Transformers The User Review Thread [SPOILERS IN ABUNDANCE!]

Rate the film one-to-ten.

  • 10

  • 9

  • 8

  • 7

  • 6

  • 5

  • 4

  • 3

  • 2

  • 1


Results are only viewable after voting.
just came back from my 2nd time. i think it's even better since i knew what to look for. there were a few things i missed in my first viewing that i understood better watching the movie just now. the audience was much better too. my first time was opening night with a half full theater but tonight was PACKED and everyone seemed to enjoy the movie. i went with a buddy of mine and his girl. his girl used to watch the cartoons only because her brother was a huge fan and she was skeptical about how the movie was turned out but in her own words she was "pleasantly surprised" because "it was f***ing awesome!"

i saw more flaws this time around but i also enjoyed it more. i hope Prime gets to whoop more ass in the sequel!!
 
Saw it for the third time and noticed one very neat inside reference- litterally... inside of Bumblebee is a Bumblee Car Air Freshener! Lol. :up:

I don't know, maybe I just didn't see it the first or second time through but it really hit me while watching it the third time through.

And I still think I might see this film a total of 6 or more times in theaters! I'm seriously addicted to it.
 
My dad couldn't stop laughing at what the air freshener said. I loved the little things in this film, like the running gag with his "treasure chest."
 
Saw it for the third time and noticed one very neat inside reference- litterally... inside of Bumblebee is a Bumblee Car Air Freshener! Lol. :up:

I don't know, maybe I just didn't see it the first or second time through but it really hit me while watching it the third time through.

And I still think I might see this film a total of 6 or more times in theaters! I'm seriously addicted to it.

I KNOW WHAT YOU MEAN, I SAW IT TODAY FOR THE THIRD TIME ALSO, AND I STILL WANNA SEE IT AGAIN!!!:cool::up: IT'S BECOME ONE OF MY FAVORITE MOVIES OF ALL TIME AND COMING FROM A BIG MOVIE BUFF LIKE MYSELF, THAT'S SAYING ALLOT!!!:o;):D:up:
 
Saw it for the third time and noticed one very neat inside reference- litterally... inside of Bumblebee is a Bumblee Car Air Freshener! Lol. :up:

I don't know, maybe I just didn't see it the first or second time through but it really hit me while watching it the third time through.

And I still think I might see this film a total of 6 or more times in theaters! I'm seriously addicted to it.

(GROUCHY SMURF VOICE)I HATE DOUBLE POSTS:cmad: :cmad: :cmad:
 
Transformers review

To be 100% honest about this film, I'll first get out of the way my major skepticism as to whether this film would be good. I'll freely admit that I still don't like the designs or the Allspark. But my mom knows I'm a huge Transformers fan and gave me the gentle push to go see this movie. And frankly...I'm very glad I got dragged by both ankles to go see this movie. I've noticed a lot of critics are giving this film low scores based on the lack of familiarity, but if there's one thing I want to impress upon other people it's this- don't let the appearances be your determining factor as to whether you get enjoyment from this movie. By the time Peter Cullen starts getting some good dialogue to work with he could be pink with flower patterns and I'd have the feeling you wouldn't care much about it.

Now where do I start on this behemoth...? The film starts off with the Allspark being introduced just before the title sequence, giving Cullen a good opportunity to narrate its plot purpose (and if there's a good idea to be had, starting the film with Prime's voice is one of them). This film also proves to have a great sense of pace- while the Qatar attack by Blackout is awesome, it's just the mint on top of your visual dessert. While the human focus irks me a bit, I also liked the fact that this film doesn't portray the army as just one giant "bad guy" filled with people who deserve what's coming to them. There's good characters who just want to go about their lives and the secret ops men in the shadows mixed into the film to give two sides to the same coin. I've heard complaints about the editing on this film as well as being abrupt and shoddy...now, come on. I consider myself as intellectual as anyone else, but you have to be really snooty to say that films like SM3 or POTC3 did it better. It's the usual Bay movie, but it's also the most cohesive.

