A friendly reminder to our users, please make sure your account is safe. Make sure you update your password and have an active email address to recover or change your password.
I probably am being unfair--they probably did as good a job as they could with all the material. I did like the expanded fight, but Harry's verbal smackdown of Voldemort isn't there and that for me was the climax of the entire series! Harry strips Voldemort of his name, his mystery, and his ego. He morally triumphs over the dark lord without having to raise a wand, if I remember right, especially since he also gives Voldemort a chance to repent. And he lets Voldemort know that Snape was disloyal to him. Harry destroys Voldemort there without touching him.
Black Moon
That's nice and all and works for the book, but you do realize, it's just them circling eachother with a lot of dialogue. What a bore to watch on film.
Kind of like how Batman and the Joker just sitting and talking to each other across the table is a bore? t:
Not to single you out personally, but I never understood the "bore" argument. I also never understood the idea that having some streamlined form of their conversation negates any extension of the battle that may precede it (not saying you personally think this). By all means, I wanted and loved the extended fight, and I'm not crying over lost moments. It's just that I can't for the life of me figure out why some think that Harry and Voldemort, [BLACKOUT]both mortal,[/BLACKOUT] circling each other in front of staff and students in the ruins of Hogwarts as the sun cinematically threatens to rise in the background, all leading up to the moment after 10 years...is boring.
But that's just me I guess. In my mind, I always envisioned such rich cinematic potential for the moment, including the previously mentioned looming sunrise, the tension and electricity in the air, and the admiring eyes of all that Harry [BLACKOUT]died to protect.[/BLACKOUT]
Having said all that, I did like what they did in the film.
The dialogue in the book from what I remember would have been too long for a movie. They could have shortened it, but from what I remember, it was more about how Voldemort will never experience love and everything and blah blah blah what has been brought up in the films already. We as the audience already know the subtext of everything at this point. Batman and the Joker had them sitting at a table with Joker doing most of the talking. In a completely different film and in a completely different context.
I bought this with Zazie dans le metro recently. Haven't seen both, but I have faith in Malle.