Downey.

 

[pjspider1C]

You know who might be a good choice for Black Cat? That blonde CIA chick from the show "Chuck". She's hot. She kicks ass. Good enough for me.

 

[Chris Wallace]

Pic?

 

[pjspider1C]

 

[Chris Wallace]

Hmm-maybe. Dunno if I would go as far as to call her hot.

 

[Cagefighterkip]

I doubt the comparison can be overcome, but I would love to be proven wrong. Sometimes when I'm skeptical about something, being wrong can be fun. Like when I relentlessly bashed Downey.

true
and i was a Ledger basher for a while

 

[Chris Wallace]

Don't get me started on my anti-Ledger naysaying.

 

[smoothbody]

please,any one but dunst,i mean any one!!!!!!

 

[Cagefighterkip]

Don't get me started on my anti-Ledger naysaying.

dont get me wrong i wasnt vehemently going against him, but i wasnt for the idea... hes a good actor i just didnt think that he was gonna end up being right for the role.
but he beyond-ass proved me wrong im glad to say. TDK is the best comic book movie ever, and ledger deserves an oscar for his genius work.

 

[Chris Wallace]

Yeah, well I was vehemently against him at first. Same with Downey. In Downey's case it was because of his past & where Ledger was concerned, I couldn't see it.

 

[Cagefighterkip]

Yeah, well I was vehemently against him at first. Same with Downey. In Downey's case it was because of his past & where Ledger was concerned, I couldn't see it.

i can see that, im just glad they both turned out genius

 

[luke1234]

i think she could be something that could really add something intense to the series, it could have a early smallville type love triangle type vibe but hyped way up...

and it could be something that last into the 5th film before its done

woooo no love triangles brother, that kind of stuff ruins superhero films. It would be interesting to see what her costume would look like. Maybe kinda like James Carsons original concept would be cool. Black Cat is really close to Catwoman, but we havent seen a good catwoman in over a decade so they can most likely get away with it. Im interested to see how this plays out and if she was even mentioned in the script.

 

[Cagefighterkip]

woooo no love triangles brother, that kind of stuff ruins superhero films. It would be interesting to see what her costume would look like. Maybe kinda like James Carsons original concept would be cool. Black Cat is really close to Catwoman, but we havent seen a good catwoman in over a decade so they can most likely get away with it. Im interested to see how this plays out and if she was even mentioned in the script.

if done poorly love triangles can be bad but look at "x2" w/wolverine, jean grey and cyclops or in TDK w/harvey, rachel and bruce. those were done well... and i feel that gwen/mj/pete could have been good if gwen had more screen time in the flick

 

[Jick]

the thing is...
what if SM4 and Batman 3 comes out the same year and the first has Black Cat, and the second, Catwoman?
comparisons won't be avoided. it'll be weird.

 

[luke1234]

if done poorly love triangles can be bad but look at "x2" w/wolverine, jean grey and cyclops or in TDK w/harvey, rachel and bruce. those were done well... and i feel that gwen/mj/pete could have been good if gwen had more screen time in the flick

yeah well cyclops wasnt even on the screen till the end of the film so it really wasnt necessiarly a love triangle, and the dark knight triangle welllll thats the dark knight so that answers that haha.

 

[luke1234]

the thing is...
what if SM4 and Batman 3 comes out the same year and the first has Black Cat, and the second, Catwoman?
comparisons won't be avoided. it'll be weird.

Sm4 will be out before 3, but i do know what you are saying it would be weird

 

[Cagefighterkip]

the thing is...
what if SM4 and Batman 3 comes out the same year and the first has Black Cat, and the second, Catwoman?
comparisons won't be avoided. it'll be weird.

ill put money on Catwoman not being in B-3 after halle berry's fiasco which wasn't that long ago... she wont be in it, but if by some odd chance she is i do see where you're going w/this...