The most important questions that no one makes

[Isildur´s Heir]

How are they going to explain how can Emil retain his intellect when he changes into Abomination, and Bruce doesn´t?
Why can Emil control his transformation, but Bruce can´t?

This can make or break the movie, because to answer this shows how much they understand the characters and what they are doing

 

[Bobstarsky]

I swear emil turns into the abomination permenantly at one point... I think that's what's gonna happen in the new film...

 

[kedrell]

^Precisely! He can't change back. And Bruce already had the buried mental problems before he became the Hulk and Emil didn't.

 

[Atomicchuck3k]

^Precisely! He can't change back. And Bruce already had the buried mental problems before he became the Hulk and Emil didn't.

Precisely! It's the same reason that She-Hulk retains her smarts!

 

[SpaghettiHULK]

Exactly, Emil has'nt mental problems with [SIZE=-1]multiple personality/dissociative identity disorders[/SIZE]. And he cannot change back. He became a monster, period. A different kind of monster, 'cause, like already said, gamma irradiation causes different effects on different subjects.

 

[co2]

Bruce has multiple personality disorder. It just so happens that when he is in a situation that Bruce cannot handle, another personality takes over, and that is what triggers the gamma in his body to transform him physically.

 

[Sava]

damn... ... all of them answered your question IH

 

[Isildur´s Heir]

Damn......no one understood s**t about my thread

I know the answer, i was asking how they are doing to address that in the movie.
But, it´s true that i don´t read Hulk in a very long time, but last time a checked, Emil could change back and forth, just like She-Hulk can.
But, after reading here that he can´t, i went to Wikipedia, and your right, he can´t.
And, for the record, Bruce doesn´t have multiple personality disorder, he has repressed feelings, those are two diferent things.
If not, wouldn´t Bruce shown those multiple personalities prior to the gamma bomb?
But he never did.
The same goes, if he had multiple personality disorder, wouldn´t there be a "normal" Hulk?
The problem here is a bit more complex than that.

 

[TheBeastWithin]

How are they going to explain how can Emil retain his intellect when he changes into Abomination, and Bruce doesn´t?
Why can Emil control his transformation, but Bruce can´t?

This can make or break the movie, because to answer this shows how much they understand the characters and what they are doing

If you think a question this trivial is going to make or break the movie, expect to be disappointed. The movie can answer the question by saying exposure to gamma radiation affects different people different ways. In other words, who cares.

 

[kedrell]

Damn......no one understood s**t about my thread

I know the answer, i was asking how they are doing to address that in the movie.
But, it´s true that i don´t read Hulk in a very long time, but last time a checked, Emil could change back and forth, just like She-Hulk can.
But, after reading here that he can´t, i went to Wikipedia, and your right, he can´t.
And, for the record, Bruce doesn´t have multiple personality disorder, he has repressed feelings, those are two diferent things.
If not, wouldn´t Bruce shown those multiple personalities prior to the gamma bomb?
But he never did.
The same goes, if he had multiple personality disorder, wouldn´t there be a "normal" Hulk?
The problem here is a bit more complex than that.

Read the "Tempest Fugit" arc in Hulk comics. He does have MPD and they were there before the gamma bomb. The bomb just gave them access to the physical world via the Hulk.

 

[Skip Rockhard]

Since everyone seems to be ignoring the real purpose of the thread, I'll ad my two cents.

I'm sure the explanation of why his intelligence is retained can be done pretty easily. Possibly the process through which Emil first becomes Abomination is different than Banner's causing different end results. Or like its been suggested, maybe Emil's psyche isn't as hindered as Bruce's.

A tiny bit of dialogue by Bruce or Betty or some other scientist, or Emil himself could explain why he's still smart.

 

[SpaghettiHULK]

It is all in the "Doc Samson" character!
In CB "Doc" wrote a complete analysis about Bruce Banner's mental matters and his three different identities(Bruce, Green Hulk and Grey Hulk), through the Sigmund Freud's divisions of the psyche(Id, Ego and Super-Ego). It was all Peter David's work!