The focus on Sam was well worth it in my estimation. Shia LaBeouf is easily the best actor in the film, combining the comedic qualities of a boy with raging hormones that we can identify with and a streak of gumption that allows him to rise to the occasion. The film's introduction of Megatron and Sam's eBay account is a bit weak, but the latter comes up at the most hilarious times to give the audience a good laugh. As anyone could guess, Bumblebee is also introduced with his own brand of comedy in the film, a success at capturing the Herbie feel without making feel too campy or overused. This whole beginning feels like one big melting pot with these two in particular. The Batman-esque sequence with Bumblebee is balanced out with the hilarity of what Sam expects to be his final moments, and the same formula could be said of many parts in this film. While Megan Fox's Mikaela seems a bit thin in the material department her addition to the love aspect is also one to be praised. Unlike the other romance plots this summer, she makes the female focus feel relatable rather than irritating...and, truth be told, we can all tell why Sam gets tongue-tied around her.

The introduction of Frenzy is also one where I was glad to be wrong. They played up the comedy just a tad over my preference, but he plays the part of the conniving little Trojan horse that Rumble did in the animation and offers an offbeat look at the marauding Decepticons to give them a more multi-faceted approach. It balances out well with Barricade, who (while certainly the ferocious warrior we expect him to be) has his own unintended hilarity. It was a bit disappointing to see that Bumblebee takes him out in such a vague fashion, but Bay doesn't disappoint with the action in this film- by the time you're done, you'll feel less like it was a disappointment and more like it was a teaser for what's to come. I wasn't really feeling the notion that the Cybertronians could just up and transform into anything that took their fancy like how Frenzy did, yet it's hard to call it a complaint when a memorable moment like Bumblebee's conversion into a new-age Camaro is attached to it. The Autobots in particular were excellently realized on the big screen- their arrival is given a genuinely beautiful score and their introductions are very solid (with the awesomeness Prime brings to the screen even with those pseudo-lips and Ratchet's side comment). This movie does a great job of mixing in the epic nature of the series with the changes of the modern age. It also doesn't feel like Bay's forcing in the emotional moments- Prime doesn't lose his noble qualities and Bumblebee's Sector 7 subplot gels with later events.

As someone who wishes he were on the East Coast, it brought a touch of irony to see the Hoover Dam become such a focal point to the plot. That aside, Prime's speech about humanity and the sacrifices it takes to keep them from eradication made me feel like I was watching the series all over again. You want classic Prime? You get Optimus at his best. That's a good tradeoff if I ever heard of one. Here's one thing that really puzzled me, though- if mass conversion was considered silly, why's the Allspark given a pass? Anyways, the Sector 7 segment worked very well. The transformation of technology wasn't too out there, and I'm glad Bumblebee wasn't portrayed less as a faithful servant to Sam and more as his counterpart after all the torture he had to endure. I should also make mention that the movie's changes to the Decepticons is not nearly as horrendous as I once thought. Starscream sounds like Starscream, and both Megatron and himself are treated with care towards their respective rivalry. Weaving's performance is about as good as it gets once our silver menace opens his optics. Hats off to you if you so much as care by the film's end as to how their visuals panned out. My sole complaint is that the banter didn't get extended, but as a fan it's cool enough to see those two carrying on their eternal feud.

The last portion of the film is when things get kicked up a notch so far it breaks the barometer. While Bonecrusher felt a bit throwaway, the action feels well-paced and exactly what I expected from Bay...heck, I'll go as far as to say he exceeded expectations. You have to be pretty flaccid to say that the fights don't border between "orgasmic" and "awesome." The Decepticons rallying together is an awesome moment, and Frenzy's death is also worth a chuckle without the sequence feeling like he's the side order to the main menu. In fact, all of the deaths feel systematic without the bitter aftertaste of incompletion. While it does become clashing scrap metal in some portions, I dare any fellow fan to tell me with a straight face that it wasn't awesome to see Megs and Prime going at it with their lines giving a tip of the hat to the 80's film. Best part of the movie, though? Starscream taking on the F-22 Raptors made the movie for me. All of that "more than meets the eye" could have been left at the wayside if only because this one sequence shows how seamlessly integrated into the real world a Transformer can be. The ending isn't what I call memorable, but that Prime was willing to die for the cause shows that this isn't the usual Bay film where the last few minutes means that the plot gets thrown by the trash. And how can you say no to Optimus giving his final speech to an instrumental version of What I've Done?

