It is now the end of May, and at the bottom of the ocean, Miss Martian has been the captive of Black Manta attempting to psychically repair the damage done to Kaldur at the end of "BEFORE THE DAWN" for roughly a month and a half. With Deathstroke still keeping his watchful (and only) eye on the situation, things become dire when Black Manta imposes a 24 hour deadline on Megan's efforts. While sapped of most of her powers via those pesky "inhibitor collars" that the X-Men seem to always get saddled with by enemies, our heroes have a secret of their own; Kaldur's mind has been fully restored, and he was merely biding his time to plan a fair escape for Megan alongside Tigress/Artemis. Any sign of any errors or mistakes or "Kaldur turning bad for real" is non existent; with Artemis' help it seems everything was successful. All they lacked was opportunity, which thanks to Artemis' vengeful criminal relatives, they happen to get. Sure, capitalizing on circumstances when planning fails may not always be the stuff of masterminds, but it's served James Bond well for over 50 years.
The B-plot of the episode picks up where "WAR" left off, although some time after with Blue Beetle and Green Beetle having some time to "clean up". The Justice League (or what is left of them) are occupying the Warworld, and Blue Beetle makes up some alibi about boom tubes which has Captain Atom convinced. Having been trained by the "world's greatest detective", Nightwing decides to investigate things himself and he wanders upon the site of the last scene of "WAR". We see him gather evidence and it was nice that this show expected its audience to follow along without narration or flashbacks, or "smell-o-vision" which used to happen all the time with Logan in "WOLVERINE & THE X-MEN" that drove me bonkers. The irony is while Nightwing had enough evidence that he was surely doubting Blue Beetle's explanation of the events, it was the Reach overplaying their hand declaring him their national hero on TV which seemed to clinch it for the boy wonder's mind. Jesse McCartney has usually been good in the role but I thought he portrayed some good tones here, vowing to get to the bottom of this and avenge his team.
But the real meat of the episode was seeing the situation devolve and get hot in Black Manta's sub between the heroes, Manta's forces and Sportsmaster and Cheshire. While Cheshire does seem to genuinely want to avenge her sister (despite often being her rival or enemy), Sportsmaster is just there to avenge his reputation against Black Manta. The rest of the episode sees the two sides complicate each other's plans until Megan attempts some psychic compromise. We get some pretty good fight sequences between Sportsmaster and Black Manta, as well as later between Sportsmaster and Deathstroke. Heck, any episode with Artemis is usually one where one can expect some good storyboards for action. Much like in "FAILSAFE", Kaldur's willingness to endanger his teammates for the sake of a plan only goes so far, but in the end he, Megan and Artemis show that they can think on their feet and compromise. The episode is another one which shows us that not all villains have to be heartless monsters. Black Manta in the end just wanted his son restored to health; he's willing to kidnap and murder (even his own men) to accomplish this, but at the end when he hugs Kaldur it was hard to not feel just a little sorry for how badly Kaldur's playing him. Compare him to Sportsmaster, who still only sees his daughters as extensions or disappointments of his reputation. Deathstroke also reveals that he has more ambitious plans than the blue collar Sportsmaster, intending on getting "a seat at the table" with the Light rather than remain an enforcer forever. Overall Kaldur and Artemis succeed in maintaining their cover, arranging Megan's release as well as preventing Artemis' family from being killed by Manta's forces. It also hit me that Sportsmaster actually does use some lines about sports which could be corny on paper, but Nick Chinlund's delivery makes them sound colder and more chilling. TV.com claims Fred Tatasciore voiced Deathstroke here, which is odd since this series has usually been good about keeping its characters from being recast due to schedule, even some of those who work on other TV shows.
There are of course a lot of upcoming developments. Cheshire tells her mother Paula that Artemis is alive; since she also was shown that Wally was part of this secret, does Cheshire tell Paula that and it gets Paula mad at Wally? We also don't know what happened to Psimon; was he still on the sub or was he returned to Queen Bee's forces when he was struck comatose? His recovery is inevitable and that will put a time limit on this undercover mission. How does Deathstroke intend on moving up; will he capitalize when it comes out that moles breached "The Light" on Black Manta's beat? Does Blue and Green Beetle using boom tubes to make their hostages vanish mean they're in league with Apokolips, or that they just employ some toys that the Light use? And if Arsenal is still hiding on Warworld, what role will he play in "THE HUNT"?
Lots of good vocal performances here, which helps in an episode when most of the dialogue is psychically transmitted. I also wouldn't be surprised if that is a trick to speed up animation production, since mouth movements often take a lot of time. While Nightwing may know who his latest mole is, there isn't much he can do about it, yet. Although we do see some chips in the facade of the enemies. For the moment, "the team" still have their undercover agents in "the Light" and now they even got some assistance out of Sportsmaster and Cheshire. The Reach have overplayed their hand and revealed their mole in the superhero ranks far sooner than Vandal Savage did last season, which may be their undoing. The show has presented three opposing sides, and while the Light and the team would both want the Reach off the planet by now, that's where their mutual agreements end.
It was a bit odd that there seemed to be no public backlash towards the Reach having an alien fleet underwater. There's a lot of ocean on the world but surely someone would have noticed. It was a blatant lie that the Reach were spouting even as Mongul attacked. Perhaps a minor detail, but it did seem strange when the show is also painting the League's credibility as being poor. I imagine Mongul is being stashed where the rest of the kids are, so we may see him again.