Yeah, same members. Sure, there might be a few guys like me that just came in from lurking around for months, years, but it's pretty much the same old stuff.
The discussions, while interesting and fun, haven't really evolved into anything mind blowing though. It basically "I like this, here's why", "I don't like this, here's why", "gonna make a poll now that will be lost in the boards in a few weeks".
It's certainly not as insane as it was with a bunch of rude, crazy members like it was in 2011 with the "hey guys, I just saw this trailer at the theater I work at, here's what happened, here's a picture of a family that was there". Those times where there were hundreds and hundreds of people in one section with the threads rapidly dying and being created by the thread manager? Those days are gone.