If we buy one of the two English midfield prospects I think they will be taking Gibson's place rather than competing with him for it. Either way way we need to add a top class proven midfielder to the list.
We need someone who is not only talented enough to improve the team, but will also blend in well with the system we play.
I have always felt that the potential to be a clossus in midfield was there with Rodwell and he is still only 19, lots of young players have injuries at that age due to growing into their frame, Fergie has said as much about the spate of injuries Welbeck has had.
Personally, I've not been overly convinced with Rodwell's ability to warrent investing such a high fee that Everton would want for him. Hes obviously young as you said & can improve, but isn't that true of alot of 19 year old players?
If you're paying £25m+ he should pretty much already be on his way to being a player.. in my opinion anyway.
Rooney was an exception to this rule, for me anyway, because he simply looked lightyears ahead of any other 18 year old striker at our club or in the Premiership.. I'm not so sure if Rodwell looks lightyears ahead of any other 20/21 year old in the Premiership..
Gibson can shoot and has a decent passing eye but he drifts out of games too easily, he lacks workrate and he's ponderous, I don't see him making it at United.
His passing ability is what annoys me, he doesn't get into games enough & isn't accurate enough with his passes.. even worse than Anderson.. who to be fair has looked a good bit better, distribution wise since his return.
The thing is Di Maria was doing it in a much easier league than Pastore is doing it in, and Di Maria has had soem good games for Madrid, the problem with that side is it is consumed by Ronaldo.
True, Pastore does look like he could well be a star of someones midfield.. hes not exactly a Scholes like central midfielder though is he.. as you said before I'm kinda finding a hard time thinking of how/where we could use him & really take full advantage of his ability.
Di Maria is odd to watch in a Real Madrid shirt, if Ronaldo cuts inside & scalps one goalwards from 30 yards, you can bet your house that inside the next 15 minutes Di Maria will try the same thing. It's like hes trying to outdo Ronaldo..
Agreed on Luiz, I think Smalling also looks good on the ball so I am not worried about that one. With Ramires he has struggled but so have many in their first season who move from a slower league to the prem, next season will be the better one to judge from.
Smalling looks like hes gonna be not only the future of Manchester United, but also England. Him & Wilshere if recent performances are to go on.