Thnx 4 the find!! Wow I'm really on the fence w/both scripts and Singer's X1
I do agree that Chabon's cast does show the diff. persona's of the X-Men, which were not shown in X1-3 the thing is how would they all got character development? I like how Jubilee/Logan were both part of the story, but Magneto is important to the X-Men, so he should have been included...changing Logan's origins would've had the fan boys pissed!! (LOL) He is a product of Weapon X!!!! now if he included Weapon X and Jubes father was part of it then I guess that would've been coo...
In the Solomon script I liked the origin scenes, but I think it would've been one 2 many...this script is similar to Singer's X1, but I like how Singers version focused on Rogue/Logan and Solomon's script seemed liked it would have been all about Logan(which was no diff. from the 3 films we got). Other than that we got Blob, Beast doing his science thang, human/mutant relations and what Rogue should have been...
Both versions are good, but I think Chabon's script would have been a live version of TAS...I like how in Singer's version the team started out small and in time grew I actually liked Jubes, Kitty, Bobby, etc as students and in X2 intro. Nightcrawler, Pyro going 2 his dark side...
I think Chabon's script would have worked well w/Singers X2 if he changed the League of Gentlemen to Weapon X....but it looks like we would've got kick a$$ X-Men films...
