Which is The BEST X-Men movie ?

[Supreme Power]

Haha! This dude thinks X3 isn't a piece of garbage! Hilarious!

Welcome to the world of opinion, moron.

A bit rude there. I think you would find most don't think it's a piece of garbage just because cyclopes dies.

Although I would of preferred him not to.

 

[tzarinna]

I forgot that it was multiple choise, but it would have gone
1. X3
2. X2
3. X1

 

[Sparta*]

As movies

1. X2
2. X3
3. X1

As successful adaptations

1. X2
2. X1
3. X3

 

[Cyclops]

A bit rude there. I think you would find most don't think it's a piece of garbage just because cyclopes dies.

Although I would of preferred him not to.

Oh, my opinions on it run far deeper than Cyclops's fate.

But that's not the point I'm making. The point I'm making is that opinion is entirely subjective, so if you mock someone for not sharing your opinion, you are opening yourself right up to turnabout, which is fair play.

 

[ShakiraRocks]

By story/plot

X2
X-men 3
X-men

By character development

X2
X-men
X-men 3

By Action and Fun

X-men 3
X2
x-men

Overall Favorite

X2
X-men 3
X-men (almost tied with X3, i liked both of them alot for different reasons)

 

[windriderx]

x3 is the best

 

[jusblaze21]

A bit rude there. I think you would find most don't think it's a piece of garbage just because cyclopes dies.

Although I would of preferred him not to.

This movie had more problems than cyke's death. And this is like the third time I've seen a Cyke fan, who did'nt like the movie basically being called biased because Cyke died. I enjoyed X2 and Cyclops got the shaft in that too.

 

[Supreme Power]

This movie had more problems than cyke's death. And this is like the third time I've seen a Cyke fan, who did'nt like the movie basically being called biased because Cyke died. I enjoyed X2 and Cyclops got the shaft in that too.

I'm actually a Cyke fan also, and the reason I don't go to the cyke thread alot anymore is because a lot of the cyke fans are biased. Some don't like the movie in any way just because he dies, and talk trash to any who do.

I didn't want him to die, and I think that wasn't a good choice for this movie, but that doesn't ruin it for me.

 

[CapBeerCino]

#1 x-men united.

#2 x-men.

 

[windriderx]

I'm actually a Cyke fan also, and the reason I don't go to the cyke thread alot anymore is because a lot of the cyke fans are biased. Some don't like the movie in any way just because he dies, and talk trash to any who do.

I didn't want him to die, and I think that wasn't a good choice for this movie, but that doesn't ruin it for me.

thank you there are sane cyclops fans out there instead the the whiny little babies ruining every thread on the forums because scott is gone. its refreshing to read a calm, collected opinion instead of reading whining tantrums of rage!!!!! thank you for this post!!!! and the one about yours!

 

[jusblaze21]

I'm actually a Cyke fan also, and the reason I don't go to the cyke thread alot anymore is because a lot of the cyke fans are biased. Some don't like the movie in any way just because he dies, and talk trash to any who do.

I didn't want him to die, and I think that wasn't a good choice for this movie, but that doesn't ruin it for me.

Cyke's death did'nt ruin the movie for me either, I knew he was going to die before viewing the film, Although I think Cyclops still should of been the one to save Jean. The bad Dialouge, the lack of character developed, and how scences were rushed, Ect. Ruined the film for me.

 

[*xmenfan*]

I would rank them as...

X2
X1




X3

 

[theJust]

haha the posters dont help the decision.

but yea by far the last stand, cause its comic-like, not realistic.

 

[spider-neil]

x3 is taking a beating with the critics but I couldn't care LESS I thought it was fantastic and will definaltely be seeing it again

tie - x2/x3
x1

x1/x2 character developement
x3 all out action LOVED IT

they set the pace for the first two movies and then the pay off is the action in the third, I'm kinda hoping they do the same with spider-man 3

 

[Nathan]

1. X2
2. X1
3. X3

 

[pt_photo_inc]

X2
X1

and there was no X3 just some crap fest with similar characters

 

[Sparta*]

X2
X1

and there was no X3 just some crap fest with similar characters

^ That pretty much sums it up

 

[Pingo]

1, X1
2, X3
3, X2

 

[psycho]

1) X2
2) X-men: The Last Stand
3) X-men

 

[Steelsheen]

X1 and X2 are almost on equal footing. i'll give X1 the edge since they had a good combination of character development/ introduction with action and eye-candy.

X3 is the opposite of what i said above.

 

[Steelsheen]

Ok my fellow X-fans, The time has come to choose Which was either your Favorite or BEST X-Men flim.

X-MEN {2000}

btw, this is still the best poster.

 

[The Ones]

tie: X2-X3

In my opinion X-1 and X-2 laid the ground work and character deveolpment already in place for X-3 to be the climax between Mutant vs Humans. I think X-3 was the best in its own way because we all know the character's and care about them.

But theres something about X-2 that sets it apart from the trilogy. Due to these i think X-2 and X-3 tie for best

 

[Jakomus]

haha! This dude thinks X1 is better than X3! Hilarious!

No, what IS hilarious is that you think X-Men 3 is any good at all!

Not so fun when it's your opinion being made fun of, is it?

 

[eat aliens]

X2 10/10
X-men 9/10
X-men: TLS 7.5/10

 

[grey_jeanie]

The x-men poster is actaully wicked. Best of all of them.