All in all, I can compact my whole family's sentiment towards this movie in one phrase- bring on the sequel. The final scene with Starscream only compounds that feeling. Bay proved to me through this film that one man really can be redeemed for his past fumbles in the span of 2 hours. If I had to offer some constructive criticism? Three things. The first is that the lubrication jokes felt like the humor was going to far. The latter two deal with Jazz. While I feel that the ethnicity of Jazz was kept in his tone, they took the dialogue to the point where it edged into the "token black guy" stereotype for me. The second is that his death and Prime's reaction felt rather weak. If I was friends with a guy for ages I would probably be more choked up seeing him divided by the waist than Prime was. That said, I hope the sequel rumors prove true in regards to him.

My final grade is an all-around A/ 90%. This film has its flaws, but what film doesn't? My suggestion- don't drink too much soda at the screening so you can sit through the whole film. And for those of you who still think this may not be up your alley if you're a fan? You're hearing right from the mouth of a former "Negatron" that this movie's flaws are miniscule in the face of the overall experience. I haven't had this much fun at the movies in some time, and Bay's Transformers made my summer get a jolt of excitement from head to toe.

-The Chibi Kiriyama
bump!!
 
imagepudv6alf7.jpg

imageangl2qej6.jpg
 
Hah I'll bee buying one of those if I see one, classy.
 
Transformers review

To be 100% honest about this film, I'll first get out of the way my major skepticism as to whether this film would be good. I'll freely admit that I still don't like the designs or the Allspark. But my mom knows I'm a huge Transformers fan and gave me the gentle push to go see this movie. And frankly...I'm very glad I got dragged by both ankles to go see this movie. I've noticed a lot of critics are giving this film low scores based on the lack of familiarity, but if there's one thing I want to impress upon other people it's this- don't let the appearances be your determining factor as to whether you get enjoyment from this movie. By the time Peter Cullen starts getting some good dialogue to work with he could be pink with flower patterns and I'd have the feeling you wouldn't care much about it.

Now where do I start on this behemoth...? The film starts off with the Allspark being introduced just before the title sequence, giving Cullen a good opportunity to narrate its plot purpose (and if there's a good idea to be had, starting the film with Prime's voice is one of them). This film also proves to have a great sense of pace- while the Qatar attack by Blackout is awesome, it's just the mint on top of your visual dessert. While the human focus irks me a bit, I also liked the fact that this film doesn't portray the army as just one giant "bad guy" filled with people who deserve what's coming to them. There's good characters who just want to go about their lives and the secret ops men in the shadows mixed into the film to give two sides to the same coin. I've heard complaints about the editing on this film as well as being abrupt and shoddy...now, come on. I consider myself as intellectual as anyone else, but you have to be really snooty to say that films like SM3 or POTC3 did it better. It's the usual Bay movie, but it's also the most cohesive.

The focus on Sam was well worth it in my estimation. Shia LaBeouf is easily the best actor in the film, combining the comedic qualities of a boy with raging hormones that we can identify with and a streak of gumption that allows him to rise to the occasion. The film's introduction of Megatron and Sam's eBay account is a bit weak, but the latter comes up at the most hilarious times to give the audience a good laugh. As anyone could guess, Bumblebee is also introduced with his own brand of comedy in the film, a success at capturing the Herbie feel without making feel too campy or overused. This whole beginning feels like one big melting pot with these two in particular. The Batman-esque sequence with Bumblebee is balanced out with the hilarity of what Sam expects to be his final moments, and the same formula could be said of many parts in this film. While Megan Fox's Mikaela seems a bit thin in the material department her addition to the love aspect is also one to be praised. Unlike the other romance plots this summer, she makes the female focus feel relatable rather than irritating...and, truth be told, we can all tell why Sam gets tongue-tied around her.

