About the butler scene

[Vile]

I would learn more toward plot hole because Bottom Line: He tells Harry Norman died by his own hand and unless he was THERE, which he WAS NOT, he couldnt possibly know that. All else is secondary.

 

[Abaddon]

I do think it was a mistake and anyone who is being critical of it will point it out. In fact I think the entire beginning of the third act is rushed. The team up, Venom's first appearance, the butler, the newscasting, etc. It just seemed Sony was saying "we need to cut this down 20 minutes get us to the fight, NOW."

But what fanboys do is discussi t ad nauseum. We all agree it was a bad idea but this thread is hours of people arguing the butler's motivations and his forensic training and whether Harry would have believed him before then and whether the butler knew Harry had gone off the deep end etc, etc.

It's all moot. There is a difference between criticizing and OBSESSING.

it's all criticism, but some people want to make excuses for it when there are none.