BvS All Things Batman v Superman: An Open Discussion - - - - - - - - Part 172

[EEK]

I'm just gonna tell myself that Terrio threw out most of Goyer's dialogue because that's what will help me sleep at night.

Lol, come on guys. Goyer is without a doubt a creative force behind MOS who most of the people here claim to love, and is certainly involved with the story direction of where things go from here. So much Goyer hate

 

[WBwins]

I'm just gonna tell myself that Terrio threw out most of Goyer's dialogue because that's what will help me sleep at night.

Eisenberg already kinda confirmed this no worries

 

[Fallen Angel]

I knew Jesse was going to be there. He went thee in 2009 for Zombieland so it's not like he's above going to these things. However, I always knew Amy Adams wasn't going to be there.

It would be funny if she (Amy) did turn up this year seeing as she only started shooting a movie a week ago when the two occasions MOS was there and she was free she didn't turn up.

 

[TheNextNolan22]

Lol, come on guys. Goyer is without a doubt a creative force behind MOS who most of the people here claim to love, and is certainly involved with the story direction of where things go from here. So much Goyer hate

All of it blind.

 

[I SEE SPIDEY]

Anyway I find the script discussion boring and we have already went over it, so I'm moving on.

 

[roach]

Whedon and Zak penn both got writing credits for avengers despite the fact Whedon discarded most of Zaks work.same thing is happening here

Penn got a story by credit
whedon got the written by credit

 

[Chip Chipperson]

Lol, come on guys. Goyer is without a doubt a creative force behind MOS who most of the people here claim to love, and is certainly involved with the story direction of where things go from here. So much Goyer hate

I don't mind Goyer being a creative consultant on the story, my problem with him is his weak dialogue.

But yes, Complete and utter blind hate. Totally unwarranted.

 

[BatmanVSuperman]

Lol, come on guys. Goyer is without a doubt a creative force behind MOS who most of the people here claim to love, and is certainly involved with the story direction of where things go from here. So much Goyer hate

Can you love MOS and dislike Goyer as an entity that hates Martian Manhunter?

 

[roach]

Fake I don't think we are disagreeing on anything because I'm not a blind Goyer hater who believes his script was thrown out. I believe the credit, both men wrote the script. I'm just saying I don't believe Terrio only rewrote a little of it here and there. I think he made a significant contribution to the script.

I could be wrong but those are my thoughts.

The new credit has it written by both of them...that means both have significant contributions to the script

 

[WoodyROM]

I just think it's funny that some of you are arguing the screenwrting process...with a frickin screenwriter.

Roach, I think I found some irony for my logline

 

[EEK]

I don't mind Goyer being a creative consultant on the story, my problem with him is his weak dialogue.

But yes, Complete and utter blind hate. Totally unwarranted.

Agreed on everything in this post. We have people that can not seem to separate emotions from reason. They build up a blind hatred and like children just continue with it, rather than discuss like a grownup. Goyer is hugely responsible for many elements of MOS that fans claim to love. Yet, it is popular to get on board with the hate train. Silliness.

 

[Fallen Angel]

I just think it's funny that some of you are arguing the screenwrting process...with a frickin screenwriter.

Roach, I think I found some irony for my logline

Some on here would argue with the validity of their birth to their own mothers.

 

[roach]

I just think it's funny that some of you are arguing the screenwrting process...with a frickin screenwriter.

Roach, I think I found some irony for my logline

I just hate this fiction we created that WB fired Goyer.

 

[WoodyROM]

Some on here would argue with the validity of their birth to their own mothers.

This is true

 

[DlAMONDZ]

That MM comment he made really rustled a lot of jimmies

People went from disliking his writing to out right hating his guts

 

[DlAMONDZ]

I just hate this fiction we created that WB fired Goyer.

He'll probably get credit for Justice League too. I remember WB hiring him to write it after MOS came out.

 

[BatmanVSuperman]

That MM comment he made really rustled a lot of jimmies

People went from disliking his writing to out right hating his guts

I'm a huge MM fan, so not gonna lie... his comments stung

 

[Sleiek]

Damn, he said something bad about MM?

I really like MM.

 

[Chip Chipperson]

I just hate this fiction we created that WB fired Goyer.

Wouldn't blame it on this board, it was more of a collective effort from everyone on the Internet who saw MOS and didn't like some of what they saw (or in the case of dialogue, heard)

 

[roach]

Agreed on everything in this post. We have people that can not seem to separate emotions from reason. They build up a blind hatred and like children just continue with it, rather than discuss like a grownup. Goyer is hugely responsible for many elements of MOS that fans claim to love. Yet, it is popular to get on board with the hate train. Silliness.

The screenwriting process is large collaborative...especially when writing a big budget movie. It's hard for us as the audience to know what was Goyer's ideas and what was a half baked idea an exec wanted in the film to make him seem like he's doing something. We as screenwriters like to believe all our words are our 100% gold when the reality is it's not. However I'll give the man who created the most emotional scene in a CBM (IMO) "Can't I keep pretending to be your son" a pass for "a boy child".
And really all this screenwriting talks reminds me that I should be writing and not playing around on the inter webs.

 

[I SEE SPIDEY]

The new credit has it written by both of them...that means both have significant contributions to the script

I never said otherwise.

 

[Black Narcissus]

They both wrote it. There. It still doens't change the fact of Batfleck and now Jesse praising him and not once mentioning Goyer, which is cool by me. I can sleep better now.

 

[EEK]

Goyer forming the concept in align with story direction Snyder agrees with, and Terrio throwing in some ideas but also fleshing out the characters within that story seems quite possible.

 

[Black Narcissus]

Damn, he said something bad about MM?

I really like MM.

I wipe my arse with MM.

There. Hate me now.

 

[DlAMONDZ]

Damn, he said something bad about MM?

I really like MM.

He was on some comedy show I remember correctly

That didn't stop fanboys from raging doe. The fact that Cyborg was cast only a couple weeks before made it worse