The introduction of Frenzy is also one where I was glad to be wrong. They played up the comedy just a tad over my preference, but he plays the part of the conniving little Trojan horse that Rumble did in the animation and offers an offbeat look at the marauding Decepticons to give them a more multi-faceted approach. It balances out well with Barricade, who (while certainly the ferocious warrior we expect him to be) has his own unintended hilarity. It was a bit disappointing to see that Bumblebee takes him out in such a vague fashion, but Bay doesn't disappoint with the action in this film- by the time you're done, you'll feel less like it was a disappointment and more like it was a teaser for what's to come. I wasn't really feeling the notion that the Cybertronians could just up and transform into anything that took their fancy like how Frenzy did, yet it's hard to call it a complaint when a memorable moment like Bumblebee's conversion into a new-age Camaro is attached to it. The Autobots in particular were excellently realized on the big screen- their arrival is given a genuinely beautiful score and their introductions are very solid (with the awesomeness Prime brings to the screen even with those pseudo-lips and Ratchet's side comment). This movie does a great job of mixing in the epic nature of the series with the changes of the modern age. It also doesn't feel like Bay's forcing in the emotional moments- Prime doesn't lose his noble qualities and Bumblebee's Sector 7 subplot gels with later events.

As someone who wishes he were on the East Coast, it brought a touch of irony to see the Hoover Dam become such a focal point to the plot. That aside, Prime's speech about humanity and the sacrifices it takes to keep them from eradication made me feel like I was watching the series all over again. You want classic Prime? You get Optimus at his best. That's a good tradeoff if I ever heard of one. Here's one thing that really puzzled me, though- if mass conversion was considered silly, why's the Allspark given a pass? Anyways, the Sector 7 segment worked very well. The transformation of technology wasn't too out there, and I'm glad Bumblebee wasn't portrayed less as a faithful servant to Sam and more as his counterpart after all the torture he had to endure. I should also make mention that the movie's changes to the Decepticons is not nearly as horrendous as I once thought. Starscream sounds like Starscream, and both Megatron and himself are treated with care towards their respective rivalry. Weaving's performance is about as good as it gets once our silver menace opens his optics. Hats off to you if you so much as care by the film's end as to how their visuals panned out. My sole complaint is that the banter didn't get extended, but as a fan it's cool enough to see those two carrying on their eternal feud.

The last portion of the film is when things get kicked up a notch so far it breaks the barometer. While Bonecrusher felt a bit throwaway, the action feels well-paced and exactly what I expected from Bay...heck, I'll go as far as to say he exceeded expectations. You have to be pretty flaccid to say that the fights don't border between "orgasmic" and "awesome." The Decepticons rallying together is an awesome moment, and Frenzy's death is also worth a chuckle without the sequence feeling like he's the side order to the main menu. In fact, all of the deaths feel systematic without the bitter aftertaste of incompletion. While it does become clashing scrap metal in some portions, I dare any fellow fan to tell me with a straight face that it wasn't awesome to see Megs and Prime going at it with their lines giving a tip of the hat to the 80's film. Best part of the movie, though? Starscream taking on the F-22 Raptors made the movie for me. All of that "more than meets the eye" could have been left at the wayside if only because this one sequence shows how seamlessly integrated into the real world a Transformer can be. The ending isn't what I call memorable, but that Prime was willing to die for the cause shows that this isn't the usual Bay film where the last few minutes means that the plot gets thrown by the trash. And how can you say no to Optimus giving his final speech to an instrumental version of What I've Done?

All in all, I can compact my whole family's sentiment towards this movie in one phrase- bring on the sequel. The final scene with Starscream only compounds that feeling. Bay proved to me through this film that one man really can be redeemed for his past fumbles in the span of 2 hours. If I had to offer some constructive criticism? Three things. The first is that the lubrication jokes felt like the humor was going to far. The latter two deal with Jazz. While I feel that the ethnicity of Jazz was kept in his tone, they took the dialogue to the point where it edged into the "token black guy" stereotype for me. The second is that his death and Prime's reaction felt rather weak. If I was friends with a guy for ages I would probably be more choked up seeing him divided by the waist than Prime was. That said, I hope the sequel rumors prove true in regards to him.

