the dumbest idea in comics,so far,for you.

[Eddie Brock]

Comic books are more than just fight scenes. If thats the olny reason you read comics, that sucks.

yeah it kinda does
he skips through to get to the fights

 

[Saved]

yeah it kinda does
he skips through to get to the fights

No, I bought Fantastic Four and other Civil War comics for more than good fight sceens, though I do get comics for action more than plot. However, I don't want to buy a comic that soley deals with Drama. Spiderman has that in his other comics but with the awsome action.

 

[Darthphere]

No, I bought Fantastic Four and other Civil War comics for more than good fight sceens, though I do get comics for action more than plot. However, I don't want to buy a comic that soley deals with Drama. Spiderman has that in his other comics but with the awsome action.

But this title is about Mary Jane. You can't in any way bash a book for serving its purpose. You bash stories and characters from the book. But you cant bash a book about Mary Jane because its about Mary Jane.

 

[Tangled Web]

You know, I don't really need alot if action to enjoy a book. In a PP:SM graphic novel "A Day in the life" there was no action, Pete just deals with his deamons and I loved it. It was sad.

 

[Eddie Brock]

But this title is about Mary Jane. You can't in any way bash a book for serving its purpose. You bash stories and characters from the book. But you cant bash a book about Mary Jane because its about Mary Jane.

i'm not bashing because it's about MJ
i'm bashing it because it sucks

KIDDING!!

 

[Saved]

I read a world without Superman. NO ACTION in it. I did enjoy it though. But I personally don't want to read a comic about MJ because I need some plot more than an episode of Laguna beach but written down.

 

[Darthphere]

Laguna Beach is awesome.

 

[Eddie Brock]

riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

 

[Tangled Web]

i agree whole-heartedly with all of that

I think everyone who cares about Spider-Man feels this way. Why is Marvel doing this to our Spidey?

 

[Phoney Bone]

Wow...so then why read it ifhe never fights. Thanks for proving my point.

That doesn't prove a point at all?!

It's a romance book. They don't need to show fights, it doesn't have a direct correlation to the real story.

All books are not super-hero books.

There's nothing wrong with a good ol' romace once and a while, doesn't make you gay at all.

 

[Eddie Brock]

I think everyone who cares about Spider-Man feels this way. Why is Marvel doing this to our Spidey?

because Joe Quesada doesn't give a rat's ass about the fans

 

[Phaedrus45]

Simply put, Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane is the best Spidey book out there today.

Nuff' said.

 

[Darthphere]

That doesn't prove a point at all?!

It's a romance book. They don't need to show fights, it doesn't have a direct correlation to the real story.

All books are not super-hero books.

There's nothing wrong with a good ol' romace once and a while, doesn't make you gay at all.

Are you sure im not gay?

 

[Saved]

That doesn't prove a point at all?!

It's a romance book. They don't need to show fights, it doesn't have a direct correlation to the real story.

All books are not super-hero books.

There's nothing wrong with a good ol' romace once and a while, doesn't make you gay at all.

Yeah, but I never said the gay joke, Eddie did. And thats not my cup o' tee. I don't reed romance comics. If I want to see romance, thats why we have girlfriends.

 

[Eddie Brock]

Yeah, but I never said the gay joke, Eddie did. And thats not my cup o' tee. I don't reed romance comics. If I want to see romance, thats why we have girlfriends.

HAVE? as in the present tense?

 

[Saved]

HAVE? as in the present tense?

We aren't talking about current relationships here, unless we want to talk about yours...

 

[The Punisher]

Spider-Man unmasking himself.

 

[LadyVader]

Gambit becoming a horseman of Apocalypse, quickly followed by Gambit going blind.

Unless it's already happened, somewhere down the line somebody needs to anally rape Gambit cause there's not much left to really destroy the character.

 

[jaydawg]

He was never much of a character to begin with.

 

[LadyVader]

That's arguable. He has always had a loyal fanbase, who have been terribly disappointed by the way Marvel has been treating him. Simply put they destroyed what few qualities he had for no good reason because no good came out of that storyline..

 

[Eddie Brock]

worst idea in comics:
letting Joe Quesada be Editor-In-Chief
i believe many will agree with me

 

[Fred_Fury]

The Origin of Bane is pretty ******ed... c'mon, his whole life he had dreams about fighting a bat? Why not just make it so he was a hitman hired to break batmans back, instead of giving him some sort of spiritual connection to batman. I thought he was a cool villian who they could have used more often. Because seriously, batman is lacking cool villaisn.

 

[supermarvelman]

DC putting Captain Marvel os the limbo shelf for decades, has got to be the dumbest most selfish idea in comic history.

 

[stillanerd]

worst idea in comics:
letting Joe Quesada be Editor-In-Chief
i believe many will agree with me

I'll second that.

But there have been quite a few. For me, the dumbest ideas in comics for Marvel (in no particular order) are:

1. Making Peter Parker a clone and Ben Reilly the orginal Spider-Man
2. Retconning it so Xorn was never Magneto.
3. The wedding of Black Panther and Storm--because it will clearly fall apart in the next few years.
4. Kevin's Smith's the Evil That Men Do which had the Black Cat origins involve date rape.
5. A three way tie in [BLACKOUT]Sins Past[/BLACKOUT], The Other: Evolve or Die, and way Peter publicly revealed his he was Spider-Man.
6. Avengers: Dissasembled (which has been the cause of all the insanity so far in Marvel, right up to Civil War) as well as Hawkeye's death and turning Scarlet Witch into an all-powerful psycho.
7. Rebooting the Spider-Man titles.
8. Wolverine remembering his past.
9. Heroes Reborn, and
10. ROB "I can't draw feet to save my life, but I can draw shoulder pads and BFGs" LIEFELD!

The dumbest ideas for DC are:

1. Turning Hal Jordan into a villain, then into the Spectre before deciding to bring him back.
2. War Crimes--which made Leslie Thompkins guilty of manslughter with regards to the Spoiler's death.
3. The return of Jason Todd as a Punisher wanna-be.
4. Bruce Jones on Nightwing.
5. Hush--the character, not the Loeb 12-parter (although the last issue sucked) and especially when Leibermen used him.
6. Zero Hour--which has proven to be completely pointless.
7. The Mary-sue known as Taranula.
8. Killing off Ra's al Ghul and replacing him with Nyssa.
9. The Last Laugh. And finally...
10. The now evil Superboy Prime and his "Retcon Punch."

 

[Citizen_Kaine]

Everything they have done to Spider-Man in the last few years including, his five hundreth issue, where Doctor Strange did everything and plugged his own mini in the process.

Spidey finally joins the Avengers and becomes their version of Speedball. Getting beat up or unmasked in every issue, and needing Luke Cage, and Spider-Woman to save him.

Gwen Stacy had sex with Norman Osborn, and than had his babies.

Peter Parker was chosen by an omnipent Spider-god, and now has stingers. Oh and he ate a guy's head as well

Peter Parker publically revealed his identity, because a law and Tony Stark asked him too.

Now laugh thinking how insane and stupid someone would sound, mentioning that three years ago