Alien 5

[Teelie]

Then we get the middling to low quality AVP movies that took a great concept and **** all over them.

 

[Luigi]

Wish we could have seen Blomkamp's film.

 

[TheVileOne]

Wish we could have seen Blomkamp's film.

I'm not sure if it would've been a good movie, but I don't see how it would've been much worse than the trash we got with Alien Covenant and the ruination of the Xenomorphs.

 

[TheVileOne]

Another Alien directed by Ridley? God yes.

God no. Covenant was terrible Prometheus was disappointing.

 

[Luigi]

I'm not sure if it would've been a good movie, but I don't see how it would've been much worse than the trash we got with Alien Covenant and the ruination of the Xenomorphs.

Aye, I'm having a hard time imagining it being worse than Covenant.

 

[DarkKnight88]

God no. Covenant was terrible Prometheus was disappointing.

He can’t hear you now

 

[Fincher]

I really liked Covenant, although I'll deduct some points if it doesn't get a sequel, because it reads as a two-parter to me. I would like an alternative sequel to Aliens, though.

 

[Iceman]

How many semi-good or better Alien films are there?

 

[Captain Tired]

God no. Covenant was terrible Prometheus was disappointing.

Agreed. Enough out of him already. He's had two movies now to explore his pseudointellectual take on intelligent design in the Alien universe. Enough of David, enough of Ridley Scott. Enough.

 

[Fincher]

How many semi-good or better Alien films are there?

For me, it's Alien, Aliens, and Covenant, although I haven't seen the AvP movies (and don't care to).

 

[Iceman]

For me, it's Alien, Aliens, and Covenant, although I haven't seen the AvP movies (and don't care to).

Thanks. I don’t know for sure if I’ve seen Covenant. Pretty sure I’ve seen everything else, and like the Terminator series, I only really liked the first 2.

 

[Doctor Jones]

I actually like Resurrection. The directing is the only thing I don't like all that much but I like Whedon's script. I'll take it over Alien 3. ****ing hell.

 

[KaijuDude1992]

See I actually like Resurrection as well and I never minded Alien 3, although I get why some people hate it. The first two movies are god tier though, but as much as I do love them I am pretty much done with Ridley Scott directing anymore Alien movies after Covenant. I was one of the few people that defended Prometheus in the beginning too, but he even managed to make that movie worse after how much he crapped all over the Alien mythology in Covenant with the David BS. I don't know if BlomKamp's movie would have been any good, but I at least would have been curious enough to see the end results of it and its hard imaging it being any worse than what we have already gotten.

 

[Captain Tired]

I like Alien 3 a great deal tbh. The first two movies are always described as horror and action, respectively, but to me Alien 3 is a great and underrated tragedy film. A rarity in mainstream blockbuster cinema. It ain't perfect, but it's good and I think it has a great deal of merit to it. I'd much rather watch that and Resurrection (dumb popcorn fun) than either of Ridley Scott's boring latter-day efforts where the Alien universe is concerned.

 

[Doctor Jones]

I can appreciate Alien 3 for craft, it's strong score, casting, and some of its ideas, I just hate how the movie bends over backwards to be like the first movie. The idea that this nightmare will never be over for Ripley is very interesting for a third movie. I like the nihilistic aspect of that. I just wish that wasn't in service of a retread of the first. It's a retraction after the second. I'm not saying go bigger, but the lack of creativity and excuses for why this movie is good gets frustrating when it's so fundamentally half measured. It's why I'm never gonna like the entire movie.

 

[Silvermoth]

It’s a shame they wasted Charlize thereon’s character but oh well. If they made a new one who would be a cast addition that would make you say “oh wow this just got interesting”

 

[SwordOfMorning]

Count me in as one of the five people who think Alien 3 is a way more interesting movie than Aliens. Same with Covenant, even though both are technically way messier.

 

[:eek:]

Walter Hill Talks Scrapped "Alien 5" Script - Dark Horizons