MadVillainy
C'mon Son
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2008
- Messages
- 32,733
- Reaction score
- 9,402
- Points
- 103
HAs anybody read any of the work of the screenwriter or seen any of his movies
I could see Wally being highly comedic, though even he doesn't need to be for a good movie adaption they should just keep the humor to a minimum like in the Spider-man films while Barry Allen should be completely serious. You don't need comedy directors near this unless they're in Favreau's league.
Kerry Conran could be a good Flash director.
Agreed.They don't need a comedy director to make it work, for either Flash. Comedy is easy and can be conveyed through a character's attitude. There's no need for slapstick stuff like Rush Hour or whatever. There can be some funny scenes but they should not be the crux of the movie.
And Barry Allen should not be completely serious, he isn't in the comics anyway. The movie should have the same tone that Iron man had to it.
I always thought a funny scene would be that one of the first times Barry ejects his Flash suit from the ring, he gets it on at super speed and is ready to dart off, but stops quickly and looks behind him and sees all his civillian clothes on the floor (which he picks up at super speed).
Stuff like that would be cool in The Flash movie without taking one out of the story. They also need to keep Barry generally optimistic and humorous, but a bit of a law and order type.
That's good, but his stories aren't dead serious like Batman. They do have humor to them.Reasons for Barry
- First Flash to wear the modern Flash suit
- Was Flash for the longest
- More Serious
- In comics, one of the original member of Justice League
I don't think Wally is funnier per sa, he's just less intelligent, and if that makes him do stupid things that are funny then I guess you could categorize him as funnier.Reasons for Wally
- Funnier
This isn't entirely true as he won't be wearing Barry's suit anymore and that Barry Allen is the main Flash again, like Hal Jordan is the main GL. However, Wally is still active as a Flash, so that isn't entirely false.
- Modern Day Flash
Now that isn't true at all. In fact, it's quite the other way around:
- All Flash TV Appearances (1990 Show, JL Animated, JL Live Action Pilot) even though 2 of them have been named Barry Allen have had more qualities for Wally
- Wally is the fastest Flash

Now that isn't true at all. In fact, it's quite the other way around:
Flash TV show:
Was entirely Barry Allen, the only Wally elements were the STAR Labs and Tina McGee, also the fact that he could only run at the speed of sound. Other than that he was entirely Barry Allen, the producers/writers even said that they liked/wanted Barry because he had more humor than most the other DC heroes and because of his origin and forensics job, they said the forensics job would give Barry reasons to be The Flash the same way Clark Kent being a reporter gives him reasons to be Superman. They also said they liked his easy going nature. They added the STAR Labs element from the Wally stories because they wanted as many story building elements as they could get, and they could change back and forth from the police lab to the STAR labs stuff to build stories. A big reason why this was done was because they couldn't do actual supervillains on the show like the Rogues, so they'd build more stories with STAR labs.
My problems with the show were that they made him a vengeance driven character with the murdrer of his tv show brother, and that the show was darker than the comics, almost like the Batman films, altho the producers said they were trying to emulate the Watchmen comic series.
Mark Waid said that the reason he never gave Wally a secret identity or job or a personal life is because Wally's lifelong dream was to be The Flash, ever since he was a kid. He was a celbrity and could make money off of it, why would he need a job or identity? Why would he want to do anything else if he was living his dream? He's Wally West, full time superhero.
Justice League/JLU:
The only Wally West elements about this Flash were his name and likeness (red hair) and the fact that Linda Park appeared in an episode.
Everything else was Barry Allen, such as the secret identity/forensics job, the origin, the fact that he's the first/only scarlet speedster, the Flash costume ring, the city he lived in (Central City), all the silver age versions of the Rogues, the fact that he co-founded the JLA/was part of the original 7, not to mention all the various nods to famous silver age Barry Allen stories such as the giant head (The Flash #117), turining into a gorailla, fat Flash (The Flash #115), and the Superman VS Flash race on the Superman cartoon, all were elements of Barry Allen's story.
The personality is that of Bart Allen's/Impulse's, with a little Guy Gardner, his relationship with Batman was like Guy's relationship with Bats in JLI. The producers of the show were even going to use Impulse before Flash, but opted to use his personality with the actual Flash character. Wally in the comics is much more sensible and tempermental/hot headed (and slightly whiny) than how he was displayed on JL/JLU.
The JLA live action pilot was supposed to be Barry Allen but they just made up a lot of crap - wanted it to be like "Friends" and it sucked.
The Batman:
Altho never seen in his secret identity on he show, this Flash was BARRY ALLEN (the producers said so). He is from Barry's city (Central City), used abilities that only Barry could do (such as the molecule vibration), fought the Mirror Master (Sam Scudder version, one of Barry's original enemies), and helped found the JLA with fellow members Green Lantern/Hal Jordan and Green Arrow/Oliver Queen (both best friends of Barry's in the comics). Also, it would have been impossible for this show's Flash to be Wally West or Bart Allen, as the show's Robin was Dick Grayson, who is the same age as Wally West and much older than Bart Allen.
He has Barry's personality with a hint of Bart Allen.
Justice League: The New Frontier:
This Flash was entirely Barry Allen, altho I'm not sure why they colored his eyes brown in some scenes when Barry has blue eyes.
Barry also has all the Flash and JLA cartoons from the sixties to the eighties, so in actuality Barry Allen still has the most appearances in alternate media.
Wally West/The Flash= Scott Porter
![]()
Linda Park= Linda Park
![]()
Jay Garrick= Gary Cole (dyed hair)
![]()
Joan Garrick= Emma Thompson (dyed hair)
![]()
Barry Allen/The Flash= Peter Krause (in flashbacks)
![]()
Iris West= Mary Louise Parker
![]()
Hunter Zolomon/Zoom= Shane West
![]()
Mirror Master= Christian Slater
![]()
Captain Cold= Jean Reno
![]()
Captain Boomerang= David Wenham
![]()
Slightly Updated
I cast Barry and Joan
what work has he done?


You don't know how happy that makes me to see someone else agree that Peter Krause is the PERFECT, PERFECT, PERFECT older Barry Allen.
Why isn't his script getting more traction from TDK?They should have so stuck with Goyer's adaptation. It pi**es me off so bad that they scrapped it. It would've been awesome. Oh, well... we'll get one soon enough. GYLLENHAAL FOR WALLY!