BrianWilly
Disciple of Whedon
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2003
- Messages
- 13,275
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 56
Well, yeah, I'm sure it's the best thing ever if you didn't actually like or know anything about the characters before.
But that's really only a fraction of the problem. The other part has to do with how completely unimpressive these "new" characters are in the first place. Freddy, for instance. Freddy's entire personality could be boiled down right now to "stoic." And...that's it. He has no opinions, no traits, no defining characteristics beyond whatever it takes to move the plot bunnies along. Sure, he's heroic, and selfless, and all that, but that one-dimensional take just serves to make him less interesting, not moreso. He's supposed to be some sort of Chosen One destined savior of the Tenth Age, and he's just...stoic. He's supposedly the protagonist of this entire mythos, and yet we haven't checked in with how he actually feels about any of this since at least the fourth or fifth issue. And even then, he was just emo. Hell, his handicap -- which has been one of the key points and motivations of the character since day one, even in this series -- has been all but completely forgotten and ignored at this point. This series has taken more time to explore fcking Sabina's characterization, and Sabina is annoying. She's freaking Forerunner combined with Superboy-Prime.
Look at all the other reinventions and legacy heroes and reboots that have come up since OYL. The Atom, Blue Beetle, Booster Gold, Dr. Fate, the Spectre, the Question, the GL Corps, so on and so forth. Love 'em or hate 'em, you could cite incredibly detailed takes on any one of them outlining explicit drives and turning points and quirks and conflicts. And with Freddy? He's stoic. He's doing some trials to get his powers and things are happening to him. The end.
But that's really only a fraction of the problem. The other part has to do with how completely unimpressive these "new" characters are in the first place. Freddy, for instance. Freddy's entire personality could be boiled down right now to "stoic." And...that's it. He has no opinions, no traits, no defining characteristics beyond whatever it takes to move the plot bunnies along. Sure, he's heroic, and selfless, and all that, but that one-dimensional take just serves to make him less interesting, not moreso. He's supposed to be some sort of Chosen One destined savior of the Tenth Age, and he's just...stoic. He's supposedly the protagonist of this entire mythos, and yet we haven't checked in with how he actually feels about any of this since at least the fourth or fifth issue. And even then, he was just emo. Hell, his handicap -- which has been one of the key points and motivations of the character since day one, even in this series -- has been all but completely forgotten and ignored at this point. This series has taken more time to explore fcking Sabina's characterization, and Sabina is annoying. She's freaking Forerunner combined with Superboy-Prime.
Look at all the other reinventions and legacy heroes and reboots that have come up since OYL. The Atom, Blue Beetle, Booster Gold, Dr. Fate, the Spectre, the Question, the GL Corps, so on and so forth. Love 'em or hate 'em, you could cite incredibly detailed takes on any one of them outlining explicit drives and turning points and quirks and conflicts. And with Freddy? He's stoic. He's doing some trials to get his powers and things are happening to him. The end.