All New, All Different x New 52 - Part 2

[Docker2.0]

Superboy Prime.

 

[random_havoc]

Sins past and superboy punch

 

[hops]

Both Spider-man retcons

 

[Spider-Aziz]

Wolverine Retcons that are not his clones are bones.

Superboy Super Reality Punch

Reality Punching Made Aunt May Immortal!

Logical deduction.

 

[WolfCypher]

The worst retcons are...Sins Past (1-5) & Superboy-Prime Punches Reality (7-2)

Only one DC retcon made it past the preliminaries. Up til the finals, every winning round was exclusively Marvel retcons. In numbers, according to us, Marvel retcons are worse than DC retcons. DC; the company of constant universe reboots, was out retconned numerously by Marvel's sheer stupidity-inducing retconning.


What didn't make the game...

Spoiler

New 52 Wally West

Finale
Sins Past x Superboy-Prime Chris Browns Reality

Vote for the worst!
​

 

[Docker2.0]

Superboy Prime. Utter b.s.

 

[WolfCypher]

Sins Past

 

[Spider-Aziz]

Superboy Prime was a good character they just brought back to let him shatter realities to restore the multiple Earths and be an emo whiney *****e who rips arms off of sockets and then trapped in the speed force with dead speedsters by being mostly pushed in by Impulse, with a little help from Barry Allen.

That crap is worse than 'Goblin f***ed Gwen, she shat his twin children, he told them they are Spider-Man's children, and Spider-Man killed their mom. Peter Parker is a poopyhead too, kill him.'

SUPERBOY PRIME

 

[random_havoc]

Sins past.

What happened to OMD? Did I miss it getting eliminated? I would've thought it would at least make final 2

 

[KevanG]

Prime

I wanted to post a Freddy gif saying "Welcome to Prime Time *****!" But I couldn't find a censored one and I have no idea how to make them.

 

[hops]

Sins past

 

[Duke]

Sins Past

 

[WolfCypher]

SuperPrimePunch was just dumb...
Sins Past offended me. So I stand by my vote.

 

[Spider-Aziz]

Prime

I wanted to post a Freddy gif saying "Welcome to Prime Time *****!" But I couldn't find a censored one and I have no idea how to make them.

 

[Daltonio]

Sins Past. As I said before, worst retcon in the history of retcons. Ever. In the history of the world.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

this really should have came down to OMD and Superboy.. but whatever!
I love Superman dearly but he has had some of the DUMBEST redos ever! freaking making the earth spin backwards , amnesiac kisses, PUNCHING REALITY but that being said they all were kinda of "tongue-in cheek" like not to be taking seriously cause it is a comic but MARVEL with Spider-man has always been about being serious and real ... but then they throw us clones, old ladies who cant die and American heroes being NAZIS( oops that the other guy) and expect us to buy it so...

"SINS"
that is honest to God CREEPY and Stupid as %^&*!! (Plus i am putting OMD in there! which is the absolutely worst vs punching reality) so yeah!!

...and i am so freaking sick of seeing Gwen in the"throes of ecstasy!" in that pic!YUCK!!
and where the hell is Cap Wagner!! he starts this and then bails! thats like asking you to have a party and then leaving you the next day to clean up!

 

[KevanG]

Yaaayy.

 

[Duke]

this really should have came down to OMD and Superboy.. but whatever!
I love Superman dearly but he has had some of the DUMBEST redos ever! freaking making the earth spin backwards , amnesiac kisses, PUNCHING REALITY but that being said they all were kinda of "tongue-in cheek" like not to be taking seriously cause it is a comic but MARVEL with Spider-man has always been about being serious and real ... but then they throw us clones, old ladies who cant die and American heroes being NAZIS( oops that the other guy) and expect us to buy it so...

"SINS"
that is honest to God CREEPY and Stupid as %^&*!! (Plus i am putting OMD in there! which is the absolutely worst vs punching reality) so yeah!!

...and i am so freaking sick of seeing Gwen in the"throes of ecstasy!" in that pic!YUCK!!
and where the hell is Cap Wagner!! he starts this and then bails! thats like asking you to have a party and then leaving you the next day to clean up!

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmm..............BV, the fact Superman actually doing that in one the greatest superhero movies of all-time, is just CLASSIC, COLOSSAL, STUPENDOUS, in short, just AWESOMENESS!!! You should turn in your nerd/superhero card, mister!!!

 

[jokesonm3]

Sins Past

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmm..............BV, the fact Superman actually doing that in one the greatest superhero movies of all-time, is just CLASSIC, COLOSSAL, STUPENDOUS, in short, just AWESOMENESS!!! You should turn in your nerd/superhero card, mister!!!

awwww come on Duke man!! I already had to give up my brother card for that "abba" thing and docker is always saying to turn in my man card when I vote against some chick not THAT CARD TOO! Man and you are right that MOVIE is stupendous colossal GREATNESS but that one brief scene undid the great drama of losi being killed!! Not to mention the catastrophe of wreaking havoc on the earth atmosphere doing that &$)) by supes!

 

[WolfCypher]

The worst retcon? Sins Past (7-3)

Overtime Retcon
Sins Past x One More Day

One More Day was the story where Peter would bargain with the devil to save his fatally wounded aunt. Mephisto would remove the marriage of Peter and Mary Jane from existence. In return, Satan would ensure Aunt May would live.

In a world where Black Panther and Iron Man exist, where Doctor Doom's brilliant mind exist, where Reed Richard has created interdimensional transporters that could fit in the palm of your hand, and his son who can create pocket universes and rewrite the universe, where perfect cloning is possible, time-travel is a Tuesday event, saving an old woman from a bullet wound is impossible. Remember...these people could NOT figure out how to fix a gunshot injury, yet they tried every impossible contingency during Secret Wars 2015.

After the Satan Pact, Peter & Mary Jane were never married, Harry Osborn was suddenly alive again, and a plethora of new characters WE'VE NEVER SEEN BEFORE were suddenly long-time friends of Peter ("Hi! I'm Carlie Cooper! I've been around since after "Kraven's Last Hunt"...I was in the background...") and a sh&% ton of stories no longer made sense anymore, yet still happened...?

For the last time ever, vote for the worst!
​

What didn't make the game...

Spoiler

Catwoman's new origin? She gets pushed out of the window of an office building, falls several stories, and is licked by cats in a alley. In other words, DC takes an origin from a movie from 1991 and makes that Catwoman's origin.

They would later go and retcon that origin. So she has two New 52 origins.

 

[Docker2.0]

One more day. Why would you make a deal with the devil knowing that they never turn out the way you plan??!

 

[Spider-Aziz]

ONE... MORE....FART

Or would you rather say poop?

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

One more day!
It was so so so BAD it's laughable!! Come on!! If he did that ,why didn't he do it for Uncle Ben!! Poor Unc Ben gets no respect! @&$( that story

 

[WolfCypher]

One More Day is the worst.