So...who would you have join the team?

Season 2
Rip
White Canary
Firestorm
Deathstroke (Slade)
Flash (Wally West)
Green Arrow (Connor/John)
Zatanna
Clock King

Season 3
Rip
Huntress
Red Arrow (Roy)
Vibe (Cisco)
Bronze Tiger
Katana
Booster Gold
ATOM

Season 4
Booster Gold
Black Canary
Firestorm
John Constantine
Killer Frost
Zatanna
Merlyn

 

I would rather they go "Brave & The Bold" style. Have team-ups for 1 or 2 episodes. One could be White Canary & Constantine. Another could be Firestorm & Vixen, etc, etc.

 

Arsenal, Katana, Huntress, Nyssa Al Ghul, Wally West, Earth-2 Harrison Wells, Jesse Quick, and Connor Hawke.

 

Since it looks like they

Spoiler

killed off Mick

, I'm thinking they'll only add characters that they can actually do something with in terms of character development, which IMO rules out villains like Slade, Clock King, etc.

If I had my druthers, I'd bring back Carter and add John Diggle Jr./Connor Hawke and Jonah Hex.

 

Looks like Rip may not recruit another criminal again after what happened with Heatwave.

 

Vixen, Constantine and Connor.

 

Two out of three I can see joining Legends between the rest of the season or a 2nd season.

 

Well, depends on the criminal. Cold can obviously be reasoned with. Heatwave was just unfortunately part of the packaged deal.

 

Arsenal, Katana, Huntress, Nyssa Al Ghul, Vixen, Cupid & Constantine

 

Vixen, Constantine... Ambush Bug

 

I'd get Vixen, Lisa Snart, maybe Constantine. Also Gideon in physical body form.

 

You know, I like the idea of Gideon getting an Aya type story arc. She's already an AI, so let's see some of that explored in the future. It would be hella interesting if she ever crossed paths with Barry after she had a body and was learning how to be alive. Since Barry created her or at least an archaic version of Gideon.

 

2nd season goes magical

Team:
Sara
Cold
Firestorm
Constantine
Zatanna
Jason Blood
Vixen

recurring appearances:
Doctor Fate
Madame Xanadu

Villains: Felix Faust (not the Felix Faust from the Constantine show) & Morgaine le Fey

 

Eh, I dunno if Felix Faust is a great idea. There are elements of Faust in the Legends of Tomorrow Vandal Savage. In fact, on the show, Savage almost feels like a composite character, made up of the two.

Besides, a mystical villain is too similar to what has been happening on Arrow this season. I'd much rather see an extraterrestrial villain now that space travel has been brought into the mix.

 

I want the Rogues back on The Flash. That's where they belong. I want a season long arc for the Rogues. Captain Cold, Heat Wave, Golden Glider, Weather Wizard, Captain Boomerang, the Top, Pied Piper, Mirror Master and Trickster (probably Axel since I doubt they could get Mark Hamill for more than one or two episodes a year). I want to see them come together as a whole team, with all the in-fighting that would entail, and take on the Flash as a unit.

Replace Captain Cold and Heat Wave with John Constantine and Vixen. Maybe get rid of Rip Hunter and shift the focus to magic next season. They could keep Atom, White Canary, and Firestorm but add one or two of Swamp Thing, Dr Fate, Zatanna, Dead Man, Spectre, etc.

 

^Felix Faust is already dead in the Arrowverse. Chas blew him up with a hand grenade on Constantine.

 

Huntress, Katana, Zatanna

 

Vandal Savage is a composite of Vandal Savage and Hath Set. They can easily do Felix Faust so he would come off vastly different.

Well LoT and Arrow are two separate shows so they can get away with it. Plus ya Darhk had some magical power from a totem but they kind of barely touched on it and when they did it was just a passing mention.

Just because Matt Ryan plays Constantine in the CW/DC universe doesn't necessarily have to mean that the stuff that happened on Constantine in is canon.

 

They confirmed that it was the same John Constantine. Unless he jumped from an alternate earth, Constantine is canonical to the Arrowverse's Earth-1.

 

Its plausible-ish now, but I really doubt it'll be plausible after another season or two of divergent revelations about the mystical community.

 

This! And I miss that show (and Scooby Doo Mystery Inc) so darn much.

-Zatanna and White Canary
-Captain Cold, Heatwave, and Constantine
-The real Jay Garrick and White Canary

 

Booster Gold, Atomic Knight, Animal Man, Vixen

 

Constantine and Vixen would be logical and really cool solid choices. Agreed on sending the Rogues back to Central City where they belong.

Huntress and Katana would be really cool as well, I think. Some alt-reality or time-lost versions of characters could be really cool to boot.

 

Constantine (though I believe that's wishful thinking)
Wildcat (dito here as the actor was hired as a lead somewhere else)
Vixen
Connor Hawke
A.T.O.M. (this time as a sort of leader)
Huntress (in a Captain Cold kinda role were she slowly becomes heroic)
Katana
Mr. Terrific