• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

Bendis, I used to love you

Bullsear

Civilian
Joined
Jul 3, 2003
Messages
399
Reaction score
0
Points
11
Brian Michael Bendis was one of the writers who got me back into comic books. USM was fun to read, he had a neat take on Daredevil, and Powers positively blew me away.
I was reading comics for the first time in the Internet era, so I didn't know how to keep track of which books came out when, but I remember driving the 30 miles to my nearest comic shop every other week, hoping that Bendis' books had come out that week. Weeks there were no Bendis books were weeks my total purchases were around a fourth of normal.
I have defended his creative decisions, his takes on my favorite characters, his storytelling, and even his fast, pithy dialogue on this board and on others, but today is the day I stop.

Today, Bendis' books are flat out boring. Nothing happens, and when something does, it's jammed into either the first or last page. His characters aren't believable. He kills them without fanfare or afterthought. Their dialogue is often not dialogue at all, but extended and juxtaposed monologue.
Worst, he writes with no sense of direction, no purpose.
These principles have become most evident to me in the last 15 issues of USM.
It doesn't seem like it, but that's around a year of uninspired, unentertaining, material, and it's not fun to read.
Bendis has become truly lost.
 
I do so enjoy when the light hits someone and their eyes open. Makes me warm and tingly.
 
He definitely seems like he's in a deep funk. After quitting Daredevil and finishing with House of M, I think he needed a break...but, his current comics show that. Ultimate Spider-Man is the worst I've ever seen it, and it's gone from being one of the best Spider-Man titles to being the absolute worst. (This clone saga makes me rethinking hating The Other so much.) New Avengers is a bit better than I've read lately...but, to me, he could only improve on what's happened in it before. Plus, Civil War is making it more interesting.

I'm hoping this is only because he was facing serious burn out. He needs a fresh Marvel title that he can revamp, or why doesn't Marvel just try out a new character.
 
Sounds like you were only infatuated with Bendis.
 
I want to know what Bendis was high on when he plotted the Ultimate Clone Saga.
 
Cyclops said:
I want to know what Bendis was high on when he plotted the Ultimate Clone Saga.


Mountain Dew and Pixie stix
 
I don't really read that much Bendis anymore since he quit DD. New Avengers has rocked recently though. I don't hate him, he's a good writer. I don't read USM though so I don't really know what you guys are talking about with that.
 
I am dropping USM after this clone saga........I am actually dropping all Ultimate books after thier respective arcs....except maybe Ultimates.


Ultimate Vision #0 was actually the first Ultimate book I didn't buy.
 
Cyclops said:
I want to know what Bendis was high on when he plotted the Ultimate Clone Saga.
probably the same thing he was on when he did ultimate hobgoblin...
 
Bendis is a one trick pony who can only do ONE genre of book well. Sooner everyone realizes this sooner we can get good books back on track.
 
WOLVERINE25TH said:
Bendis is a one trick pony who can only do ONE genre of book well. Sooner everyone realizes this sooner we can get good books back on track.

Been saying that from day one.
 
I liked House of M a lot. I've read the first 13 Ultimate Spider-Man trades and I like them to varying degrees. I'm reading the Daredevil hardcover with "Underboss" and "Out" right now and so far it's great. His Ultimate X-Men arcs were pretty good too.

So I like the Bendis stuff I've read, but I don't think any of it is less than a year old.
 
When people say New Avengers rocks.... are they joking?
What good stories have we even seen come from new avengers?
I mean we got that b-lister Collective story...and saying it was a b-list story is pushing it.
The best story with them wasn't even in their book. And that would be the new thunderbolts vs the new avengers part 1 and 2. But like I said that was in the new thunderbolts comic.
Issue 12 and 13 to be persice.
 
Cyclops said:
I want to know what Bendis was high on when he plotted the Ultimate Clone Saga.

ketamine.jpg
 
Yeah, I buy NA....and if ya pay attention I complain about it REGULARLY. Once CW ends it's most definitely goin' on notice as bein' dropped.
 
WOLVERINE25TH said:
Yeah, I buy NA....and if ya pay attention I complain about it REGULARLY. Once CW ends it's most definitely goin' on notice as bein' dropped.


Thats nice, but youre still adding to its sales, making you slightly hypocritical.
 
Even though I'm not reading any new books from him at the moment,I still consider his DD to be his best cape run,and probably DD's best run

Plus Torso is pretty good so far from what I've read.
 
WOLVERINE25TH said:
Yeah, I buy NA....and if ya pay attention I complain about it REGULARLY. Once CW ends it's most definitely goin' on notice as bein' dropped.
All the CW tie ins are over. So...you can stop buying them now.
But though I'm dissapointed in it so far, #26 with Hawkeyes return seems promising.
 
GNR4Life said:
Even though I'm not reading any new books from him at the moment,I still consider his DD to be his best cape run,and probably DD's best run
Plus Torso is pretty good so far from what I've read.

Blasphemy
 
yup, I'm done too, for all the reasons stated above. His DD will forever be a golden era, and thankfully he left when he did (although I'm personally less than impressed with Brubaker) but everything else, even pPwers, has just been downhill, and it seems evident he puts less aand less thought into his stuff
 
Elijya said:
yup, I'm done too, for all the reasons stated above. His DD will forever be a golden era, and thankfully he left when he did (although I'm personally less than impressed with Brubaker) but everything else, even pPwers, has just been downhill, and it seems evident he puts less aand less thought into his stuff

This is what happens to people who buy their own hype. Ask Oliver Stone, Val Kilmer and David Lynch.
 
We havent had a bona fide Bendis bashing thread in a while.


Personally, I just dont bother reading his stuff anymore and Bendis bashing, just isnt much fun as it was anymore.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"