I Am The Knight
Voilá!
- Joined
- May 10, 2005
- Messages
- 24,907
- Reaction score
- 3,613
- Points
- 103
I wanted Depp for Joker. That was some time ago.....

ChrisBaleBatman said:I think he'd had been cool, but what turns me off about him is that he's such a power house. I mean, Lots of people will need to be told that Ldeger was "one of the dudes in Brokeback Mountain". But, Depp? That man is known throughout the entire universe......I belive he's got 3 solar systems named after him. As well as EVERY woman wanting to have his children, and EVERY man wanting to be him.....I dunno, the dude is just too huge a name for a role that will only be 2nd to Batman/ Bale. You risk getting hit with TONS of criticism if you do it right, by having Batman being the lead character.....and not having the Joker run the film (again..).
That'd be my only gripe with Depp as the Joker.
ChrisBaleBatman said:I like Escalation. It rings from the ending to the first one.
Naming it like a graphic novel would be bad, unless it's BATMAN YEAR ONE......but, who knows.
Batman II sounds like a cop out, and wouldn't exactly ring well with Batman Begins already out. I mean, I think if they were going to do that, they would have left Begins out of the title. So, I think we're not getting any numbers b/c of that.
What if you cast him as Dent?
Agreed.....it doesn't seems as though it would run well with it now..
I hate the names this movies are set up for. It's almost as annoying as seeing Begins and Returns not making more money at the B.O.
I Am The Knight said:Problem is that general audiences get confused with titles, and WB will probably want something that sounds ''cool'' against Batman. Let's drop the ''Batman Does Something'' titles and go a bit more Bond in the way the films are named.
ChrisBaleBatman said:Well, that's the thing about Depp. I am convinced the man can BECOME any role, if he's got the right person to ase it off. And, he does that perfectly. I am convinced he could pull of the Joker and pull off Dent/ Two-Face.
But, raybia.....the thing I loved about Batman Begins, was that the movie was all about Bruce Wayne/ Batman. He was the center piece, and he was the main character. Everyone else was secondary, and that's the way it should be.
But, if you add Depp. I mean, mother****ing Depp? Damn, that'd be a huge draw.....and would create criticism b/c if you have Depp, you'll NEED to give him a huge part in the film. He's a heavy hitter, people go to see HIM. Not to see some of him. So, that could create horrible word of mouth, that there wasn't enough Depp.....or that they didn't let Depp act, or let Depp shine. Tons of that.
And, if they give in and give him the screentime...we get another BATMAN 89 film, which is a showcase of the Joker. I just don't want that. I want Bale to be the top dog, the man that carries the film because he's the man playing the Batman. I feel that with Depp, and he's a fantastic actor, he's such a powerhouse....it would change things too much.
But, I get you man. I do, the guy is an incredible actor.
ChrisBaleBatman said:Well, doesn't the Bond films have 007: ***title***?
ChrisBaleBatman said:Didn't they BOTH make money though? I mean, Begins surprised people with it's numbers I think.....and Batman Returns was good enough that it got another film.
Do they? I'm not sure
ChrisBaleBatman said:Nah, don't worry about it. I mean, Depp is a great actor. I think if cirumstances were different, he'd get the role. But, the sad thing is that it's not about his abilities, it's about the toher stuff, ya know? I guess Hollywood has a way of doing that, making things so complicated.
The thing about Bale is that he seems to REFUSE to cash in on anything. The man could probably choose some huge budget film to make, and cash in the bucks. But, he sticks to his Indie roots. I totally respect the dude for that. He seems to keep himself under the radar by choosing deeper, lower-key roles.
And yeah, your right....I think Bale will only get better as the Batman/Bruce Wayne. And, it'd be best to keep him in the forefront of it and keep the focus on him.
Voice of reason, eh? I guess I can try out being a Hostage negotiator. I always wanted to do that.....