 

[Weadazoid]

Since everyone seems to be ignoring the real purpose of the thread, I'll ad my two cents.

I'm sure the explanation of why his intelligence is retained can be done pretty easily. Possibly the process through which Emil first becomes Abomination is different than Banner's causing different end results. Or like its been suggested, maybe Emil's psyche isn't as hindered as Bruce's.

A tiny bit of dialogue by Bruce or Betty or some other scientist, or Emil himself could explain why he's still smart.

yeah I always figured the same, I figure they concentrate the dosage to say the Medula Oblongata..the reptilian part of the brain.....

that would explain the reptilian look... the oblongata is the older part of the human brain, and a big part of any reptiles brain....if you watched Water boy you would no that Corlnell Sanders......

but seriously also concentrating on the medula could have a purpose..they could thorize that the effects won't invade the more complex higher cortex functions..perhaps this dose of Radiation mixed with Nanomeades is more controlled


as for the permanents state..a higher more direct does to one area of the brain could explain it..... Emils transformation is far more deliberate..perhaps whoever it is that is helping him has info from the Banners old experiments...both involved reptiles...

 

[wil]

Since everyone seems to be ignoring the real purpose of the thread, I'll ad my two cents.

I'm sure the explanation of why his intelligence is retained can be done pretty easily. Possibly the process through which Emil first becomes Abomination is different than Banner's causing different end results. Or like its been suggested, maybe Emil's psyche isn't as hindered as Bruce's.

A tiny bit of dialogue by Bruce or Betty or some other scientist, or Emil himself could explain why he's still smart.

Exactly! They could have it that origin of abomination was not an accident but a much more refined process that that of the Hulk's.

 

[Isildur´s Heir]

Read the "Tempest Fugit" arc in Hulk comics. He does have MPD and they were there before the gamma bomb. The bomb just gave them access to the physical world via the Hulk.

I never read the "Tempest Fugit" so, give me an example...

I'm sure the explanation of why his intelligence is retained can be done pretty easily. Possibly the process through which Emil first becomes Abomination is different than Banner's causing different end results. Or like its been suggested, maybe Emil's psyche isn't as hindered as Bruce's.

It can´t have nothing to do with Emil´s transformation, it´s all about Bruce, it doesn´t have to do with the monsters, but rather the men.
The reason why Emil retains his intellect is not because his transformation was diferent from Banner´s, but rather because Banner is diferent from anyone.

If you think a question this trivial is going to make or break the movie, expect to be disappointed. The movie can answer the question by saying exposure to gamma radiation affects different people different ways. In other words, who cares.

Trivial?
Dude, are you for real?
Or are you one of the dumb ones that just to see two green giants fighting?
To explain why Abomination and Hulk are diferent is actually to understand the characters involved, so, there isn´t one single shred of "trivial" here.

Another good question to be explained is, why are Hulk and Abomination are enemies?
And anyone that gives me the, "because they have similar powers and are green", get the "i´m stupid" award.

 

[Obi-Ron]

I'm hoping they use the comic explanation that a person's gamma mutation is related to their psyche. Emil should be shown to be an "abomination" long before the gamma exposure.

 

[TheBeastWithin]

Why Abomination retains his intellect and Hulk doesn't is probably the least important question one could think of. It can and most likely will be addressed in the movie by one line of dialogue. Probably something along the lines of "Q: Why does Blonsky retain his intellect while Banner's seems to regress during transformation? A: The effects of exposure to such massive doses of gamma radiation are completely unpredictable". So yes, this specific issue is trivial. So trivial, in fact, we don't even have a definitive answer to this question in the comics.

 

[Atomicchuck3k]

Why Abomination retains his intellect and Hulk doesn't is probably the least important question one could think of. It can and most likely will be addressed in the movie by one line of dialogue. Probably something along the lines of "Q: Why does Blonsky retain his intellect while Banner's seems to regress during transformation? A: The effects of exposure to such massive doses of gamma radiation are completely unpredictable". So yes, this specific issue is trivial. So trivial, in fact, we don't even have a definitive answer to this question in the comics.

KUDOS!!!