My final grade is an all-around A/ 90%. This film has its flaws, but what film doesn't? My suggestion- don't drink too much soda at the screening so you can sit through the whole film. And for those of you who still think this may not be up your alley if you're a fan? You're hearing right from the mouth of a former "Negatron" that this movie's flaws are miniscule in the face of the overall experience. I haven't had this much fun at the movies in some time, and Bay's Transformers made my summer get a jolt of excitement from head to toe.

-The Chibi Kiriyama

VERY well written review Chibi. You probably write quite often...this sounds VERY professional.

But I don't agree with a lot of it. I think I lean more toward Ragdus's side where I like it moreso because of my attachment to Transformers. I think I would be too critical if I weren't a fan. I do want to watch it again to give it another chance...but as of now...I just like the movie. Not love it.
 
6/10.

Awesome action, cool score, bunch of truly funny moments, but an overall laughable rendition of an epic struggle/war that spawned over millions of years.

Only scene that somewhat conveyed the notion of epic was the autobots' arrival and that's about it.
 
6/10.

Awesome action, cool score, bunch of truly funny moments, but an overall laughable rendition of an epic struggle/war that spawned over millions of years.

Only scene that somewhat conveyed the notion of epic was the autobots' arrival and that's about it.

Hhahahaha...

Have you even seen the old-school transformers cartoons recently, if anything, it felt like they were taking themselves too seriously. I thought it was appropriate. but to each his own.
 
This movie was amazing!! I was very impressed with the action and I loved the score. I laughed really hard when the huge black guy freaked out when the cops came in the house and he jumped through the glass door lol! It was kind of a random/unnecessary scene and thats why it was so funny.
anyways its a great film and I can't wait to see it again. :trans:
 
BTW, did any of your theaters give out the Transformers Prequel Movie Comic by Target? It was pretty good actually! Just wondering if any of you got one
 
All I got was a long line and a 30 minute wait to get into the screening. :csad:
 
I really am sad to say that Transformers was a misfire. I was looking forward to this film and was disappointed by this unsatisfying and incredibly shallow movie. It’s the movie equivalent of cotton candy. It’s large, bright and appears full until you go to take a bite and it disappears. It’s all fluff delivering a soulless, babbling film. Most of the cool special effects are negated by presenting them with the jarring, shaky camera style. Since everything on screen doesn’t read true, I guess Bay decided to jolt the viewer and to try and fool the eye by shaking everything up on many of the action sequences. My eye isn’t so easily fooled and the jumbled mess of action gets washed away in the nauseating confusion. You expected plot stupidity and flaws in logic everywhere but you also expected those ridiculous flaws to be overcome by fun action and explosions. Sadly, that’s not the case with Transformers. There’s not one satisfying robot brawl that was not ruined by the shaky zoom of the camera. The Megatron Vs Optimus fight was a useless garble that looked like an erector set accident. The acting was beyond horrible (Megan Fox may be a cute little girl but she sure can’t act) and the plot was awful. Transformers doesn’t have much going for it, unfortunately.

4/10 at best. Sorry.
 
Why is it that everyone jumps to Megan Fox when they talk about bad acting? I mean, we all knew she was there for the eye candy but I actually was surprised that she did a decent job. And even then, she wasn't the worst actor in this movie.
 
Megan Fox was a good actress to me, and that's considering that after the sneak preview clip of the movie I didn't expect her to do much in this film acting-wise.

I don't know. Maybe it's because my expectations were low to begin with?
 
Megan Fox was a good actress to me, and that's considering that after the sneak preview clip of the movie I didn't expect her to do much in this film acting-wise.

I don't know. Maybe it's because my expectations were low to begin with?

It's just weird. It's like people go out of their way to mention her in the bad acting department like if they expected an Oscar nomination to come out of this. She's a mediocre actress who is hot. What more do you want from the poor poor, hot, very hot, smoking....um where was I?:huh:
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,377
Messages
22,094,201
Members
45,889
Latest member
Starman68
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"